Holiday Dinner
by Plural Chaos
· posted by Charles Goin
Artist · Nov 15, 2026
· Report
- Package
- Max
- Curators requested
- 25
- Sub-genres
- adult contemporary, commercial, alternative pop
- Mood
- happy
- Release
- Released on Spotify
- Track
- Open on Spotify
The first truly inclusive holiday Christmas song for Pastafarians and Christians alike! “Holiday Dinner” by Plural Chaos captures the nostalgic warmth and holly-jolly charm of a 1930s–40s Christmas classic, with a delightfully irreverent twist. Imagine Bing Crosby hosting Christmas dinner at Olive Garden with Buddha, Zeus, Odin, Grandma, and the Flying Spaghetti Monster. A vintage-style holiday singalong celebrating every faith, every tradition, and everyone having a seat at the table. Ra'Men!
Replies 26
Curators are independent playlist owners, not Intonality staff, and each reply is their own opinion. Replies carry a decision and are shown in full as written; curators know they are public before they write. Anyone signed in can join. To answer a specific reply, use the reply link under it.
I really liked the song in terms of melodies, but in this case I wasn't as convinced by the sound. I wish you lots of luck and hope the song is successful, although in this case I can't help you.
Show original
La canción me ha gustado mucho a nivel de melodías, pero en este caso no me he convencido tanto a nivel de sonido. Te deseo mucha suerte y espero que la canción tenga éxito, aunque en este caso yo no te pueda ayudar
“Holiday Dinner” has a lively, playful character, with guitars and an energetic arrangement that bring the artist's creative vision to life. The vocal texture, however, felt a little too heavily treated for our preferences. We found that this processing created some distance from the performance, whereas we tend to connect more with voices that retain a natural, expressive quality. Ultimately, this kept the track from finding a place in our current rotation. We appreciate the opportunity to explore your creative work and hope these observations were helpful! For Plural Chaos, may your musical journey continue to bring fresh ideas, rewarding collaborations, and exciting discoveries. Cheers, L. Napoleon | Campfire Melodies
Generic feedback and obviously didn't listen to the track.. a common thread here. This is a HOLIDAY SONG.. no comments about that, and comments about things the song doesn't have. Also the playlist pitched by intonality wasn't a holiday one even though that is specifically the only genre listed. Extra star for putting in the effort of naming the song and band.
Reply
Sign in to reply. Artists and curators both use their Intonality account.
There’s something really lovely about the sonic character of this track. The guitars are especially pleasing, and your voice carries a beautiful tone that complements the composition naturally. I’m also quite impressed by the creative direction and the ideas you’ve explored. My only reservation is that I’d have liked a little more variation in the arrangement to give the song further emotional and dynamic movement. Nevertheless, you have a wonderful creative instinct and plenty of potential ahead. Keep creating!
Generic feedback and obviously didn't listen to the track.. a common thread here. This is a HOLIDAY SONG.. no comments about that. Also the playlist pitched by intonality wasn't a holiday one even though that is specifically the only genre listed.
Reply
Sign in to reply. Artists and curators both use their Intonality account.
Hi Plural Chaos! Thanks for sharing your song. I really enjoyed the atmosphere, and the vocals fit the overall sound nicely, giving the track its own identity. The song creates an engaging listening experience from start to finish, but this time I was hoping for a vocal performance that would leave a stronger impression. It’s a thoughtfully crafted piece of work, and I’d be happy to hear more of your music in the future.
Generic feedback and obviously didn't listen to the track.. a common thread here. This is a HOLIDAY SONG.. no comments about that. Also the playlist pitched by intonality wasn't a holiday one even though that is specifically the only genre listed.
Reply
Sign in to reply. Artists and curators both use their Intonality account.
Hi, Plural Chaos! How are things? Thank you so much for sending "Holiday Dinner" our way for review! Right off the bat, the track’s instrumental construction deserves praise: you’ve crafted a great instrumental style, featuring solid, authentic progressions and a strong interplay between the guitars and drums! On the other hand, when assessing how well it fits into our current playlists, we noticed that the production leans into a distinctly vintage aesthetic—with a vocal delivery style and an analog-style mix that draw direct inspiration from the 1960s. This nostalgic sound creates a listening experience that feels a bit removed from the contemporary direction we’re currently focusing on for our selections. Thank you again for trusting us with your work and for sharing your music with us. We’ll be rooting for the success of this release, and we look forward to hearing your future projects! Best, Debbys 💚 Pop Aesthetics
Good feedback, acknowledged the esthetic of the song and its holiday nature. Issue with intonality is this is a HOLIDAY SONG.. the playlist pitched isn't a holiday one. So of course rejected.
