Every public campaign. Every curator's verdict.
Artists who opted in have their campaign posted here in full: which curators listened, who added the track, who declined, and exactly what they wrote. Artists and curators reply to each other in the open. Nothing is edited or cherry-picked.
Opted-in campaigns in full: every curator's verdict and feedback, declines included.
Cristobal Delgado Candela Curator
on Nice Girl by Fair Game · 3 weeks ago
Declined
Hello, thanks for sending over your song. I won't be able to share the song due to the fact it was made with AI. I hope you understand I try to keep my playlists AI-free. Wish you the best of luck with your release.
unique playlists Curator
on Nice Girl by Fair Game · 3 weeks ago
Declined
I found this to be a pleasant and uplifting track, and I particularly enjoyed the overall vibe you’ve created. The core song idea is impressive; however, the mix didn’t quite grab my attention in the way I’d hoped. For my playlist, I generally look for mixes t...
Ioan Curator
on Nice Girl by Fair Game · 3 weeks ago
Declined
A decent energy in this vocal led track, for me though this one felt to electronic and generic in feel and flavour, missing that soulful organic flow that my 'Sunsets' vibed playlist looks for so for that reason I'm having to take a pass
Álvaro Curator
on Nice Girl by Fair Game · 3 weeks ago
Declined
Hi there Fair Game, hope you are doing great! Thank you for sending the track!! Great idea overall.Good sound selection and mixing of elements. The vocal is so epic and well mixed. However I am lookinvg for slightly less BPMs tracks for my playlists as followi...
JPRA Curator
on Nice Girl by Fair Game · 3 weeks ago
Declined
Loved the overall idea of the tune and the vocal performance but I felt the arrangement didn't hit the spot for me this time.
Rave Sector Curator
on Nice Girl by Fair Game · 3 weeks ago
Declined
Hey there, thanks for sending your tune. In my opinion, there are too many different types of vocals, and the song never really takes off. I was waiting for the kick, and then another break came in after the intro.
Vibe Agency - Asia Curator
on Nice Girl by Fair Game · 3 weeks ago
Declined
Hey there! We really enjoy that buildup and cool lead layering you've made. However the tone of that male voice feels a bit sweet kinda for us personally, and overall production is too hissing and squished for our personal taste, which doesn't fit quite nice a...
Jens Van der Borght Curator
on Nice Girl by Fair Game · 3 weeks ago
Declined
Hi, Quality production. All elements in the mix work together smoothly. For my electronic playlists this song has however too much focus on the vocals and too little on instrumental and melodic progression to see it fit in the mood with the other songs. Also f...
Rushkeys Curator
on Nice Girl by Fair Game · 3 weeks ago
Declined
Hey Fair Game, thanks for the submission. This has plenty of energy and a strong, immediate feel - the fast-paced production and prominent vocals give it a very direct, accessible character. My electronica playlist sits quite far on the other side, focusing on...
Sebastian Wernke-Schmiesing Curator
on Nice Girl by Fair Game · 3 weeks ago
Declined
Hey, thanks so much for your submission. Unfortunately, your song was generated by AI. We're not interested in that. The sound quality of AI music is too poor for our standards. Plus, AI-generated songs get absolutely no streams on Spotify and are therefore of...
Selected By Nona Curator
on Afterlife by KIIX · 1 month ago
Added
Awesome track KIIX! Love the vibe, super groovy yet chill. It has a summer feel too. Definitely worth adding to my playlist. Great work!
Andrew Curator
on Afterlife by KIIX · 1 month ago
Added
Hey there, solid work! Nice production quality and the chord progression is well done. Perhaps hear more from you in the future. Best to you!
Cristobal Delgado Candela Curator
on Afterlife by KIIX · 1 month ago
Added
Hey KIIX! Thanks for sending over your song “Afterlife”! It sounds absolutely beautiful. The melodic composition is strong, the vocals are gorgeous, and the arrangement flows really well from start to finish. Everything works together nicely and creates a grea...
Luke Bertoz Curator
on Afterlife by KIIX · 1 month ago
Declined
Thanks for your submission. Super tight and tidy production here. Mix is well done as well. I like the subtle build up and drops and the vocals are perfect. In saying that I feel this too electronic and mainstream sounding for my playlists. I tend to playlist...
Anderson Júnior Curator
on Afterlife by KIIX · 1 month ago
Added
We note that your voice shows consistency and tuning at an intermediate level of application. I felt excited by this sound, very close to Alok, seeing that this electronic bass instrument has a primary characteristic. It is a sawtooth wave with low-pass filter...
VinylHoops Curator
on Afterlife by KIIX · 1 month ago
Declined
Hey KIIX, Damn, this is a very good track with a catchy sound design. But I'm having a big hesitation about accepting it: for a pop sub, I'm looking for a strong acoustic performance overall - leaning into acoustic guitars and drums, while keeping the vocals c...
Adrian Curator
on Afterlife by KIIX · 1 month ago
Declined
i thought that the sound design is super creative, vocals are made for the top40 stations. it's a super clever track but the melody didn't resonate with me quite as strongly on this one, i'm sorry, totally a matter of personal taste at this point
JPRA Curator
on Afterlife by KIIX · 1 month ago
Declined
Loved the vocal performance and the piano performance but I felt the arrangement didn’t hit the spot for me this time.
Sebastian Wernke-Schmiesing Curator
on Fela by Cristian Saavedra · 1 month ago
1
Added
Hey, thanks a lot for your submission. Solid Afro House track. Not a hit. Good average track. I can give it a little support here.
Sebastian Wernke-Schmiesing Curator
on Afterlife by KIIX · 1 month ago
Added
Hey, thanks so much for your submission. It's a good track with a strong topline and great sound. Not a hit, but very solid. I like it. I'll support it.
How this board works
- Every campaign here was posted with the artist's permission, chosen at checkout. Artists can switch it off from their dashboard at any time.
- Campaigns are posted once every curator has replied, so no curator sees another's feedback while reviewing. We publish the full text, including declines.
- Reviews an artist has disputed are hidden until resolved.
- Placements are verified against Spotify. Follower counts are the latest we have for each playlist.
Your campaign could be next on the board.