Every public campaign. Every curator's verdict.
Artists who opted in have their campaign posted here in full: which curators listened, who added the track, who declined, and exactly what they wrote. Artists and curators reply to each other in the open. Nothing is edited or cherry-picked.
Opted-in campaigns in full: every curator's verdict and feedback, declines included.
Hey Yasuha. Hearing a good flowing arrangement already on the track. However, there's something about the sound of the vocal that I didn't connect with as much as I think I could have. I do think it's how it was recorded or mixed. It's a bit too thin with a ve...
Hey there! We appreciate your careful voice sync along with creative melodies and warm beat. However the overall vibe feels a bit nostalgic with those melodies and somewhat even a little moody/thoughtful with the tone of your vocal, which doesn't fit quite nic...
Hi there! Great track. Really enjoyed the vibes and the instrumental . However , for our playlist , we lookout for a bit old school Snoop Dogg style rap stuff. Rest ,the track has got some real good potential. Good luck! can't wait to hear more tracks from you...
Notamos que esta música possui melodia secundário marcante mais os componentes de bateria que possuem sons manipulados por meio de filtro passa-baixa e a ressonância. Vimos que sua voz segue sincronizado na maioria dos trechos musicais e qualidade sonora també...
Hi there! Great track. Really liked the rap vocals and vibes . However , the overall instrumental and the mix didn't sound that convincing . Rest ,the track has got some real good potential. Good luck! can't wait to hear more tracks from you.
Hey Yasuha, While I can definitely appreciate your bars and your sound design, I would have avoided mixing in gentler chords and samples, or singing. We're really going for a more gangsta rap and aggressive vocal performance combination for the playlist; the g...
Hey, Nice sounding bassline in this one. personally felt the mix needed work. I like some more dynamics over the mix. Also the chorus the vocal sat well in the mix but the verses the vocals felt really quiet and quite muffled in the mix. They were also missing...
Hi Yasuha, I really liked the chill ambience of the beat and the catchy hook but unfortunately the vocal sounded too quiet in the mix during the verses and overall I felt like the volume and dynamics of the vocal could have been more consistent. I'm sorry to t...
I think you have a good song because the verses are good, but it would need a catchier chorus that convinces me more. I wish you luck.
Hello there! I'm sorry to say that I will be declining your track because the quality of the production didn't meet my standards. I think the direction is definitely correct but the sound selection is still lacking for me. Your raps are good, I love that you i...
Hey Yasuha, thanks for sharing your track! I like the moody atmosphere and the raw vibe, which gives the music a distinct character. There’s a nice sense of attitude in the overall sound, and the darker mood works well with the style you’re exploring. For my h...
Hey there, Yashua - thanks for the submission. Your track has a unique sound and real home-made, underground feel. The vocal has character, but the mix is very unbalanced. The vocal goes from way too quiet to way too loud. The flow and the sung parts are quite...
I liked the atmospheric production and the way the Auto-Tuned vocal blends into the spacey instrumental. The main issue for me was the lack of an immediately recognizable vocal hook. At four minutes, I wanted a stronger moment that would stay with me after lis...
Hi! Thanks for sharing your track! The rap sounds rhythmic and engaging, and the low vocal timbre gives it a deep sound. The instrumental blends smoothly with the vocals, but the overall vibe feels a bit monotonous for my playlists. There's a missing punchline...
After a careful evaluation, I feel your song creates a relaxed atmosphere, supported by good sound quality and very well-executed production. However, when comparing it with the criteria of my current curation, I feel that both the vocal performance and the so...
Hi there! The beat had a very catchy groove. But I will be passing for now as the vocal mix sounds a tad too thin making it a tad too difficult to understand. Apologies!
Creo que la canción está bien producida y suena bien, pero me falta algo para que me convenza del todo. La melodía principal y el estribillo no me han llegado enamorar de todo
I truly enjoyed the innovative instrumental work here; it carries a wonderful vibe and some truly memorable melodic ideas. However, the vocals and overall mix didn't quite resonate with my curation style on this occasion. I appreciate you sharing your music an...
Hi there! Thanks for this track. Catchy and emotive vocal performance; the lyrics are well presented. The music enhances the overall track's vibe. I like the mix of smooth melodies and catchy beats. I like listening to this track, and I appreciate your work. B...
Hey Ronin, thanks for sending your track Half Astronaut, Half martian our way. Loved the lyrics but we feel the track is a bit slow paced. We will sadly have to skip this one. Keep making more music.
How this board works
- Every campaign here was posted with the artist's permission, chosen at checkout. Artists can switch it off from their dashboard at any time.
- Campaigns are posted once every curator has replied, so no curator sees another's feedback while reviewing. We publish the full text, including declines.
- Reviews an artist has disputed are hidden until resolved.
- Placements are verified against Spotify. Follower counts are the latest we have for each playlist.
Your campaign could be next on the board.