Reply
Sign in to reply. Artists and curators both use their Intonality account.
Hello Plural Chaos, how are you? :) Thank you so much for sharing “Holiday Dinner” with us! The track features a good vocal connection, with a powerful and stripped-down presence rendition. We like the way the voice imposes itself in the composition, bringing personality and an authentic identity to the work. However, considering our current aesthetic direction, we feel that the track follows a more retro proposal, with a mix with a very analog character and sonic references that refer to past decades. The arrangements bring more acidic elements to the drums and guitars, as well as a construction that evokes a vintage atmosphere, with references that take us back to the 40s. These choices give the composition a particular identity, but end up distancing the work from the more contemporary, dynamic and grooved sounds that we are prioritizing in our playlists at the moment. Thank you for sharing your work with us and we wish you much success in the upcoming releases! Neighborhood's Vibe
Plural Chaos, it was interesting to discover "Holiday Dinner". The track has an authentic identity, supported by a dynamic and energetic progression. Even so, the synthetic vocal timbre creates a sense of overlap with the other melodic layers, which lose prominence as the vocal performance takes over. This imbalance moves the track away from the approach we're currently prioritizing in our curation. Thank you for introducing your music to our team. We appreciated the opportunity to discover this release.
Generic feedback a common thread here. This is a HOLIDAY SONG.. no comments about that. Also the playlist pitched by intonality wasn't a holiday one even though that is specifically the only genre listed.
Reply
Sign in to reply. Artists and curators both use their Intonality account.
Hello. The song starts with good energy, with typical festive percussion sounds and rhythmic trumpets and a good swing style, with male and female voices in tune and energetic without breaking the harmony. A guitar with a picking pattern follows its melody and the special percussion does a very good job with sounds that follow the rhythm very well. It ends quickly but without becoming tiresome, and all vocal displays meet their purpose. This time it will not be included because we are looking for somewhat rougher, more alternative melodies, but it is a good production. Kind regards!
Show original
Hola. La canción empieza con buena energía, con sonidos de percusión típicos festivos y trompetas rítmicas y un buen estilo swing, con voz masculina y femenina entonadas y enérgicas sin romper la armonía. Una guitarra con un punteo sigue su melodía y la percusión especial hace un trabajo muy bueno en sus sonidos que siguen muy bien el ritmo. Termina de forma rápida pero sin cansar, y todas sus demostraciones vocales cumplen su objetivo. Esta vez no será incorporada por buscar melodías algo más ásperas y alternativas pero es una buena producción. Saludos cordiales!
Good feedback, acknowledged the esthetic of the song and its holiday nature. Issue with intonality is this is a HOLIDAY SONG.. the playlist pitched isn't a holiday one. So of course rejected.
Reply
Sign in to reply. Artists and curators both use their Intonality account.
Thank you for your submission. This is a decent Christmas song. I have to be honest the melodies with the vocals didn't catch my attention this time. That is no insult, just a subjective opinion. I wish you all the best.
Good feedback, acknowledged the esthetic of the song and its holiday nature. Issue with intonality is this is a HOLIDAY SONG.. the playlist pitched isn't a holiday one. So of course rejected.
Hello Charles, thanks for the feedback. Although my playlists aren't holiday playlists specifically, I still accept Christmas songs for the Holiday period that resonate with me. I would imagine the pool of curators that only do Christmas themed playlists is quite small overall, however I hope you find them! Thanks again for your submission.
Reply
Sign in to reply. Artists and curators both use their Intonality account.
Amazingly made Charles, thank you for sharing your track with me. I appreciate the energy behind the guitar arrangement and the instrumental has a lively character, but I felt the overall melody needed a stronger identity. The song has a solid foundation, although it did not leave the lasting impression I was hoping for. I hope to see more of your craft in the future.
