Every public campaign. Every curator's verdict.
Artists who opted in have their campaign posted here in full: which curators listened, who added the track, who declined, and exactly what they wrote. Artists and curators reply to each other in the open. Nothing is edited or cherry-picked.
Opted-in campaigns in full: every curator's verdict and feedback, declines included.
ice level of detail in the production, but some of the processing feels a little too noticeable for my taste. I think pulling back a few of the effects and letting more of the natural tone come through could give the track a warmer, more personal feel. There’s...
Hey, thanks for the submission! A really warm tune and nice synths/beat but the song felt way too familiar and polished/digital. Also, a bit too romantic for us. Wishing you all the best anyway!
No written feedback with this decision.
Hey Jade Si'mone, I'm afraid I'll have to pass on your submission as I didn't feel like the quality of the mixing was up to my standards. The vocal sounded a bit harsh as it had a sharp and very airy tone, and the audio of the instrumental was lacking depth fo...
Hey Tony Frissore, that bass groove is so slick and I loved the rich tone. The track has a really compelling arrangement and the vibe overall is perfect for my playlist. Much love!
Hi Jade Si'mone, the melody of the vocal and the vibe of the song has such a soulful feel which I loved but unfortunately I just felt the production of the song wasn't ready as the vocal mix sounded quite noisy and has a really bright and sibilant quality. I'm...
Hi Tony Frissore, the sound selection and production is so on point and the track has such a nice vibe and groove. I'll be more than happy to share this, best wishes!
Hey Tony Frissore, I loved the introspective vibe and the soulful sound selection. Great work on the production too. I'd love to share this, cheers!
Hey what's up, thanks for the song and good job on the new release! The beat is quite good, It is well produced and I was vibing with it, the bars/lyrics however are not really vibing with me personally if I may be honest, so in conclusion, I have to decline t...
Thank you for the submission. I really appreciate the effort and the overall presentation. The delivery and flow are solid, but the track doesn’t have enough melodic quality for the direction of my playlist. Keep creating and developing your sound.
I appreciate the full tone the rhythm section gave the track. I also liked the main musical theme. However, as I listened, I was hoping for it to be a bit brighter and to have a bit more development in phrasing and dynamics. That said, I'll have to pass for no...
Hello! Thanks for your track! Beautiful vocals, sounds deep and rich! I like the timbre of the voice and the romantic vibe in general. This would be perfect for my playlist.
Hey there! From the beginning, the song shows a clear style. The choice of sounds within the beat is interesting and helps build a distinct identity, which gives the overall concept a lot of personality. As the track develops, though, I feel the structure lose...
Hey Tony. Love the atmosphere on this track. Great progression and instrumentation that really presents an introspective space. The instrumentation feels like it already fits my focus beats playlist, but unfortunately, this track's spoken word vocal just makes...
Hey Tony, thanks for the submission. I really enjoyed the dreamy, cinematic atmosphere here. The beat and groovy bass give the track a smooth flow, while the spoken elements sit nicely within the lush, spacious production and add to its hazy character. For my...
Ooh, there’s a lovely warmth to the track, but the vintage character feels a little stronger than what I’m curating at the moment. I’d love to hear that same charm paired with a fresher, slightly more current feel. The overall character is still really nice, a...
I really like the sense of scale in this, it feels like the track has a whole little scene playing out behind it :) It just gets a bit too cinematic for the kind of sound I’m trying to keep on the playlist, especially with how much the arrangement builds aroun...
There’s a lot of precision in the production here, and I can tell you’ve put plenty of thought into making everything line up nicely :) For my playlist, though, it feels a little too polished and controlled, like some of the natural movement has been ironed ou...
Hey, Digging the groove in this one. I don't focus on spoken word and find it quite distracting. I prefer songs with more focus on melodic progression in the instruments and not constantly a vocal upfront. Wish you all the best with your release! Cheers, Jens
Hi Tony! Thank you for sharing “Stolen Valor” with us. We admire the track's motifs but in our opinion it does not match the playlist style. We will have to pass this one on. Feel free to send in more to us :)
How this board works
- Every campaign here was posted with the artist's permission, chosen at checkout. Artists can switch it off from their dashboard at any time.
- Campaigns are posted once every curator has replied, so no curator sees another's feedback while reviewing. We publish the full text, including declines.
- Reviews an artist has disputed are hidden until resolved.
- Placements are verified against Spotify. Follower counts are the latest we have for each playlist.
Your campaign could be next on the board.