Every public campaign. Every curator's verdict.
Artists who opted in have their campaign posted here in full: which curators listened, who added the track, who declined, and exactly what they wrote. Artists and curators reply to each other in the open. Nothing is edited or cherry-picked.
Opted-in campaigns in full: every curator's verdict and feedback, declines included.
Matthew Lucky Curator
on Love Is In The Air by Michael P Flyer · 1 month ago
Added
The vocals really stand out here, with a strong delivery and a smooth, confident tone. The mixing is also well done, keeping everything clear and balanced without taking away from the character of the track. Overall, a really solid record that fits the playlis...
Silverpalms music Curator
on Love Is In The Air by Michael P Flyer · 1 month ago
Declined
Hi Michael P Flyer, I appreciate the trust in allowing me to review this track. I’m quite drawn to the engaging beats and the catchy melodies in this arrangement. Unfortunately, I will decline because I’m not resonating with the bright mix in the synths and la...
Javier Mandiola Curator
on Love Is In The Air by Michael P Flyer · 1 month ago
Declined
The track features a solid development and a well-crafted structure, resulting in a strong overall level of quality. However, after evaluating it according to the direction of my current curation, I’ve decided not to include it in my selection, as its stylisti...
JPRA Curator
on Love Is In The Air by Michael P Flyer · 1 month ago
Declined
The vocal performance was great but I felt the arrangement didn’t hit the spot for me this time and the mix needed a bit more work. Wish you the best!
VinylHoops Curator
on Love Is In The Air by Michael P Flyer · 1 month ago
Declined
Hey Michale P Flyer, For a pop sub, I'm looking for a strong acoustic performance overall - leaning into acoustic guitars and drums, while keeping the vocals clean and clear throughout. This track has a lovely vocal performance, however I think in this case th...
Vibe Agency - Asia Curator
on Love Is In The Air by Michael P Flyer · 1 month ago
Declined
Hello! We appreciate your hard work on careful singing along with melodies and drums. However your song feels a bit too positive and uplifting for our personal taste, which doesn't fit our playlists, where we usually place engaging tracks with a bit deeper/int...
Mood Sculptor Playlists Curator
on Love Is In The Air by Michael P Flyer · 1 month ago
Declined
Hey Michael P Flyer, I liked the upbeat and festive energy of the song but I just felt like the instrumental had a slightly one dimensional sounding arrangement and none of the melodies were really engaging. I also didn't find the vocal melody particularly cat...
CountryOutlaw Curator
on Libertad by DJ Whit Allen, Nico Martinez, Mario Moreno · 1 month ago
Added
No written feedback with this decision.
Jens Van der Borght Curator
on Libertad by DJ Whit Allen, Nico Martinez, Mario Moreno · 1 month ago
Declined
Hey, I liked the percussion groove in this one. Th emix was quite crowded and elements fighting for attention. Some EQ and panning to give element their space in the frequency spectrum, could help. This song is also way too vocal focused for my lists. Wish you...
ClubMafia Curator
on Libertad by DJ Whit Allen, Nico Martinez, Mario Moreno · 1 month ago
Added
No written feedback with this decision.
omglooitsRaph Curator
on Libertad by DJ Whit Allen, Nico Martinez, Mario Moreno · 1 month ago
Declined
Hello there and thank you for sharing your music! Nice and clean production, good work on the soundtrack, I like the trumpet in there. The rhythm and groove is nice but I am not sure about the vocals. Too many vocal effects on there for me personally to be a g...
Seafarer Records Curator
on Libertad by DJ Whit Allen, Nico Martinez, Mario Moreno · 1 month ago
Declined
A huge thanks for taking the time to share your music with us, it’s greatly appreciated! The production elements sit really nicely together but we prioritize hybrid arrangements that incorporate both electronic and organic elements. Hope this one resonates and...
Daniel Mena Curator
on Libertad by DJ Whit Allen, Nico Martinez, Mario Moreno · 1 month ago
Declined
What gives the track most of its direction for me is the voice. It clearly takes the leading role and carries a strong narrative presence from the beginning, which gives the song a lot of potential. At the same time, that constant presence can also work agains...
Hey thanks for sharing with me! Loving the production, really enjoyed the percussions with the trumpet. Vocals are great too, but sadly I'm looking for a more urban sound like Tyla to dance in the clubs. Sorry and I wish you all the best!
Varad Mulay Curator
on Libertad by DJ Whit Allen, Nico Martinez, Mario Moreno · 1 month ago
Declined
Thanks for sharing your track.The track feels well polished.Production is meticulous.The percussion and instrumentation is amazing.The vocal processing and performance are good as well.However,the track doesnt fit the current direction of our playlists,which a...
Recap Curator
on Libertad by DJ Whit Allen, Nico Martinez, Mario Moreno · 1 month ago
Added
No written feedback with this decision.
Lefuturewave Curator
on Libertad by DJ Whit Allen, Nico Martinez, Mario Moreno · 1 month ago
Declined
Hey, this song has good vocals from Nico Martinez and the intro starts off cool. Additionally, elements like the sax and beat work really well. However, the chorus isn't quite dynamic enough in my opinion. Furthermore, I don't find the overall progression dist...
Javier Mandiola Curator
on Libertad by DJ Whit Allen, Nico Martinez, Mario Moreno · 1 month ago
Declined
The instrumentation and overall sound quality are both strong, with a well-produced and carefully crafted presentation. However, the vocal performance doesn’t quite meet the level I’m currently looking for in my playlist, so I’ve decided to pass on this one.
Vibe Agency - Asia Curator
on Libertad by DJ Whit Allen, Nico Martinez, Mario Moreno · 2 months ago
Declined
Hello! We appreciate your smooth voice sync along with drums and instruments. However your track feels a bit uplifting and light, which doesn't fit quite nice among other stronger and engaging afro latin tracks kinda in style of mestiza or aaron sevilla that w...
Jens Van der Borght Curator
on TRUE FRIENDS (feat. SARAH) by TKAT, SARAH · 2 months ago
Declined
Hi, Quality production. All elements in the mix work together smoothly. For my electronic playlists this song has however too much focus on the vocals and too little on instrumental and melodic progression to see it fit in the mood with the other songs. For my...
How this board works
- Every campaign here was posted with the artist's permission, chosen at checkout. Artists can switch it off from their dashboard at any time.
- Campaigns are posted once every curator has replied, so no curator sees another's feedback while reviewing. We publish the full text, including declines.
- Reviews an artist has disputed are hidden until resolved.
- Placements are verified against Spotify. Follower counts are the latest we have for each playlist.
Your campaign could be next on the board.