Generic feedback and obviously didn't listen to the track.. a common thread here. This is a HOLIDAY SONG.. no comments about that. Also the playlist pitched by intonality wasn't a holiday one even though that is specifically the only genre listed.
Hello Charles, I understand your point, and honestly, I can see why you're disappointed. I apologize that my feedback came across as generic and didn't acknowledge the holiday theme of your song. That should have been reflected in my review, especially considering the playlist's stated focus. I appreciate you pointing this out, and I'll be more attentive to the details of each submission moving forward. Thanks for the honest feedback.
Reply
Sign in to reply. Artists and curators both use their Intonality account.
- Pop/R&B Wave 1,214 followers
- Placement verified on Spotify
Thank you for sharing this beautiful track with me. I really love the way the vocals carry emotion, the smoothness of the delivery, and how the production creates such a warm and captivating atmosphere. The songwriting also adds depth to the record, making it easy to connect with. I genuinely enjoyed listening, and I'd be happy to feature this on my playlist. Keep creating music like this, and I look forward to hearing more from you.
Thanks for sharing this track! I really appreciate the creativity and the direction you've taken with the production. The instrumental has some nice touches, but the vocal mix, delivery and overall energy could use a little more refinement to bring everything together. The vibe is interesting, but the execution doesn't quite match the sound I'm looking for on my playlist. Keep pushing, there's potential here.
Generic feedback and obviously didn't listen to the track.. a common thread here. This is a HOLIDAY SONG.. no comments about that. Also the playlist pitched by intonality wasn't a holiday one even though that is specifically the only genre listed.
Reply
Sign in to reply. Artists and curators both use their Intonality account.
- Feel-Good Indie & Alternative Vibes 8,748 followers
- Placement verified on Spotify
Hi! Thanks for your track! It’s got a great, positive vibe! I love the dynamic rhythm and the warm lyrics. Welcome to my playlist!
I appreciate the response.. wasn't upset. Also it wasn't that it was AI, it was that it was more cut and paste. It didn't give much detail, but I do appreciate the positive feedback.
Hi! I’m sorry that you perceived my review as being AI-generated, and I apologize if my words caused any offense. I write reviews myself for each track, for each artist. The fact that my playlist isn’t holiday-themed isn’t an issue, as many tracks still fit the vibe, mood, and overall sound of the playlist. I don’t exclude artists simply because a track happens to have a holiday vibe. I truly hope my feedback didn’t upset you.
Reply
Sign in to reply. Artists and curators both use their Intonality account.
Hi, thank you for sharing your track! I like the catchy melodic arrangement and the overall atmospheric feel. However, the vocal performance was a little bit out of pitch at times in my opinion. I'm looking for indie pop with more natural-sounding vocals and a stronger emotional connection. Wishing you all the best with your music!
Hey there, thank you very much for sharing "Holiday Dinner" with us! Appreciate that. The track has many good ideas and a strong foundation. However, we think the song would benefit from better mixing and mastering. The current mix sounds a little unpolished, too compressed and lacks certain depth and warmth... Keep refining your art, we’re excited to hear more from you in the future! Best of luck!
Hi, it was good to hear Holiday Dinner by Plural Chaos, which brings a pleasantly cheerful Christmas feeling right from the start. However, the mix sounds a bit muddy and lacks the dynamic range we look for, so it is not a good fit for our playlist. Keep creating and building on your ideas.
Hi there! Thanks for your submission. I liked guitar riff at the bridge (right after chorus part). There is also cool holiday atmosphere with emotional and expressive vocal. However, this track sounds a bit too dynamic and too energetic for my playlist. Thanks again and good luck with your project. I'm sure you'll find your audience soon. Please remember it's only my personal opinion.
Hello, Plural Chaos! Thank you for submitting your track "Holiday Dinner"! We found the vocal interpretation interesting, with an active yet laid-back dynamism that created a truly uplifting sound. However, upon reviewing it in relation to our playlists, we noticed that the instrumental arrangements featured elements that sounded a little more retro (in sections such as 01:21 to 01:52, for example), which ended up differing from the current direction of our playlists, which tend to lean more towards instrumentations that incorporate slightly more prominent contemporary nuances throughout their composition. It was a pleasure to receive your track and get to know a little about your musical identity! We hope it finds opportunities in playlists with greater aesthetic and sonic compatibility. We wish you an excellent week and a campaign filled with great achievements! If you found our feedback helpful, we would be grateful for your rating. Best regards!
