Every public campaign. Every curator's verdict.
Artists who opted in have their campaign posted here in full: which curators listened, who added the track, who declined, and exactly what they wrote. Artists and curators reply to each other in the open. Nothing is edited or cherry-picked.
Opted-in campaigns in full: every curator's verdict and feedback, declines included.
Vibe Agency - Asia Curator
on Fearless and Surrender by James Johnson · 3 weeks ago
Declined
Hey there! We like that female voice sync along with the beat and warm melodies. However the overall tone of singing feels a bit too sweet/sugary for us personally, which doesn't fit quite nice among other tracks with slightly faster pace and deeper/introspect...
Lim K. Curator
on Fearless and Surrender by James Johnson · 4 weeks ago
Declined
ice level of detail in the production, but some of the processing feels a little too noticeable for my taste. I think pulling back a few of the effects and letting more of the natural tone come through could give the track a warmer, more personal feel. There’s...
Stereofox Curator
on Fearless and Surrender by James Johnson · 4 weeks ago
Declined
Hey, thanks for the submission! A really warm tune and nice synths/beat but the song felt way too familiar and polished/digital. Also, a bit too romantic for us. Wishing you all the best anyway!
Mood Sculptor Playlists Curator
on Fearless and Surrender by James Johnson · 4 weeks ago
Declined
Hey Jade Si'mone, I'm afraid I'll have to pass on your submission as I didn't feel like the quality of the mixing was up to my standards. The vocal sounded a bit harsh as it had a sharp and very airy tone, and the audio of the instrumental was lacking depth fo...
Sound Surfer Playlists Curator
on Fearless and Surrender by James Johnson · 4 weeks ago
Declined
Hi Jade Si'mone, the melody of the vocal and the vibe of the song has such a soulful feel which I loved but unfortunately I just felt the production of the song wasn't ready as the vocal mix sounded quite noisy and has a really bright and sibilant quality. I'm...
Svitlana Curator
on Fearless and Surrender by James Johnson · 4 weeks ago
Added
Hello! Thanks for your track! Beautiful vocals, sounds deep and rich! I like the timbre of the voice and the romantic vibe in general. This would be perfect for my playlist.
Silverpalms music Curator
on Fearless and Surrender by James Johnson · 4 weeks ago
Declined
Hello Jade Si’mone, I’m truly captivated by the passionate vocal delivery and the spiritually inspiring songwriting. Unfortunately, I'm sorry but I’m not resonating with the bright vocal mix in this arrangement so I will decline for now. I’m focusing on vocals...
Hugh Caluscusin Curator
on Fearless and Surrender by James Johnson · 4 weeks ago
Declined
This song is a nice one but I'm afraid this is AI? I don't fully support AI-created song just yet. Especially for "Christian songs".
Javier Mandiola Curator
on Fearless and Surrender by James Johnson · 4 weeks ago
Declined
There is a lot to appreciate in the way this song has been put together. The sound feels clean and refined, the vocal delivery brings a fitting presence, and the production gives the track a warm and enjoyable character. That said, its overall pace feels more...
Silverpalms music Curator
on Hold No Secrets by Anka Mason · 1 month ago
Declined
Hi Anka Mason! Your vocal delivery sound so intimate and the harmonies blend so well with the lead vocals. Unfortunately, I’m struggling to resonate with the hissing vocal mix. I’m aiming for vocal tracks that have balanced warmth and tweaked harsh sounds espe...
Svitlana Curator
on Hold No Secrets by Anka Mason · 1 month ago
Added
Hi! Thanks for your track! Beautiful guitar sound! The vocals blend harmoniously with the guitar. A romantic vibe. Welcome to my playlist!
Anderson Júnior Curator
on Hold No Secrets by Anka Mason · 1 month ago
Declined
Notamos que esta música traz calmaria e consistência nas cordas de violão e outros instrumentos que possuem sons orgânicos. Considerando que tenha ajustado equalização para manter boa fidelidade sonora, observo que está adequado aos ouvintes. Sua voz segue afi...
Sound Surfer Playlists Curator
on Hold No Secrets by Anka Mason · 1 month ago
Added
Hi Anka Mason, great songwriting and I think the song's mellow vibe works really well for my playlist so I'll be adding it today, cheers!
Vibe Agency - Asia Curator
on Home Again by Anka Mason · 1 month ago
Declined
Hey there! We appreciate your singing rhythm along with pianos. However your song feels a bit slow and sad, which doesn't fit well among other faster tracks with introspective tone of rnb singing throughout that we usually feature in our 'melodic hip hop & rnb...
Grubby Curator
on Seven Times Infinity by Anka Mason · 1 month ago
Declined
Hey there, Anka - thanks for the submission! your track has a really nice, warm sound. It's got that classic blues grit and heart. I thought the band sounded great, and the harmonies were a nice touch (although I thought they got slightly pitchy just after hal...
Boundless Fusion Curator
on Hold No Secrets by Anka Mason · 1 month ago
Declined
There’s a cool old-school character in this, and I like that the track has a clear sense of identity. The vintage flavor feels a little stronger than what I’m looking for right now, and the chord progression didn’t quite give me that extra “ohhh” moment. Addin...
Boundless Fusion Curator
on Home Again by Anka Mason · 1 month ago
Declined
There’s definitely a distinct character in the way you approach the vocals, and I can tell you’re making an intentional choice with the delivery. It just isn’t quite a vocal style I connect with for this playlist right now. Keep experimenting with different wa...
Boundless Fusion Curator
on Seven Times Infinity by Anka Mason · 1 month ago
Declined
There’s a cool idea in the track, and I like that you’re giving the production its own texture. I did notice a constant layer of white noise sitting underneath, which makes the mix feel a little busy, and some of the harmonies don’t quite feel like they’re spe...
VinylHoops Curator
on Hold No Secrets by Anka Mason · 1 month ago
Declined
Hi again Anka Mason, Another beautiful vocal performance here, and to be honest, the recording of your acoustic instruments is very high. I think this is a great folk rock track, you have a singing style like Stevie Nicks, which I think is high praise. Even af...
Curated By Kenyama Curator
on Hold No Secrets by Anka Mason · 1 month ago
Declined
Hi there Anka. Love the vocal performance on this track. Great overall balance in mix as well. Great sounding track. Unfortunately, the track's mood is just much too somber for my coastal playlist that's only composed of tracks with much brighter leaning progr...
How this board works
- Every campaign here was posted with the artist's permission, chosen at checkout. Artists can switch it off from their dashboard at any time.
- Campaigns are posted once every curator has replied, so no curator sees another's feedback while reviewing. We publish the full text, including declines.
- Reviews an artist has disputed are hidden until resolved.
- Placements are verified against Spotify. Follower counts are the latest we have for each playlist.
Your campaign could be next on the board.