Every public campaign. Every curator's verdict.
Artists who opted in have their campaign posted here in full: which curators listened, who added the track, who declined, and exactly what they wrote. Artists and curators reply to each other in the open. Nothing is edited or cherry-picked.
Opted-in campaigns in full: every curator's verdict and feedback, declines included.
Rushkeys Curator
on TRUE FRIENDS (feat. SARAH) by TKAT, SARAH · 2 months ago
Declined
Hello TKAT and SARAH, thanks for sharing this with me. There’s a lot of personality in the production — the groove is catchy, the arrangement keeps changing, and the vocals and scratches add plenty of character to the genre-blending sound. For my playlist, I’m...
Álvaro Curator
on TRUE FRIENDS (feat. SARAH) by TKAT, SARAH · 2 months ago
Declined
Hi there, thanks for sending! The idea is interesting, I think the sound selection and is good and well mixed. The vocal is cool yeah but at the beginning it is a bit crazy, also the processing could be slightly better. Hope you can understand and best of luck...
Grubby Curator
on TRUE FRIENDS (feat. SARAH) by TKAT, SARAH · 2 months ago
Declined
Hey there, thanks for the submission. Your track has a lots of ideas and a really unique sound. I liked the slightly odd arrangement, with many elements coming together in a kind of musical collage. For me, it was a little too experimental though - some of the...
Hey both! Thanks for sending this over! The vocal phrasing feels really natural, especially in the quieter sections.However, The vintage influence is really clear, though it's a little outside the modern direction of my playlist.Appreciate you sharing this wit...
Varad Mulay Curator
on TRUE FRIENDS (feat. SARAH) by TKAT, SARAH · 2 months ago
Declined
Thanks for sharing your track.The vocal performance was good.The composition feels quiet hurried as compared to lyrical pace.The atmosphere could be better with more defining and stable layers.The production need touchups in man places,especially when it comes...
Lim K. Curator
on TRUE FRIENDS (feat. SARAH) by TKAT, SARAH · 2 months ago
Declined
this has a really lively energy and i can see it working well in a party setting. it just feels a little too celebratory for the mood im curating right now, so I won't be adding this one for now. still a fun listen tho, appreciate u sending it over!
Vibe Agency - Asia Curator
on TRUE FRIENDS (feat. SARAH) by TKAT, SARAH · 2 months ago
Declined
Hello! We appreciate your hard work on the clean production and careful voice sync throughout. However your song has a little upbeat tempo and the tone of female singing is a little too sweet and sugary for us personally, which doesn't fit quite nice among oth...
Dmytro Curator
on TRUE FRIENDS (feat. SARAH) by TKAT, SARAH · 2 months ago
Declined
Hey there! To start with, I really dig that hypnotizing energy of your song. It gets more and more infectious. Colorful piano part gets stuck in my head. Unfortunately, the vocal performance did not resonate enough with me. I'm really sorry. Your music is a wo...
VinylHoops Curator
on TRUE FRIENDS (feat. SARAH) by TKAT, SARAH · 2 months ago
Declined
Hey TKAT, SARAH, This is a captivating song for sure, though for a pop sub, I would have been looking for more commanding vocals that match a commercial pop sound. I also like minimally processed vocals, while these here are heavily laden with FX. On future po...
Sound Surfer Playlists Curator
on TRUE FRIENDS (feat. SARAH) by TKAT, SARAH · 2 months ago
Declined
Hi TKAT, I really liked the smooth funky groove of the instrumental but for me the vocal sounded much too loud in the mix and the timing didn't feel very cohesive with the groove of the instrumental. I'm sorry to turn this down for now.
Selected By Nona Curator
on TRUE FRIENDS (feat. SARAH) by TKAT, SARAH · 2 months ago
Declined
Hello TKAT and SARAH! Production wise, it's pretty solid. I like how groovy and funky and rhythmic it is. Unfortunately, I will be declining because the I didn't really like how the vocals came in. I was kind of shocked, I didn't know what was going on for a b...
Alejandro Badia Curator
on Side Effects by Clockwork Lemons · 2 months ago
Declined
Hey, thanks for the submission! The song is not bad, the production is solid... I like the vibe on the drums, the bass line is also nice and the melodies have a cool vibe... nice atmosphere in general! Unfortunately I didn't feel the vocals as much as I would...
Rave Sector Curator
on Side Effects by Clockwork Lemons · 2 months ago
Declined
Hey, Thx for sending your tune. The song has a nice idea, but I am not a big fan of the kick drum... It's a bit too hard IMO.
Laurelanne Davis Curator
on Side Effects by Clockwork Lemons · 2 months ago
Added
https://open.spotify.com/track/58RmI36nZR98f08kTzVYBQ?si=c29b21e1f494462a Thank you so much for submitting this one. I'm loving this nostalgia-driven late 80s/early 90s vibe. The production is spot on, and your voice captures that era.
amplaylists Curator
on Side Effects by Clockwork Lemons · 2 months ago
Declined
The sound design, sample selection, and the arrangement of the track conveys musical movement and I find the melody quite striking. Conversely, the track overall musical direction shifts the stylistic leaning of my playlist towards a lofi and indie rock so I h...
Sounds Of Meow Curator
on Side Effects by Clockwork Lemons · 2 months ago
Declined
Hello and thank you for submission. Song is nicely produced and mixed, however it's not in our genre range, so we have to pass on this one. Kind Regards
acoustic tides Curator
on Side Effects by Clockwork Lemons · 2 months ago
Declined
Hi Clockwork Lemons! Thanks for sharing this track with me. The synths and the catchy vocals were truly engaging. I’m truly sorry for declining this track as I’m not connecting with the house beats as I’m looking for a more syncopated or steady groove for my I...
Grubby Curator
on Side Effects by Clockwork Lemons · 2 months ago
Declined
Hey there, Clockwork Lemons - thanks for the submission. Your track has a nice, warm sound with plenty of space in the mix. I thought there was a slight retro feel to this one too, and the vocal had a decent character. For me, the synth patterns & drum arrange...
Dominik Friedrich Curator
on Side Effects by Clockwork Lemons · 2 months ago
Declined
great energy and the vocals and also great drive and the Beat great choice of tempo as well. But for my playlists and taste the Beat also sounds a little bit to much computer produced a little bit too much repetitive and a little bit too much forseeable. What...
Audio Journey Playlists Curator
on Side Effects by Clockwork Lemons · 2 months ago
Declined
I liked the clean production, the panning of the elements and the steady mood of the track. However, though enjoyable, the overall mood and structure strayed from my current selection that leans more towards Indie Folk/Alternative Indie. That said, I'll have t...
How this board works
- Every campaign here was posted with the artist's permission, chosen at checkout. Artists can switch it off from their dashboard at any time.
- Campaigns are posted once every curator has replied, so no curator sees another's feedback while reviewing. We publish the full text, including declines.
- Reviews an artist has disputed are hidden until resolved.
- Placements are verified against Spotify. Follower counts are the latest we have for each playlist.
Your campaign could be next on the board.