Hi, Plural Chaos! Thanks for sharing. I really liked how you combined male and female vocals. The melody evokes a festive feeling in the listener and is perfect for the Christmas holidays. Your composition is wonderful, but unfortunately, I didn’t fully appreciate it. I hope you understand. Best wishes!
Hello mate! Thanks a lot for this great sound! Well, The release is really dreamy. Sincerely enjoyed the deep work, groovy vibes, great dynamic atmo :-) Yet, this production is too much sung for my playlist... To be honest, my playlist do features productions less based on this Anyway, I sincerely wish you all the best for that production!
Thanks for the reply.. yea not your fault a 100% how intonality handled it.
Well, I did listen, but unfortunately, I did not notice I had activated the holiday song toogle, so received yours by error. Sorry for declining, I'm used to review electronic music, hence the vocabulary, but the song was in fact quite full of happiness and even humor, and quite nicely produced, so I sincerely wish you will meet success :)
Reply
Sign in to reply. Artists and curators both use their Intonality account.
Hi there thank you for sharing some of your tunes my way home. Nice drums you have here , this upbeat drive running like a thread through the song. Unfortunately I do feel like the voice is a little less up my alley sadly , mostly the character on there. Some clever hooks besides that. Kind regards , Jelle
- shoegaze & indie 2,794 followers
- Placement verified on Spotify
No written feedback was left with this decision.
There’s some tasteful quality to the guitar tones and I appreciate the musicality behind this track. The overall sound leans a little too polished and artificial for my playlist, though, I’m looking to hear a more organic character and a timeless direction in the arrangement. Keep experimenting with your sound!
Generic feedback and obviously didn't listen to the track.. a common thread here. This is a HOLIDAY SONG.. no comments about that, and comments about things the song doesn't have. Also the playlist pitched by intonality wasn't a holiday one even though that is specifically the only genre listed.
Reply
Sign in to reply. Artists and curators both use their Intonality account.
- Moth to Flame (dark pop) 2,762 followers
- Placement verified on Spotify
No written feedback was left with this decision.
Hi, thank you for sending us your song. We appreciate your creativity in writing this song. In our opinion, this song sounds very energetic right from the intro. The rock/punk-style instrumentation in this song is also iconic and has its own unique character. The tempo and rhythm are also faster, which we think makes the song even more lively and fun. Therefore, we feel it isn’t quite a good fit for our playlist, as our playlist prioritizes songs with a blend of melancholic, calm, and relaxed vibes, and most of the songs typically feature soft instrumental and vocal elements throughout. However, this is just our personal opinion as listeners. We hope you continue to be creative in your music and wish you success with your future songs.
Generic feedback and obviously didn't listen to the track.. a common thread here. This is a HOLIDAY SONG.. no comments about that. Also the playlist pitched by intonality wasn't a holiday one even though that is specifically the only genre listed.
Reply
Sign in to reply. Artists and curators both use their Intonality account.
Most pitches responded with generic feedback and obviously didn't listen to the track.. This was a HOLIDAY TRACK, Done in the style of Burl Ives. No comments about that, and mostly comments about things the song doesn't have in it. I would say of the 25 responses in general.. 3 actually listened to the track. I was even place on 4 playlists.. and shockingly.. none are Holiday. I mean Ill take the add, but its not going to do a thing for me promotion wise and probably hurt me on the algorithm. Also none of the playlists pitched by intonality were holiday ones even though that is specifically the only genre listed. What a waste of everyone's time and effort. If you have a Holiday playlist as an option it should go to Holiday playlist curators.. not a ton of curators that are not even remotely adject.. what a waste. So much for not being bot driven playlists curation.
Sign in to join the discussion. Artists and curators both use their Intonality account.
Generic feedback and obviously didn't listen to the track.. a common thread here. This is a HOLIDAY SONG.. no comments about that. Also the playlist mentioned isn't a holiday one.