Shouldn't Be
by Jed Craddock, D.R.O.
· posted by Jed Craddock
Artist · Nov 12, 2026
· Report
- Package
- Pro
- Curators requested
- 25
- Sub-genres
- retro soul, indie soul, neo-soul, funk
- Mood
- sad, relaxed
- Release
- Released on Spotify
- Track
- Open on Spotify
RnB Soul, Falsetto, rich, somber mood. Makes you feel suspended in a satisfying way until the Chord progression changes. Gang vocals slap hard and are a nice timbre change from the solo falsetto vocal. The slide guitar is unexpected yet fits like a glove.
Replies 25
Curators are independent playlist owners, not Intonality staff, and each reply is their own opinion. Replies carry a decision and are shown in full as written; curators know they are public before they write. Anyone signed in can join. To answer a specific reply, use the reply link under it.
The guitar work is one of my favourite parts of this track. The composition has a laid-back character, and I enjoy how the sounds and ideas evolve without losing that relaxed atmosphere. There’s creativity in the arrangement, and the overall tone is genuinely pleasing and interesting. On the production side, I feel the midrange could use more presence. Some central elements don’t come through as clearly as they could, so a more balanced mixdown might bring out the detail and give the guitars stronger definition. I’d also enjoy more variation as the track progresses; introducing fresh textures or subtle arrangement changes could give the later sections greater momentum. These are refinements rather than concerns with the core idea, which I find appealing. The musical direction already has a distinct charm, and I’d love to hear how you develop it further.
- Funky, Jazzy, Soul Grooves ☀️ by Don's Tunes 12,361 followers
- Placement verified on Spotify
Hi! This is one awesome tune with lovely mellow, soulful sound. I will feature it on my Funky, Soul Grooves playlist. I will be happy if you can share it with your fans on social media. Keep it up!
Hello, Jed Craddock and DRO! All right? Thanks for sharing your track with us! The song presents a beautiful vocal timbre, with softness and good expressiveness in the interpretation. We like the way the voice leads the composition, conveying a pleasant feeling and adding delicacy to the proposal. However, when we analyze the alignment with the current direction of our curation, we perceive a more environmental and chill atmosphere, with a relaxed and spaced dynamic. Moments of vocal pauses, as in 2:15, reinforce this contemplative feeling and lead the track into a lighter, more atmospheric experience, unlike the rhythmic presence and more constant fluidity we are prioritizing at this time. Due to this divergence in sound direction, the track will not be selected this time. Thank you for sharing your work with us and we wish you every success in your musical trajectories! Neighborhood's Vibe 🎧
The groove of this one is really tasteful, and I think the lead guitar part was done well. I really enjoyed listening to this. However, for my playlist, I think it might not sit well, as I'm aiming for tracks that have more drive to them. Still, thank you for sharing this one with me. Wishing you the best on this one
I find the song's melody, arrangement, and vocal performance quite engaging to listen to. However, for the mix, the vocals felt a little bit reverb-y and the drums could still use a bit more punch. For now, I'll be passing on this track.
- Soulful Selections 5,135 followers
- Placement verified on Spotify
Hey Jed. Hearing a great fit in style on this track for my soul playlist. Nicely sultry with a soulful progression and arrangement. I'll be adding this, thanks!
- Evening Drive 8,395 followers
- Placement verified on Spotify
Hi there Jed. This is a great fit in production style for my evening playlist. Nicely relaxed with a soulful vibe and style. Adding this, thanks very much!
- Soulful Nights 63,503 followers
- Placement verified on Spotify
Hey Jed Craddock, D.R.O., Thanks for the sub, this is a great fit for Soulful Nights! I think the vocals, the Melody, and the production value are all top-notch. I did struggle to decide if this was either an R&B or soulful playlist, but I think it's soulful enough that it's gonna go there. Feel free to send this or more of your songs again when you're ready, as judging by the quality of this latest one, I bet you have lots of gems in reserve. Feel free to shout us out on IG and we'll do the same for you!
Thank you VinylHoops for adding Shouldn’t Be to your playlist Soulful Nights! I just gave you a shout out on IG and started following your there as well!
Amazing, thanks Jed!
Reply
Sign in to reply. Artists and curators both use their Intonality account.
- 12am nostalgia 18,686 followers
- Placement verified on Spotify
No written feedback was left with this decision.
