Every public campaign. Every curator's verdict.
Artists who opted in have their campaign posted here in full: which curators listened, who added the track, who declined, and exactly what they wrote. Artists and curators reply to each other in the open. Nothing is edited or cherry-picked.
Opted-in campaigns in full: every curator's verdict and feedback, declines included.
Lissa Timmerman Curator
on Rise up and rebel by Echovayn · 1 week ago
Declined
Wonderful track . Really liked the lively vibes , catchy vocals and the energy . The melodies are appealing too . But currently I am focusing a bit more on chill and soothing content , Alt-J style . Good luck! eager to hear more from you.
Ant Curator
on Granddaughter by Kevin Klein · 1 week ago
Declined
Thanks for sharing your song! I liked the combination of guitar and keys, which creates a gentle, warm atmosphere alongside the vocals. The overall sound is pleasant and easy to listen to. However, I was hoping for a more catchy and memorable chorus that would...
Sound Surfer Playlists Curator
on Formal Resignation by Echovayn · 1 week ago
Declined
Hi Echovayn, this has the grittiness and intensity that I'm after and I loved the impactful fast paced energy. Unfortunately though, the mixing quality sounded way too bright and sibilant which sounded really harsh to the ears. Unfortunately this didn't meet m...
Sound Surfer Playlists Curator
on None Of My Concern by Eric B Turner · 1 week ago
Added
Hi Eric B Turner, this definitely has the soulful sound that I'm looking for and I was genuinely mesmerized by the vocal. I'll be adding this for sure, best wishes!
Mood Sculptor Playlists Curator
on Rise up and rebel by Echovayn · 1 week ago
Declined
Hey Echovayn, the vocal is quite catchy and the fun uptempo energy of the song would work well for my playlist. however, I just felt like the mixing could be improved because it has a really noisy, fuzzy, and grainy sound which made the audio sound a bit low q...
Mood Sculptor Playlists Curator
on None Of My Concern by Eric B Turner · 1 week ago
Added
Hey Eric B Turner, the vocal sounds so incredibly soulful and the song has a captivating vibe. This is perfect for my Soulful Mood playlist, much love!
you do you Curator
on Rise up and rebel by Echovayn · 1 week ago
Declined
Hi there! Great track. Really liked the lively vibes and the vocal content . The melodies are appealing too . However , for our playlist , we prefer a bit light stuff Alt J style . Rest ,the track has got some real good potential. Good luck! can't wait to hear...
Lim K. Curator
on Granddaughter by Kevin Klein · 1 week ago
Declined
There’s something really beautiful about this song, and I could genuinely feel the emotions you were trying to convey. The performance has a lovely sincerity to it, but the overall mood feels a little too sad for the playlist I’m curating right now. A touch mo...
Boundless Fusion Curator
on Formal Resignation by Echovayn · 1 week ago
Declined
I like the confidence and strong presence this track brings from the start :) The overall delivery feels a little too intense for the atmosphere I’m looking for in my playlist right now, so I’ll have to pass on this one. Bringing in more dynamic contrast and l...
Boundless Fusion Curator
on Granddaughter by Kevin Klein · 1 week ago
Declined
There’s a lovely melodic quality to this track, and I appreciate the softer direction you’ve taken with it :) The ballad-style arrangement isn’t quite what I’m looking for in my playlist right now. Adding a stronger rhythmic foundation and giving the song a li...
Endless Grooves Curator
on Granddaughter by Kevin Klein · 1 week ago
Added
I like how well the bright and light tone of the guitar contrasts with the warm tone of the vocals and piano. I will be adding this to my curation. Thank you!
Boundless Fusion Curator
on None Of My Concern by Eric B Turner · 1 week ago
Declined
There’s some nice musicality here, and I appreciate the thought behind the arrangement :) The jazz influences are a little too prominent for the sound I’m collecting in my playlist right now. A more grounded groove and a simpler melodic direction could help th...
SoundSafari Playlists Curator
on Formal Resignation by Echovayn · 1 week ago
Added
Greetings! I really enjoyed the heavy tone of the guitars as it matched the metal style of the arrangement. This will be a great addition to my playlist. Thank you!
SoundSafari Playlists Curator
on None Of My Concern by Eric B Turner · 1 week ago
Added
Hi there! I really enjoyed the tone of the guitars as it fit the mood and style of the arrangement very well. This will be a great addition to my playlist. Thank you!
Endless Grooves Curator
on None Of My Concern by Eric B Turner · 1 week ago
Added
Amazing vocal performance as it matched the darker and soulful sound of the chords in the arrangement! I will be adding this to my curation. Thank you!
Sergio Curator
on Formal Resignation by Echovayn · 1 week ago
Declined
Hola. La canción tiene una introducción con una voz que va del misterio al estruendo del rock pesado, con guitarras sumamente intensas y fuertes con aceleraciones de riff y una batería presente marcando también el ritmo. La vocalización al igual que las guitar...
Grubby Curator
on Formal Resignation by Echovayn · 1 week ago
Declined
Hey there, Echovayn - thanks for the submission. Your track has an intense sound and bags of energy. There are lots of ideas, fills and variations, which is cool. For me, the vocal tone was very generic and lacking in a unique character or tone. Overall, the m...
Grubby Curator
on Granddaughter by Kevin Klein · 1 week ago
Declined
Hey there, Kevin - thanks for the submission. Your track has a really warm, tactile sound and a nice, mellow soulfulness. The sentiment is heartfelt and I could feel the sincerity in the lyrics and the story. For me, the arrangement and some of the sound choic...
Konstantin Curator
on Formal Resignation by Echovayn · 1 week ago
Declined
Hey there, thank you very much for sharing your music with us! The track has a great foundation for a modern metal song, great melodies. However, we think the song would benefit from better mixing and mastering. The current mix sounds very overcompressed, unba...
Konstantin Curator
on Granddaughter by Kevin Klein · 1 week ago
Declined
Dear Kevin, thank you very much for sharing your song with us. Appreciate that. Beautiful lyrics. Overall great song! We personally think your track would benefit from better mixing and mastering though. The mix sounds a little unballnaced in our opinion...the...
How this board works
- Every campaign here was posted with the artist's permission, chosen at checkout. Artists can switch it off from their dashboard at any time.
- Campaigns are posted once every curator has replied, so no curator sees another's feedback while reviewing. We publish the full text, including declines.
- Reviews an artist has disputed are hidden until resolved.
- Placements are verified against Spotify. Follower counts are the latest we have for each playlist.
Your campaign could be next on the board.