Loading...
Campaign board

Every public campaign. Every curator's verdict.

Artists who opted in have their campaign posted here in full: which curators listened, who added the track, who declined, and exactly what they wrote. Artists and curators reply to each other in the open. Nothing is edited or cherry-picked.

Opted-in campaigns in full: every curator's verdict and feedback, declines included.

New campaign Every curator replies with a decision and feedback · from $79
8.5MFollowers across curator playlistsFollowers
1,614Verified curator playlistsPlaylists
70%Of replies are declines. Published, not hidden.Declines
11hMedian time to a curator replyReply time
100%Of replies shown in full, as writtenShown in full
Adrian Curator on Heaven by Amber Song · 2 weeks ago Declined

really love that you retained the rawness of the instrumental lines, vocals are totally made for the radio. it's a super clever track but the melody didn't resonate with me quite as strongly on this one, i'm sorry, totally a matter of personal taste at this po...

John Friday Aworinde Curator on Heaven by Amber Song · 2 weeks ago Added
Chill Vibes | Song writer, Acoustic, Blues, Lo-fi & Country. · 1,524 followers

This one has a nice balance of atmosphere and energy. The beat sets the mood, while your vocal performance gives the track enough movement to keep things engaging. I enjoyed the combination and am happy to accept the submission.

acoustic tides Curator on Heaven by Amber Song · 2 weeks ago Declined

Hi Amber Song! Thank you for sharing this track with me. The songwriting sound so inspiring and the cinematic instrumentation were so exquisite. However, I’m sorry for declining this track because I noticed the mix of the instrumentation were a bit too bright...

Lim K. Curator on Heaven by Amber Song · 2 weeks ago Declined

There’s a clear direction behind the production, but some of the vocal and instrumental textures feel a little too processed, making the performance sound less natural and expressive than I’d like for my playlist. A bit more variation in the delivery and some...

organica Curator on Ship on Land by Echovayn · 2 weeks ago Declined

Hey, You have a beautiful voice to listen to! Too bad about the processing. For me it had this strange metallic sound while I would love to hear your voice more natural. Lastly this track felt too fast in the drums to fit our chill time list. Have a nice day!...

unique playlists Curator on Heaven by Amber Song · 2 weeks ago Declined

I really connected with the energy and mood your track conveys. The song's core idea is quite catchy; however, I found the overall mix didn't quite align with the quality I look for. Because of this, it isn't the right fit for my playlist at this time. I appre...

Jens Van der Borght Curator on Heaven by Amber Song · 2 weeks ago Declined

Hey, Dreamy vibe in this one. I was less a fan of the mix though. Found it quite metallic and harsh in the high end. The song was also too upbeat for my slow guitar lists. Wish you all the best with your release! Cheers, Jens

Selected By Nona Curator on Heaven by Amber Song · 2 weeks ago Declined

Hello there! I will be declining your track because the quality of the mix didn't meet my standards. Right now, it has this fuzzy and muffled like quality that I find a bit distracting. It's a nice song though. I think it definitely fits my indie playlist due...

you do you Curator on Heaven by Amber Song · 2 weeks ago Declined

Hey there , nice track . Really liked the vocals , vibes and emotions . However , at the moment we are looking for a bit more jolly mood , Crystal Fighters style . Rest , it has got some really good potential. Good luck! can't wait to hear more tracks from you...

LSB RECORDS Curator on Heaven by Amber Song · 2 weeks ago Added
Songwriter / Chill Vibes · 1,205 followers

Thank you for sharing your track with me. I really appreciate the soulful sound, the emotional depth, and the heartfelt vocal delivery. The song has a beautiful atmosphere that makes it easy to connect with its message. You’ve done a great job bringing these e...

Matthew Lucky Curator on Heaven by Amber Song · 2 weeks ago Declined

I appreciate the originality in your sound and the effort you put into this release. However, the track lacks enough variation in its phrasing to keep the progression engaging from start to finish. It has its own character, but it doesn’t quite hold the listen...

Lissa Timmerman Curator on Ship on Land by Echovayn · 2 weeks ago Declined

Hi there! The instrumental melody felt very country. Although the higher vocals didn't exactly resonate with the mood of my slower lists, I am in love with your instrumental soft folk kinda country groove. Your vocal feels a bit too intense for my slower playl...

Juhász Benedek Curator on Heaven by Amber Song · 2 weeks ago Declined

Hey there, thank you for sharing your song with me! I think that the song started of really nicely with the acoustic guitar theme and with the piano parts. I think that the strings also offered some really cool ideas, well done with the overall feel that you h...

Konstantin Curator on Heaven by Amber Song · 2 weeks ago Declined

Hey there, thank you very much for sharing "Heaven" with us! The track has a great foundation for a good singer-singwriter song, great melodies. However, we think the song would benefit from better mixing and mastering. The current mix sounds very overcompress...

omglooitsRaph Curator on Heaven by Amber Song · 2 weeks ago Declined

Hi there and thank you for sharing your song! The production is clean but those vocal effects are way too much. all the best, R

Mel Strocen Curator on Heaven by Amber Song · 2 weeks ago Added
Whiskey Chain - Top 150 Country · 4,841 followers

Thanks for submitting your track Amber. Beautiful song. The singing voice is clear and engaging. The musical arrangement - instruments, structure, tempo - is also outstanding. The song isn't a perfect fit for my playlist but I will add it anyway. Best of luck...

Don's Tunes Curator on Heaven by Amber Song · 2 weeks ago Declined

Hi! Thanks for the submission! I really like the heartfelt lyrics and the airy, emotional feel of the song but for my playlists I prefer tracks that have a bit darker, bluesy atmosphere. I will listen to more stuff from you to find a song that will be a better...

Sergio Curator on From the Smokies to The Opry by Echovayn · 2 weeks ago Added
SOFT 90s 2000s TOP 100 · 1,241 followers

Hola. La canción tiene un comienzo que es identificable al country desde su inicio. La instrumentalización es la acorde a ella, con buenas guitarras acústicas y sonidos de fondo envolventes que manejan una melodía exquisita en su recorrido. La vocalización fem...

Luke Bertoz Curator on From the Smokies to The Opry by Echovayn · 2 weeks ago Declined

Thanks for your submission. Love the vocal here. Has a nice tone and the song has a nice smooth feel to it. In saying that, this is too conventional sounding for my taste. I'm afters something a little more alternative and edgy sounding. Thanks and good luck w...

acoustic tides Curator on From the Smokies to The Opry by Echovayn · 2 weeks ago Declined

Hi Echovayn! Thank you for trusting me again with your track. I appreciate the swung feel in the arrangement. I’m quite sorry for declining because the vocal mix felt a bit subdued and the instrumentation felt a bit hollow for me. I’m actually looking to add t...

How this board works

  • Every campaign here was posted with the artist's permission, chosen at checkout. Artists can switch it off from their dashboard at any time.
  • Campaigns are posted once every curator has replied, so no curator sees another's feedback while reviewing. We publish the full text, including declines.
  • Reviews an artist has disputed are hidden until resolved.
  • Placements are verified against Spotify. Follower counts are the latest we have for each playlist.

Your campaign could be next on the board.

New campaign Every curator replies with a decision and feedback · from $79