Every public campaign. Every curator's verdict.
Artists who opted in have their campaign posted here in full: which curators listened, who added the track, who declined, and exactly what they wrote. Artists and curators reply to each other in the open. Nothing is edited or cherry-picked.
Opted-in campaigns in full: every curator's verdict and feedback, declines included.
Thank for your submission, DJ RiccoFX. The piano accompaining the vocals is quite nice and mellow. Nice epic section at 2:14. However, I'm not interested in productions with vocals for my neoclassical playlists. Keep in mind this is just my opinion.
I appreciate the clean production, prominent vocal mix and the piano phrasing. However, though entertaining, I was hoping for a bit more development in phrasing and dynamics. Additionally, I'm currently seeking tracks that are a bit brighter and livelier. That...
Hey, DJ RiccoFX! I hope you're doing well!! I just listened to Color of the Sound, which stands out for its distinctive piano sequence and vocals with a modern, refined tone. However, this simpler arrangement doesn't quite match our Chill direction, which focu...
I really like the low, deeper resonating vocal tone and also the lyrics and the darker yet hopeful vibe. But for my playlists and taste, the chord progression in the piano also feels a little bit too foreseeable and mainstream. I just miss a bit more surprisin...
He,y Beauitufl atmosphere. The piano fits perfectly in my list but we don't focus on a vocal upfront, especially not digital sounding vocals. We like just focus on slow and felt piano. Good luck! Jessa
Hey thanks for sharing this track. I really enjoyed the harmonic progression and the choice of instruments. There is a beautiful melancholic and almost cinematic atmosphere to the track that gives it a strong emotional character. For my current playlist, thoug...
Hi DJ RiccoFX! Thank you for sharing this. I’m so sorry for declining this track because I’m not connecting with the super polished vocals and the epic strings in the arrangement. I’m looking for a more rustic Indie folk feel with rawer vocals and subtle strin...
Thanks for the submission, an emotional track with some strong vocals and nice keys, track production and balance is good however for my lists I'm looking for a bit more in terms of groove with drums and percussion this one is a bit too mellow for my taste so...
Hey DJ RiccoFX, thanks for sharing your music and the emotional story behind it! This is a heartfelt song with a nice cinematic atmosphere, rich harmonies and a lovely sense of emotion. I appreciate the expressive musical approach and the way the arrangement s...
Hey DJ RiccoFX, thanks for sending the track. Idea is pretty solid overall.Love the sound selection and mixing of each element , specially from the Piano. The vocal is beautiful, the lyrics too! And th eprocessing on point. Definitely this is a quaility track...
Hi, thank you very much for sharing your work. A very balanced song with good buildup and progression. However the song is too cinematic for my playlists. Therefore I politely decline this one.
Thanks for sending this in. The idea behind the piece comes across, and the emotional piano writing fits the story you describe, but for me the track isn't there yet. The mix sounds flat: the piano and the electronic layers sit on the same level, so there's li...
Morning folks! I genuinely enjoyed every second of this. but l'm not digging the Iyrics. you've certainly have a unique and recognizeable sound, just not connecting with them. keep doing your thing though. cheers
Hey there , beautiful composition . Really loved the catchy vocals and emotions . The ambience feels nice and soothing . Though the mood suits my playlist well , I prefer a bit more lively chorus vibes with some drums in it . Good luck! will have to pass on th...
Hello there! Pretty decent starting point here, but the vocals feel a bit heavy on the low end which affected the overall balance of the mix. A few adjustments in that areas could make a noticeable difference to the final result. Apologies for the decline toda...
Hola. La canción tiene un comienzo que es identificable al country desde su inicio. La instrumentalización es la acorde a ella, con buenas guitarras acústicas y sonidos de fondo envolventes que manejan una melodía exquisita en su recorrido. La vocalización fem...
Thanks for your submission. Love the vocal here. Has a nice tone and the song has a nice smooth feel to it. In saying that, this is too conventional sounding for my taste. I'm afters something a little more alternative and edgy sounding. Thanks and good luck w...
Hi Echovayn! Thank you for trusting me again with your track. I appreciate the swung feel in the arrangement. I’m quite sorry for declining because the vocal mix felt a bit subdued and the instrumentation felt a bit hollow for me. I’m actually looking to add t...
It’s great to hear from you. Usually looking for something moodier, so this feels a bit too bright, but the main chord progression is really nice. Best of luck with the release!
Beautful song and writing and vocal tone but to my ears and lsits the rooot to fifth pattern in the bass sounds a bit too old school and traditional to m years and lists. In general I miss a bit more modern sound and some more surprising musical elements. Stil...
How this board works
- Every campaign here was posted with the artist's permission, chosen at checkout. Artists can switch it off from their dashboard at any time.
- Campaigns are posted once every curator has replied, so no curator sees another's feedback while reviewing. We publish the full text, including declines.
- Reviews an artist has disputed are hidden until resolved.
- Placements are verified against Spotify. Follower counts are the latest we have for each playlist.
Your campaign could be next on the board.