- café after hours 9,088 followers
- Placement verified on Spotify
Hi there! Good job with this song and I loved the overall soulful melodies and performance. Happy to add this! :)
- Pop Soul & Neo Mellow 26,447 followers
- Placement verified on Spotify
Hi, Jed Craddock and D.R.O.! It was amazing discovering your music! "Shouldn't Be" brings a relaxing atmosphere, with nuances that captivate and soothe the audience. A combination that fits beautifully into our playlist. It has been officially accepted into our "Pop Soul & Neo Mellow" playlist! Wishing you great success throughout your musical career. If you found our feedback helpful, we would be very happy and grateful if you could rate us 5 stars! Sending you a big hug, buddy!
- Neo-Soul Cafe 1,455 followers
- Placement verified on Spotify
This track has a great vibe. It's well balanced with nicely finished production. The falsetto vocals can get a little muddy in the "highs" at times, making it hard to understand the lyrics. Instrumentation is tight and a good rhythm helps carry that vocal. Feels a bit linear at times in the melody but that's often the case with a slow jam type of song. Overall I think it makes for great listening, giving me some Al Green vibes and I'm happy to add it to my Neo-Soul playlist.
Hello, Jed Craddock, D.R.O., how are you? The sound of Shouldn't Be is captivating. Your chords create a romantic direction, while the voice stands out with its high-pitched tone and strong reverb. But I feel that the section from 03:00 onward carries a heavier climax that sounds experimental compared to the simple and intimate touch of our playlists. Even so, congratulations on your mature approach, and don't forget to leave a positive rating for our review. Nage, Chill Connections
We really enjoyed your track and appreciate the overall sound and musical direction. Our only feedback is that some sections feel a little repetitive, particularly in the arrangement. We believe adding more variation in certain parts, whether through subtle instrumental changes or dynamic shifts, could bring more movement and make the listening experience even more engaging. Best Regards, Adityaa
Hi Jed Craddock, D.R.O., I’m drawn to your soulful vocal delivery and slow groove in this arrangement that feels so passionate. I enjoyed the slow yet melodic guitar solo around the 2:19 section. However, I will decline this submission this time based on the lack of depth in the mix. I tend to aim for tracks that have a more potent drum mix that have a deeper kick and tighter snare. Best wishes!
- Soulful Grooves 12,169 followers
- Placement verified on Spotify
I really enjoyed the groove of the arrangement and the way it complemented the light falsetto melody of the vocals! I will be adding this to my curation. Thank you!
- Mellow Mood 8,592 followers
- Placement verified on Spotify
Hey Jed Craddock, super soulful track which I think is really perfect for my playlist, much love and keep it up!
- Relax & Chill 14,691 followers
- Placement verified on Spotify
Hey Jed Craddock, the slow and soulful mood works beautifully for my playlist and I have to say the guitar playing was superb throughout the track. I'd love to share this, cheers!
- Soul Garden Club 4,261 followers
- Placement verified on Spotify
Incredibly soulful and chill. I love the vocal tone you have. Definitely a track worth adding. Keep it up! Thanks for sharing.
- Soul / Selected 5,939 followers
- Placement verified on Spotify
Amazing track Jed Craddock and D.R.O.! I love the soulful and bluesy vibe it has. It really allowed the guitars and your vocals to shine. Great song and thanks for this. I'll be adding it to my playlist.
Notamos que a melodia secundária veio apresentando bem no contexto. O ambiente presente está bem controlado e possui consistência que faz sentido. Um ponto marcante é seu solo de guitarra que segue tocando em forma de choro. Um andamento musical bem sensualizado para passar um tempo junto com os casais, ideal para esses playlists. A qualidade técnica foi impecável. Porém, como nossos playlists possuem questões seletivas ao andamento musical ser relativamente pouco mais rápido, acreditamos que a melhor retenção de ouvintes das músicas compartilhadas aqui ou não é manter a recusa nesta música. Normalmente evitamos certo foco as músicas consideradas sensualizadas. Bom trabalho!
- Slow Mornings Soul 8,792 followers
- Placement verified on Spotify
The song has such an amazing melody and I love the falsetto style singing here as it really reinforces the song's overall sexiness. Featuring this one in my playlist!
- Indie Chill 1,556 followers
- Placement verified on Spotify
Hey. Thanks for sharing this track with us - really lovely vibe. The instrumentation is super smooth and well mixed. The vocal is really powerful also. Great musicianship all around. Happy to share on Indie Chill for four weeks.
- Indie 900 2,135 followers
- Placement verified on Spotify
No written feedback was left with this decision.
- Slow Guitars 31,238 followers
- Placement verified on Spotify
Chill vibe for my slow guitar list. Wish you all the best with your release! Cheers, Jens
Sign in to join the discussion. Artists and curators both use their Intonality account.
Hey Kenyama, thank you for adding shouldn’t be to your playlist. Are you on IG? Would love to follow you there as well and give you a shout out on my socials. IG - jedcraddock_music