Every public campaign. Every curator's verdict.
Artists who opted in have their campaign posted here in full: which curators listened, who added the track, who declined, and exactly what they wrote. Artists and curators reply to each other in the open. Nothing is edited or cherry-picked.
Opted-in campaigns in full: every curator's verdict and feedback, declines included.
Hanne Curator
on Ballerina by Citeable Boy · 5 days ago
Declined
Hi there and thank you for submitting your song! A pretty nice and soothing tune. The instrumental sound clean and in synergy with the vocals. I like the lyrics because they are pretty relatable as well. Clean work on the production and the rhythm as well but...
amplaylists Curator
on Psycho valentine by Crimson scenes · 5 days ago
Declined
I'm sorry for letting go of this track at the moment. The song has a really nice arrangement but the digital artifacts in the track feel a bit too prominent that it affects the texture of the song.
Anderson Júnior Curator
on Ballerina by Citeable Boy · 6 days ago
Added
I note that at the beginning of the stanza section we can perceive a chord modulation that shifts modes from minor to major, followed by cadence resolutions. We hear instruments that, by their quality, have fidelity. Your voice continues to sing well and your...
Claudio Suriano Curator
on Ballerina by Citeable Boy · 6 days ago
Declined
Nice sophisticated harmony. I enjoy the bass line being a pedal most of the time. Lovely strings arpeggios. Nice rock groove starting at 1:14. However, the reason why I am passing is that I'm not interested in productions with strings for my indie playlists. K...
Konstantin Curator
on Psycho valentine by Crimson scenes · 6 days ago
Declined
Hello there! thank you very much for sharing your song with us. Appreciate that. Cool melodies, nice performance. However, the mix and master sound very unballanced and unpolished. Sounds very overcompressed and not natural... Keep polishing your craft, keep o...
SoundSafari Playlists Curator
on Psycho valentine by Crimson scenes · 6 days ago
Added
Hi there! I really enjoyed the way the melody sounded with the chords in the arrangement as it made the track sound cohesive to listen to. This will be a great addition to my playlist. Thank you!
Mood Playlists Curator
on Psycho valentine by Crimson scenes · 6 days ago
Declined
This is a solid rock track; I particularly enjoyed the strong vocals and the excellent guitar work, which really sets the mood. However, I found the overall song structure a little predictable, and I'm currently searching for material with a more distinctive e...
Daily Dosa Playlists Curator
on Ballerina by Citeable Boy · 6 days ago
Declined
Hi Citeable Boy, I was quite into the fusion of bossa nova and soft rock arrangements, and your romantic vocals are quite pleasant! I was into the heartfelt songwriting and other elements like the use of synths of this track, however we are searching for more...
Sergio Curator
on Psycho valentine by Crimson scenes · 6 days ago
Added
Hola. La canción tiene una buena introducción, lenta y melódica, con excelentes punteos de guitarra de fondo y una batería profunda que acompaña una voz principal melódica, algo áspera y capaz de alcanzar notas exigentes con naturalidad. Sus cambios de intensi...
Valentina Mandiola Curator
on Psycho valentine by Crimson scenes · 6 days ago
Declined
Psico Valentín comes across as a release that fits well within the genre. Its biggest strength lies in its thoughtful lyrics, but to be specific with you, I'm not completely convinced by the artificial voice. I prioritize authentic performances and a more chee...
Chill Connections Curator
on Ballerina by Citeable Boy · 6 days ago
Declined
Hey, Citeable Boy, how are you? I just listened to Ballerina. Your vocals have a heartfelt, mature quality, while the drums and harmonies create a catchy sound with a nostalgic feel. However, this aesthetic, combined with the more intense climax around 02:12,...
Bryan Rolli Curator
on Formal Resignation by Echovayn · 1 week ago
Declined
Thanks for your submission. I don't accept any songs made with artificial intelligence so I'm going to pass on this one.
omglooitsRaph Curator
on Ballerina by Citeable Boy · 1 week ago
Declined
Good day and thank you for sharing your music! A pretty soothing and relaxing tune for sure. The instrumental sounds clean, good work on those subtle and relaxing influences in there. The vocals drop in at 24 seconds, which is pretty logical for a slow paced s...
VinylHoops Curator
on Ballerina by Citeable Boy · 1 week ago
Declined
Hey Citeable Boy, There's no doubt this is a catchy song, you have wonderful vocals and lovely acoustic instrumentation. However, it's precisely the acoustic sound design that is the reason for the decline. What my playlist is about is really hard rock with ag...
Music of your Mood Curator
on Formal Resignation by Echovayn · 1 week ago
Declined
Hey there! Thanks for this song. The heavy, energetic, and crushing music lines match well with the powerful vocals. The mood of the song is well conveyed by the charismatic and emotional vocals. I like the energy this song brings. I think it's a strong perfor...
the song has a nice gentle mood and well written story but leans a lot more retro than modern and my playlist stay focused on modern. I also do not have a playlist that would work in this genre . And being in playlists where your song matches the genre is not...
Curated By Kenyama Curator
on Ballerina by Citeable Boy · 1 week ago
Declined
Hi there Citeable Boy. Love the atmosphere on this track. Great balanced mix and sound already. This does have a rock feel and arrangement style, however, the track's mood is just much too relaxed and somber for my sunset rock playlist that is composed of trac...
Konstantin Curator
on Ballerina by Citeable Boy · 1 week ago
Declined
Hey there! thank you very much for sharing your song with us. Appreciate that. Great instrumental performance. Many good ideas. However, first of all the vocal melodies didn't feel engaging enough to us, to be quite honest...and secondly, the track is a little...
Mood Playlists Curator
on Ballerina by Citeable Boy · 1 week ago
Declined
I enjoyed listening to your track; the vocals were quite unique, and I appreciated the warmth of the guitar. However, the overall vibe leans a bit too vintage for my playlist, which tends to feature more contemporary sounds. I truly appreciate you sending it m...
Mood Playlists Curator
on Formal Resignation by Echovayn · 1 week ago
Declined
I appreciate you sending this track over. The guitar riffs and drumming really caught my attention! While I enjoy rock, I generally gravitate towards a more polished production style for my playlist. I wish you the best of luck with your music!
How this board works
- Every campaign here was posted with the artist's permission, chosen at checkout. Artists can switch it off from their dashboard at any time.
- Campaigns are posted once every curator has replied, so no curator sees another's feedback while reviewing. We publish the full text, including declines.
- Reviews an artist has disputed are hidden until resolved.
- Placements are verified against Spotify. Follower counts are the latest we have for each playlist.
Your campaign could be next on the board.