Every public campaign. Every curator's verdict.
Artists who opted in have their campaign posted here in full: which curators listened, who added the track, who declined, and exactly what they wrote. Artists and curators reply to each other in the open. Nothing is edited or cherry-picked.
Sergio Curator
on Did You Ever Feel? by Clockwork Lemons · 4 months ago
Declined
The song has a good melody and there is an interesting sense of progressiveness in its development; however, it differs quite a bit from the style of our playlist. We appreciate you sharing it and we look forward to new releases. Best of luck!!
Rushkeys Curator
on Did You Ever Feel? by Clockwork Lemons · 4 months ago
Declined
Hey Mark, thanks for introducing your song to me. Nice track with a strong meaning and theme. Everything sounds really professional here — strong production, nice lyrics, catchy flow and a very clean overall sound. The vocals and arrangement feel very accessib...
Javier Mandiola Curator
on Did You Ever Feel? by Clockwork Lemons · 4 months ago
Added
Your proposal offers a very pleasant atmosphere thanks to its excellent production and a well-achieved sound quality, where every element is perceived as careful and balanced. You have managed to create a captivating atmosphere, with a professional level that...
Adrian Curator
on Did You Ever Feel? by Clockwork Lemons · 4 months ago
Declined
mix on the production end is well balanced, vocals come through the music so very cleanly and seamlessly. it’s a super clever track but what didn’t quite match up with my personal taste is the lack of a big breakthrough element which i felt would further solid...
VinylHoops Curator
on Did You Ever Feel? by Clockwork Lemons · 4 months ago
Declined
I think this track has a lot of potential, but there are some concerns I'm having about the vocals and the instrumentation. First of all, you have very electronic drums; on top of that you have a lot of chorusing on your vocal performance. Those two add up to...
Recap Curator
on Slow and Steady by mama no likey, Abrielle · 4 months ago
Added
Nice pace here, it really takes its time and builds a steady momentum that fits the playlist energy. I’m going to add it to rock for people, great groove and energy, send more when you’ve got them.
CountryOutlaw Curator
on Slow and Steady by mama no likey, Abrielle · 4 months ago
Declined
Hey Mama, No Likey, the arrangement sometimes feels a touch crowded which blunts the main motif, but the chorus hook really sticks and has real singalong potential. I'm going to decline this one for the playlist for now.
ErnestCLuiz Curator
on Slow and Steady by mama no likey, Abrielle · 4 months ago
Declined
Nice feel but the track’s overall roughness leans a little raw for the playlist’s smoother classic and soft rock mood. Your vocal tone really sells the grit though, it’s got character. Sorry, I’m declining this time.
oldbandtee Curator
on Slow and Steady by mama no likey, Abrielle · 4 months ago
Added
Nice groove here, the pocket really holds the song together and gives it that patient drive I want on the garage rock vibes list. I’ll add it, and I’d love to hear what you do next.
StuckIn1984 Curator
on Slow and Steady by mama no likey, Abrielle · 4 months ago
Added
Nice work, Mama No Likey. The hook really locks in and that steady groove pulls the track forward, so I’m adding it to the Modern and classic rock playlist. Keep sending stuff that rides that momentum.
RockRecords Curator
on Slow and Steady by mama no likey, Abrielle · 4 months ago
Added
Nice track, Mama No Likey. The groove and patient momentum pull me in and the guitar edge gives it character.
Claudio Suriano Curator
on Slow and Steady by mama no likey, Abrielle · 4 months ago
Declined
Thanks for your submission, Mama No Likey. It's an interesting rock production. I enjoy the chours at 0:30. However, the reason why I am declining is that I'm interested in more edgy and contemporary Indie Rock productions and not in classic rock ones. Keep in...
Sandeep Raghavan Curator
on Slow and Steady by mama no likey, Abrielle · 4 months ago
Added
No written feedback with this decision.
Bryan Rolli Curator
on Slow and Steady by mama no likey, Abrielle · 4 months ago
Declined
Thanks for your submission. I like the driving grooves, anthemic choruses and crisp production in this song. However, I'm looking for more aggressive hard rock and metal tunes for my playlist, while this song has more of an alt-rock/roots rock sound to me. I'm...
VinylHoops Curator
on Slow and Steady by mama no likey, Abrielle · 4 months ago
Added
Hey Mama No likey, Thanks for the sub, this is a great fit for Rock Roadtrip! Feel free to resubmit in 2 weeks for a replacement! Feel free to shout us out on IG and we'll do the same for you!
Lim K. Curator
on Slow and Steady by mama no likey, Abrielle · 4 months ago
Declined
This one has a bit of a garage band feel that doesn’t quite line up with my taste for the playlist, so it’s not a match right now. Maybe polishing the production and tightening the overall sound could help it land better. Thanks for sending this through, feel...
Gerald Curator
on Slow and Steady by mama no likey, Abrielle · 4 months ago
Declined
I find the instrumental tracks to be tight, smooth vocal delivery throughout. It's a solid track but I tend to gravitate towards songs with a much edgier arrangement but that's just because of my own musical taste
Javier Mandiola Curator
on Slow and Steady by mama no likey, Abrielle · 4 months ago
Declined
A great start with well-crafted guitars, providing energy and power from the beginning, reflecting dedication and high-quality production. The structure is very well developed, allowing each section to flow coherently and maintain interest throughout the song....
Don's Tunes Curator
on Slow and Steady by mama no likey, Abrielle · 4 months ago
Declined
Hi! Thanks for the submission! This is one really cool tune with great energy and engaging, expressive sound. I definitely like it but for my playlists I focus on a more classic blues / blues-rock style with a bit darker tone and mood. Keep it up!
Lost Velvet Curator
on Slow and Steady by mama no likey, Abrielle · 4 months ago
Declined
Thank you for the submission! The track has a really cool energetic chorus and great production. It didn’t feel like a great fit for our playlists as we are on the lookout for something darker and more melancholic!
How this board works
- Every campaign here was posted with the artist's permission, chosen at checkout. Artists can switch it off from their dashboard at any time.
- Campaigns are posted once every curator has replied, so no curator sees another's feedback while reviewing. We publish the full text, including declines.
- Reviews an artist has disputed are hidden until resolved.
- Placements are verified against Spotify. Follower counts are the latest we have for each playlist.
Your campaign could be next on the board.