Closing Chapter

We genuinely love the beauty of your song and the lovely atmosphere you've created. One small thought is that the arrangement feels a little repetitive as the track progresses. Perhaps adding some subtle variations and developments could make the song feel even more engaging. Keep up the beautiful work! Best Regards, Adityaa

Hey, thanks for the submission! This was really beautiful and warm but also a little too romantic for my taste and also I wish the production offered a little more variety. Vocal processing was a nice touch, though. Best!

Hey there , awesome track . Loved the smooth vocal content and catchy melodies . The instrumental also sounds great . But at the moment , I am focusing a bit more on old school 2pac style rap stuff for my violet playlist . Good luck! eager to hear more from you.

This song has a really nice groove and vibe. Easy flow. The back track rhythm is consistent. The Opening chorus hook and the repeat around 1:20 has a vocal that just sounds too processed. It's a bit muddy and wobbly. The chorus seems to come before the verses and at the end the track feels incomplete. Very linear and could use either mor instrumental or a bridge or transition. Consider some adjustments to Vocal Mix & Processing, Frequency Balance and Clarity to capture all the highs, mids and lows. Would you also consider moving the chorus from the intro to after the verses? There's something really strong in the making here! I enjoyed listening. Thank you.

Hi there! We really enjoy your smooth voice sync along with warm piano lead and pleasant beat flow. However your track has a bit slow pace and the tone of your singing feels a bit too sweet & romantic for our taste, which doesn't fit quite nice among other faster melodic tracks with deeper & introspective tone of rnb singing along that we prefer in our 'melodic hip hop & rnb' playlist to be honest, sorry 🙏

The final chapter works really well within the genre; it's intimate and soft, atmospheric. However, I don't find its melancholic and introspective approach convincing, since I lean more towards brighter pieces that inspire romance. So, even though the voices sound talented, I chose to pass. I miss a riskier ending, something out of the ordinary.

Your song has a strong foundation, with a polished sonic identity and a well-structured arrangement that reflects a clear understanding of production. The overall execution is appealing and professionally delivered. Nevertheless, the vocal delivery doesn't quite make the impression I'm seeking from the tracks selected for my playlist at the moment. Despite the positive qualities of the production, I won't be moving forward with this submission.

Hi there Prince Dube, I’m sorry if this felt slightly too harsh but I’ll have to pass on this submission based on the bright and too polished vocals. Sadly, it didn’t align with my preference as I’m focusing more on vocals that have warmth and dry mix. Best wishes!

Lovely dreamy piano parts and vocals in the introduction. I enjoy the fact that there's not rhythmic instrument and that drums enters only at 0:25. However, the beat that enters is quite electronic and I prefer more real drums. I'll pass this time, but I wish you good luck with your release and I hope to hear more music from you.

Hi! Thanks for the submission! I really like your soulful vocals and the lyrics of the tune but for my playlists I prefer a more classic soul and blues with fewer electronic elements. I will listen to more tracks from you to find one that will fit better. Keep it up!

Hello, Prince Dube! Thank you for submitting your track "Closing Chapter"! We appreciate your vocal performance, with its beautiful tone and good tuning throughout the lines, which, combined with the calm and soothing delivery (as in 00:51, for example), resulted in a truly satisfying sound. However, upon reviewing it in relation to our playlists, we noticed that the sample lines featured variations that felt less expansive (in sections such as 01:15 to 01:38, for example) compared to our current style, which tends to seek sample variations that develop with a more consistently expansive progression throughout their structure. Thank you once again for the opportunity to review your track! It may be well received by playlists with greater aesthetic compatibility. Wishing you a successful campaign and an amazing week! If you found our feedback helpful, we would greatly appreciate your rating. Best regards!

Apologies for declining this track at the moment. The song has a really solid mix and I find the vocal performance quite engaging. That said, the vocals have a bit of autotune sets a different listening experience than what I'm trying to build in my playlist.