Every public campaign. Every curator's verdict.
Artists who opted in have their campaign posted here in full: which curators listened, who added the track, who declined, and exactly what they wrote. Artists and curators reply to each other in the open. Nothing is edited or cherry-picked.
Opted-in campaigns in full: every curator's verdict and feedback, declines included.
Thanks for your submission, Echovayn. I enjoyed this laid-back country production. In particular, I appreciate the big choir at 48 seconds. However, I'm not interested in productions that contain the crunchy electric guitars for my Indie Rock playlist. Of cour...
Hello! It sounds like a very chill and calm track. Perfect vibe for my indie playlist. However, the mix right now has this unnaturally airy sound that I find a bit muffled and fuzzy. Sorry for the decline.
vocals sound super effortless here, love that you retained the rawness of the instrumental lines. it's a super clever track but i just kinda wish it has this momentous component which i felt would further solidify the hook on here
There’s a really nice warmth to the track, but it leans a little more country-leaning than the direction I’m looking for right now. I’d keep some of that organic charm while bringing in a slightly different flavor to make it feel closer to the sound I’m after....
Greetings and thank you for sharing your song with me! A nice and clean production, the strings sound crisp in there, I like the bassline. The vocals start early which I like for audience retention. I like the lyrics as well as they are pretty relatable but I...
Hello there! thank you very much for sharing your new song with us. Nice melodies, the song has strong foundation for a good country track. However, the production side of the song is not there yet...the master sounds very overcompressed and not natural. Sound...
Hi! Thanks for sending this lovely song. I enjoyed its easy-going melody and the lyrics but for my playlists I prefer a more classic blues / americana with a bit grittier / darker tone and mood. Keep it up!
No written feedback with this decision.
Very grateful for the thoughtfulness behind this. The production on this came out well. The artistry and love put in this track really shines, but the overall pace feels a little more laid-back than the mood we generally feature. Best of luck with this release...
If 'Libre' is a future release where the instrumental is its greatest asset. I like the piano's contribution where it conveys emotions with total effectiveness and love for music. However, its linear and melancholic style differs from what I'm prioritizing for...
The track's got a solid melody and I love the warm piano tone in this track. Adding this to my playlist!
Hey SAMBOX, the track's cinematic pulse leans a bit restrained for the brighter, more immediate arc I curate, but that piano hook really lingers and feels handwritten. I’m going to decline this time, thanks for sending it.
Hi SAMBOX, thank you for sharing, but I'm sorry to say that the melody was not quite captivating for me as the structure of the melody was a bit unclear and it could use a bit more refining in the performance for it to sound a lot more smooth. Really sorry to...
Nice touch with the cinematic scope, though the mastering feels a touch compressed which flattens the dynamics. The piano motif has a warm, easy feel that stuck with me. I’ll decline this time, thanks for sharing.
Hello there! How are you doing today? Thanks a lot for your latest submission! Some nice piano melodies used in a good arrangement of this track. I'll have to pass for the simple reason I'm currently looking for piano songs with more ambient background texture...
The overall mood here drifts a bit toward somber and doesn't match the playlist's brighter cinematic arc, but your piano motif is memorable and tasteful. I'm going to decline this time, thanks for sending it.
Here's a polished English version with a professional curator tone: While the instrumentation is pleasant and the atmosphere showcases a strong artistic vision supported by quality production, I have decided to pass on the track at this time. I am currently pr...
No written feedback with this decision.
The textures feel a bit dense at times, which keeps the piano from opening up as much as it could. I like how focused the central motif is, it has real clarity. I’ll pass on adding it today.
Sailing into the fog has a delicate beginning. The voice of a small child is perceived as sweet and tender. As the minutes pass, I think it is a proposal where its greatest strength lies in the vocals. But, there are no changes or risk. It would have captured...
How this board works
- Every campaign here was posted with the artist's permission, chosen at checkout. Artists can switch it off from their dashboard at any time.
- Campaigns are posted once every curator has replied, so no curator sees another's feedback while reviewing. We publish the full text, including declines.
- Reviews an artist has disputed are hidden until resolved.
- Placements are verified against Spotify. Follower counts are the latest we have for each playlist.
Your campaign could be next on the board.