Every public campaign. Every curator's verdict.
Artists who opted in have their campaign posted here in full: which curators listened, who added the track, who declined, and exactly what they wrote. Artists and curators reply to each other in the open. Nothing is edited or cherry-picked.
The melodic writing is strong and emotionally grounded. I appreciated how naturally the song flows and how cohesive the musical ideas feel. There’s a sincerity in the songwriting that stands out. Personally though, the vocal tone felt slightly too processed fo...
Hi, Brian David! Thanks for sharing. The beginning of your song captivates the listener with its soulful vocals and a slight hoarseness that adds a special charm to the sound. Every word the singer utters penetrates the listener’s heart, creating a spiritual a...
Thanks for your submission, David. I love the muted upright piano used in the verse. However, the reason why I am passing is that I'm not interested in productions with kick drum on each beat for my indie playlist. Of course, this is just my opinion.
No written feedback with this decision.
Hey Brian, thank you for sharing your song! I think that the drum beat was really good, there are some really cool parts in the song that I've really enjoyed, well done with the overall feel that you have came up with. I think that you have some really interes...
Thank you for sending your track. I think the song has a structure that works very well. The rhythmic side gives the track a lot of identity, keeping it dynamic and engaging from beginning to end. The area where I feel there is the most room to grow is the voc...
No written feedback with this decision.
Dear Brian, thank you very much for sharing your music with us! "The Echo in Your Soul" features nice melodies and great production, your work is polished and well-crafted. However, the sound, vibe, energy, and specific sub-genre aren’t quite what we feature o...
Thanks for your submission. Nice slow 4 to floor groove. So nice and back in the pocket. Great vocal, too. In saying that, I fell this is a little too conventional sounding for my playlists. I'm after something a little more alternative with both the sound and...
your vocals such a distinct and radio friendly tone, love that the entire production is centered around it. it’s a super clever track really but i just kinda wish the choruses would open up even more as i felt that the lead up from the verses was already dynam...
No written feedback with this decision.
Hey there! We enjoy that voice rhythm with instruments in your song. However the overall tempo is a little slow and relaxing for us personally, which doesn't fit much stronger and energetic/upbeat side of our 'rock legends' playlist. And we usually place dream...
Hey, Nice bassline and smooth vocal. This one however feels a bit too digital and strong for my list. I prefer more slow paced guitar songs, more a style like Charlotte Day Wilson. Just my personal preference of course. Totally fine if this was the vibe you we...
Impressive songwriting in this track! However, I felt that the vocals had a bit too much processing in the mix for my taste. Apologies but I will have to decline this submission.
Hi! Thanks for the submission. I like the emotional lyrics and mood of the tune but for my playlists I focus on a more classic blues / folk with a bit darker tone and mood. Keep it up!
No written feedback with this decision.
Hey there, Brian - thanks for the submission. This heartfelt track has a warm sound, and an intimate atmosphere. I thought the production was really good (perhaps the ducking compression in a little too noticeable, but overall very good sound). The vocal has a...
From its very beginning, the song possesses an intense depth with a soft, clear, and melancholic melody. Its instrumentation is perfectly suited to the theme, with subtle percussion and synthesizer touches accompanying the melody. The simultaneously raspy and...
Hey Brian David, I think the vocal performance was powerful and I was drawn to the richness of your voice but where the song didn't convince me was the quality of the instrumental. The audio sounds very muffled, grainy, and overall just lacking in quality. I'm...
Hello Brian, thanks for sharing this with me. Knowing the story behind the song gives it a lot of meaning, and I can hear how personal it is. The vocal feels sincere, and the songwriting carries that emotion really well. It’s not quite right for my playlist, t...
How this board works
- Every campaign here was posted with the artist's permission, chosen at checkout. Artists can switch it off from their dashboard at any time.
- Campaigns are posted once every curator has replied, so no curator sees another's feedback while reviewing. We publish the full text, including declines.
- Reviews an artist has disputed are hidden until resolved.
- Placements are verified against Spotify. Follower counts are the latest we have for each playlist.
Your campaign could be next on the board.