Every public campaign. Every curator's verdict.
Artists who opted in have their campaign posted here in full: which curators listened, who added the track, who declined, and exactly what they wrote. Artists and curators reply to each other in the open. Nothing is edited or cherry-picked.
Opted-in campaigns in full: every curator's verdict and feedback, declines included.
Dmytro Curator
on Rag Doll Arrival by Echovayn · 1 day ago
Declined
Hey there! Unfortunately, the song sounds too plastic and odd to me. Especially the vocals: they sound artificial. Sorry, it's not for me. Thank you for the submission!
Lefuturewave Curator
on Rag Doll Arrival by Echovayn · 1 day ago
Declined
Hey, this song has good production and lyrics, but the vocals could have been a bit more convincing, especially during the chorus, in my opinion. You need to work on that next time. For now, unfortunately, I have to decline. Cheers!
Andrew Curator
on Rag Doll Arrival by Echovayn · 1 day ago
Declined
Hey there, I like the vibe and the vision here, it's got some real energy behind it. The balance of elements is also really well done, the relative volume levels in the mixdown is solid. I'd only have liked to hear some unusual or unexpected element for the ge...
John Friday Aworinde Curator
on Rag Doll Arrival by Echovayn · 1 day ago
Declined
Thank you for your submission. The track has a strong heavy-music influence, with an arrangement and overall sonic character that lean toward Metal/Hardcore rather than the Hip-Hop styles featured on our playlist. To preserve the playlist's identity and flow,...
SPNZ Curator
on Rag Doll Arrival by Echovayn · 1 day ago
Declined
Hi there and thanks for submitting your track! This one is really dope and I appreciate the overall creativity of this piece. The overall vibe is very engaging! But the quality of the vocal sound tends to be more synthetic for me. I prefer music that has a lit...
Don's Tunes Curator
on Resilience - Remix by The Fairy Wrens, Hugh Middleton | Out With the In · 1 day ago
Declined
Hi! Thanks for the submission! I really like your expressive, emotional sound and the energy of the track but for my playlists I focus on a more classic blues / blues-rock style with a laid-back, bluesy mood. Keep it up!
Sebastian Wernke-Schmiesing Curator
on Color of the Sound (Gentle Metalcore) by DJ RiccoFX · 1 day ago
Declined
Hey, thanks so much for your submission. Unfortunately, your song was generated by AI. We're not interested in that. Sorry.
Anderson Júnior Curator
on Color of the Sound (Gentle Metalcore) by DJ RiccoFX · 1 day ago
Declined
Notamos que esse título traz uma explicação sobre as cores que representam um fogo que foi descoberto há milhões de anos. Apresentou boa estrutura musical e nesse trecho estrofe pela segunda vez notei algo diferenciado, onde o acompanhamento de guitarra faz to...
Tim Haverman Curator
on Color of the Sound (Gentle Metalcore) by DJ RiccoFX · 1 day ago
Declined
Thanks for sending your track my way. Even though this is obviously an AI song, it has some nice elements musically. If you continue down this path, the vocals need to be more "in the mix" instead of sitting on top. I would also strive to add more uniqueness t...
Indie Idiots Curator
on Rag Doll Arrival by Echovayn · 1 day ago
Declined
Nice vocals and strong production but a bit too straight ahead rock pop. Looking more for indie and alternative here.
Silverpalms music Curator
on Resilience - Remix by The Fairy Wrens, Hugh Middleton | Out With the In · 1 day ago
Declined
Hello The Fairy Wrens, Hugh Middleton, I appreciate the chance to review this track. I’m drawn to the soaring guitar solo and deep basslines. Unfortunately, I will decline because I’m not resonating with the muddy guitars, bass, and recessed drum mix. I’m focu...
Claudio Suriano Curator
on Resilience - Remix by The Fairy Wrens, Hugh Middleton | Out With the In · 2 days ago
Declined
Nice grungy indie rock production. I like the repetitive riff played in unison by bass and guitars. Cool guitar solo starting at 2 minutes and 14 seconds. However, I wished there was more variation in the conversation. After a while, the riff feels too heavy....
Mood Playlists Curator
on Rag Doll Arrival by Echovayn · 2 days ago
Declined
Echovayn brings plenty of punch to the table with Rag Doll Arrival, pushing an aggressive alternative rock drive that definitely has some raw power behind it. The problem comes down to the vocal work. The vocal mix sits awkwardly against the instruments instea...
Yuriy Sumnyk Curator
on Rag Doll Arrival by Echovayn · 2 days ago
Declined
Hi, Echovayn! Thanks for sharing. Your track sounds dynamic and grabs the listener with its powerful female vocals. The electronic elements blend masterfully with the loud drums and heavy riffs. Your song is an interesting musical experience, but I think it’s...
FMD Playlists Curator
on Rag Doll Arrival by Echovayn · 3 days ago
Declined
Hey. Thanks for sharing this song with us. Unfortunately I found this too AI reliant, perhaps with some more human elements in the mix it would be more workable.
FMD Playlists Curator
on Resilience - Remix by The Fairy Wrens, Hugh Middleton | Out With the In · 3 days ago
Declined
Hey. Thanks for sharing this track with us. Nice work - there is a lot of character in the vocal and the band sounds super tight. Although we do feature alternative rock in our playlists, I found this song to have a particularly nostalgic feel, reminiscent of...
Valentina Mandiola Curator
on Rag Doll Arrival by Echovayn · 3 days ago
Declined
The arrival of Rag Doll feels energetic from the start, what attracts me the most is its drive and consistency. However, the lyrics and production differ quite a bit from my personal preference, as I didn’t connect with the mix and mastering. I prefer more coh...
Valentina Mandiola Curator
on Color of the Sound (Gentle Metalcore) by DJ RiccoFX · 3 days ago
Declined
Color of Sound is a release that gradually gains strength and energy as the minutes go by, but to be specific and honest with you, it doesn’t align with the authenticity I’m looking for in my selection. I’m sorry to say that I wasn’t hooked by the artificial p...
SoundSafari Playlists Curator
on Rag Doll Arrival by Echovayn · 3 days ago
Declined
Hi there! I quite enjoyed the booming sound of the drums in the mix. But I will have to pass for now as the vocals sounded a tad too thin in the mix for me. Sorry!
Sound Surfer Playlists Curator
on Rag Doll Arrival by Echovayn · 3 days ago
Declined
Hi Echovayn, the lyrics and instrumental arrangement stood out to me and the track's dark and gritty atmosphere should make it a great fit for my playlist. Unfortunately though the quality of the mix didn't meet my expectations as there was a sharp harshness t...
How this board works
- Every campaign here was posted with the artist's permission, chosen at checkout. Artists can switch it off from their dashboard at any time.
- Campaigns are posted once every curator has replied, so no curator sees another's feedback while reviewing. We publish the full text, including declines.
- Reviews an artist has disputed are hidden until resolved.
- Placements are verified against Spotify. Follower counts are the latest we have for each playlist.
Your campaign could be next on the board.