Loading...
Campaign board

Every public campaign. Every curator's verdict.

Artists who opted in have their campaign posted here in full: which curators listened, who added the track, who declined, and exactly what they wrote. Artists and curators reply to each other in the open. Nothing is edited or cherry-picked.

New campaign Every curator replies with a decision and feedback · from $79
6.8MFollowers across curator playlists
1,255Verified curator playlists
74%Of replies are declines. Published, not hidden.
15hMedian time to a curator reply
100%Of replies shown in full, as written
Daniel Mena Curator on She Looks so Good Tonight by Chris Portka · 3 months ago Declined

Hi! Thanks for sending your track. I think you have a very strong style here, and it works well with the vocal. There’s a nice sense of synergy between the rhythm and the voice, especially in the chorus sections, which is a great point. What I felt is that, in...

Daniel Mena Curator on Better Days by DFalcon · 3 months ago Declined

Hi! Thanks for sending your track. I think there is a very good structure here, and the vocal manages to define themselves well within the song. The style is present, and there are solid elements that help the track feel well-shaped. Perhaps the song could sti...

Anderson Júnior Curator on She Looks so Good Tonight by Chris Portka · 3 months ago Declined

Então, eu ouvi sua música e notamos que seu estilo é mais focado para Soft rock. Os instrumentos acústicos possuem boa qualidade técnica considerando os ajustes de equalização, compressão e efeitos onde objetivo é manter sonoridade bem vestido. O que me chama...

Anderson Júnior Curator on Better Days by DFalcon · 3 months ago Declined

Apresentou boas progressões de acordes e melódicos, além das relações de volume entre instrumentos e vozes. Os instrumentos acústicos apresentam excelentes detalhes sonoras sem perdas significativas aos ouvidos humanos. A silabação de sua voz por exemplo segue...

Yuriy Sumnyk Curator on Setting Sail Into the Mist by Tracy Sabin · 3 months ago Declined

Hi, Tracy Sabin! Thanks for sharing. Your track has a cinematic sound and has the potential to be the soundtrack to a children’s cartoon. The vocals are dreamy, but the verses need more variety, in my opinion. The production is great, and the track is easy to...

acoustic tides Curator on Setting Sail Into the Mist by Tracy Sabin · 3 months ago Declined

Hi Tracy Sabin! Truly sorry for declining this track as I noticed that the overall mix sounded a bit too muddy whereas I’m looking for more piano focused tracks with clarity in the mix. Wishing you all the best!

StuckIn1984 Curator on She Looks so Good Tonight by Chris Portka · 3 months ago Added
Modern and classic rock · 2,197 followers

No written feedback with this decision.

Lim K. Curator on She Looks so Good Tonight by Chris Portka · 3 months ago Declined

Hi!! I can hear the creativity behind this and there are definitely some interesting ideas throughout the track. For me though, the production and mix choices feel a bit unusual in a way that didn’t fully come together, so it’s not quite the right fit for the...

RockRecords Curator on She Looks so Good Tonight by Chris Portka · 3 months ago Added
the real rock playlist · 6,053 followers

No written feedback with this decision.

Lim K. Curator on Better Days by DFalcon · 3 months ago Declined

I can hear the amount of work that went into shaping the sound here, and there are some cool textures throughout. The production feels a bit too processed for my taste though, so it doesn’t quite connect naturally enough for the playlist right now. Letting the...

John Warzala Curator on Better Days by DFalcon · 3 months ago Declined

Hey Dfalcon! Thanks for sending Better Days my way. The production on this is really well done. Your vocal delivery sounds JUST like Daughtry and has his same signature powerhouse voice that carries the song. The instrumentation and arrangement also is very sp...

John Warzala Curator on She Looks so Good Tonight by Chris Portka · 3 months ago Declined

Hey Dfalcon! Thanks for sending Better Days my way. The production on this is really well done. Your vocal delivery sounds JUST like Daughtry, almost indistinguishable! It has his iconic, powerful, driving tone that really carries the track. While I dig this t...

Vibe Agency - Asia Curator on Setting Sail Into the Mist by Tracy Sabin · 3 months ago Declined

Hello! We appreciate your time and efforts you put into creative this creative and positive track. However we're looking for non-vocal based with much deeper & introspective tones throughout tracks for our "ambient dreams" playlist 🙏

Don's Tunes Curator on She Looks so Good Tonight by Chris Portka · 3 months ago Declined

Hi! Thanks for the submission! I really enjoyed the tune - lovely romantic mood and lyrics and authentic, expressive sound. I like your style but for my playlists I fucus on a bit darker in tone, minor in key tracks. Keep it up!

Javier Mandiola Curator on Setting Sail Into the Mist by Tracy Sabin · 3 months ago Declined

Instrumentally, the song presents a level of high professional quality, accompanied by a very well-worked harmony and an extremely pleasant atmosphere that allows one to fully enjoy the proposal. The production is perceived as carefully crafted in every detail...

Sandeep Raghavan Curator on She Looks so Good Tonight by Chris Portka · 3 months ago Declined

Very interesting sound. I loved the guitars. You have a really unique voice too. I loved the way that you have written the lyrics. I just felt that the overall mix was not for me. I feel that the vocal layers are a little too drowned amongst the instrumentatio...

Sandeep Raghavan Curator on Better Days by DFalcon · 3 months ago Declined

Your track has a radiant, uplifting quality that’s easy to enjoy. I loved how the emotion behind it felt genuine, and the overall atmosphere is very pleasant. There’s a beautiful sense of openness in your sound. Personally though, the brightness in the mix was...

oldbandtee Curator on She Looks so Good Tonight by Chris Portka · 3 months ago Added
garage rock vibes · 3,079 followers

No written feedback with this decision.

Claudio Suriano Curator on She Looks so Good Tonight by Chris Portka · 3 months ago Declined

Cool production start with only acoustic guitar, followed by vocals entering at 0:09 together with kick drum. The reason why I am not sharing it is that I'm not interested in productions with kick drum on each beat for my indie roadtrip playlist. Of course, th...

Rushkeys Curator on Better Days by DFalcon · 3 months ago Declined

Hello DFalcon, thanks for sending this. I enjoyed the songwritting, arrangement and the overall flow of the track — everything feels tight, balanced and well played. The band sound comes through clearly and gives it a nice classic indie feel. The vocals are we...

How this board works

  • Every campaign here was posted with the artist's permission, chosen at checkout. Artists can switch it off from their dashboard at any time.
  • Campaigns are posted once every curator has replied, so no curator sees another's feedback while reviewing. We publish the full text, including declines.
  • Reviews an artist has disputed are hidden until resolved.
  • Placements are verified against Spotify. Follower counts are the latest we have for each playlist.

Your campaign could be next on the board.

New campaign Every curator replies with a decision and feedback · from $79