Every public campaign. Every curator's verdict.
Artists who opted in have their campaign posted here in full: which curators listened, who added the track, who declined, and exactly what they wrote. Artists and curators reply to each other in the open. Nothing is edited or cherry-picked.
Opted-in campaigns in full: every curator's verdict and feedback, declines included.
Michael Wilkie Curator
on Ivy House by Echovayn · 1 week ago
Declined
Really nice songwriting here. Solid song structure with effective transitions. I would get more specific and detailed with vocal prompts as this vocal is fairly common. in your DAW isolate the vocal stem and apply a de-esser and adjust reverb. Some spectral ar...
Lissa Timmerman Curator
on Ivy House by Echovayn · 1 week ago
Declined
Hey there , fantastic track . Really appreciate the county vibes , catchy vocals and melodies . However , for my playlist , I lookout for a bit more smooth and dreamy style vocal content , Billie Eilish style . Good luck! I will have to skip this one .
Juhász Benedek Curator
on Fire In Her Eyes by Dave Stefanic · 1 week ago
Declined
Hey there, thank you for sharing your song with me! I think that the song started of really nicely, very well done with the overall feel, it was really cool in my opinion. I think that you are a great singer, well done with the chord progression it was really...
Matthew Lucky Curator
on Fire In Her Eyes by Dave Stefanic · 1 week ago
Declined
I appreciate the character and thought you put into this track, especially the way the different elements come together. Unfortunately, the overall sound texture doesn’t quite connect with the direction of my playlist, so I’ll have to pass on this one. Keep re...
Don's Tunes Curator
on Fire In Her Eyes by Dave Stefanic · 1 week ago
Declined
Hi! Thanks for sending this track. I really enjoyed its emotional, heartfelt lyrics and your vocals but for my playlists I focus on a more classic blues / folk with a bit darker, minor in key mood. Keep it up!
Curated By Kenyama Curator
on Ivy House by Echovayn · 1 week ago
Declined
Hi there Echovayn. Hearing a very country leaning style on this track. However, this track's arrangement is leaning on a very somber ballad styled mood which isn't really a character/mood present on my sunset rock playlist which this is closest to. The tracks...
Silverpalms music Curator
on Ivy House by Echovayn · 1 week ago
Declined
Hello Echovayn, Thanks for sharing this. I’m drawn to the melancholic vocal delivery and I can feel the heartbreaking emotions in the vocal tone. Unfortunately, I will decline as I noticed the rich Country leaning vocal tone and the digital feel in the drum mi...
Sandeep Raghavan Curator
on Ivy House by Echovayn · 1 week ago
Declined
Your track has a beautiful emotional quality to it. The mood feels expressive and thoughtful. The writing feels honest and heartfelt. I really enjoyed the power behind your voice. Personally though, the mix sounded slightly too bright for my listening preferen...
Sandeep Raghavan Curator
on Ship on Land by Echovayn · 1 week ago
Declined
The songwriting is strong and the emotional direction feels very authentic. I appreciated the depth of the melody. Personally though, the mood leaned slightly too melancholic for my playlists. That’s just my personal opinion and I completely respect your creat...
Sandeep Raghavan Curator
on Love What You Do by William Wyatt · 1 week ago
Declined
You have a killer voice. I loved the performance. The melodies are beautifully written and the songwriting feels sincere. I enjoyed the emotional clarity throughout the track. The musical direction feels intentional. Personally though, the brightness of the mi...
Hendrik Akyel Curator
on Love What You Do by William Wyatt · 1 week ago
Declined
Hey thanks for the submission. That is a very chill track with a quite melancholic atmosphere. While the vocals were quite smooth, for me personally some of the lines could have also been developed a bit further. Have a nice day! Hendrik
Dominik Friedrich Curator
on Love What You Do by William Wyatt · 1 week ago
Declined
Vocal tone and very solid production sound as well. But for my playlist and for my taste and ears as well, the chord progression sounds a little bit too foreseeable and repetitive and mainstream. I also miss a vocal melody that sounds a bit more surprising, an...
Lissa Timmerman Curator
on Love What You Do by William Wyatt · 1 week ago
Declined
Hi there! Great track. Really liked the vocals , vibes and energy . The instrumental and the melodies are appealing . However , currently I am looking for a bit more soft and soothing content Alt-J style. Rest ,the track has got some real good potential. Good...
you do you Curator
on Love What You Do by William Wyatt · 1 week ago
Added
No written feedback with this decision.
Daniel Mena Curator
on Love What You Do by William Wyatt · 1 week ago
Declined
Hey there! I really enjoyed the melodies throughout the track. They create a nice synergy within the mix, and I think the vocal brings an attractive character that fits naturally with the overall style. The song has a pleasant atmosphere, and I appreciate how...
Boundless Fusion Curator
on Love What You Do by William Wyatt · 1 week ago
Declined
There’s a warm, easygoing character to this track, and I appreciate the personality in the instrumentation :) The country influence isn’t quite in line with the sound I’m collecting for my playlist right now, so I’ll have to pass on this one. Exploring a diffe...
Sounds of Riley Curator
on Love What You Do by William Wyatt · 1 week ago
Declined
Thanks for sharing the track. Love how straightforward your track sounded for my ears. Also, the production is solid. However, I think the vocals were a bit forward for my taste, which doesn't sit well with my preferences for my playlist. With this being said,...
Adrian Curator
on Love What You Do by William Wyatt · 1 week ago
Declined
really love how full the sound is on the production end, vocals are totally made for the radio. it's a super clever track really but i just kinda wish the choruses would open up even more as i felt that the lead up from the verses was already dynamically stron...
Dizzy Boy Curator
on Ship on Land by Echovayn · 1 week ago
Declined
Appreciate the submission! I’m currently looking for tracks that create a stronger connection with the overall mood of the playlist, rather than simply matching one part of the sound. I’m not quite getting that connection with this one, so I’ll pass for now. T...
Hendrik Akyel Curator
on Ship on Land by Echovayn · 1 week ago
Declined
Hey thanks for the submission. Loving the dreamy and laid back vibe here with a nostalgic atmosphere. The vocal writing was quite smooth, but for me personally the vocals still felt a bit too thin and airy in the mix. Cheers! Hendrik
How this board works
- Every campaign here was posted with the artist's permission, chosen at checkout. Artists can switch it off from their dashboard at any time.
- Campaigns are posted once every curator has replied, so no curator sees another's feedback while reviewing. We publish the full text, including declines.
- Reviews an artist has disputed are hidden until resolved.
- Placements are verified against Spotify. Follower counts are the latest we have for each playlist.
Your campaign could be next on the board.