Every public campaign. Every curator's verdict.
Artists who opted in have their campaign posted here in full: which curators listened, who added the track, who declined, and exactly what they wrote. Artists and curators reply to each other in the open. Nothing is edited or cherry-picked.
Opted-in campaigns in full: every curator's verdict and feedback, declines included.
There’s a cool idea in the track, and I like that you’re giving the production its own texture. I did notice a constant layer of white noise sitting underneath, which makes the mix feel a little busy, and some of the harmonies don’t quite feel like they’re spe...
Hi, Anka Mason, John F. Mason! Thanks for sharing. First of all, I want to highlight the energetic and charismatic vocals. The melody is energetic and has a lot of depth. Your track has potential, but I think it could use a bit more aggression. I hope you unde...
Hi, MindMassage, ST3PH, Dewwy, Paul Silve! Your track has a magical vibe and draws the listener in with its hypnotic flow. The beat is multi-layered—I especially want to highlight the synths in the background. Your track is great, but I didn’t listen to it all...
Thanks for sending this track. However, I think this lacks grit, which is essential for my alt-rock playlist. So, I'll decline for now due to this. Still, I appreciate you sending this track. Best wishes
When evaluating your track, I found the production to be well executed, creating a polished, cohesive, and consistent sound throughout the song. Overall, it feels like a solid and enjoyable production. However, when considering the vocal performance against th...
Hey hey, I like the production quality here in terms of relative volume levels, and the singing quality is also top-notch, as is the vocal processing. I think the tracks could use some glueing together, however - if you haven't, try running all tracks through...
Hey Nashville Exile, super catchy song with a contagious energy and I think it's quite perfect for my Roadtrip Mood playlist. Much love!
Hey there, thank you for sharing your song! I think that the song had a really interesting feel, well done with the mood that you have created, it sounded really interesting in my opinion. I think that you have a great voice, well done with the overall feel th...
Hey there! Thank you very much for sharing your music with us. Really appreciate that! The song has a strong foundation for a good indie rock track. the guitar, drums and other instrumental performance is engaging, giving it a solid musical backbone. However,...
Greetings! And thank you for sharing your song! A nice and vibrant instrumental, I like the trumpet in there. The production is clean as well, you have a great voice! The vocals drop in at 10seconds which I believe is good for audience retention. The pace of t...
Hi there and thank you for sharing your song! The production is clean, I like the subtle bass in there, great work on the instrumental! The vocals drop in at 9 seconds which I like, this is good for audience retention I believe. The pass of the song is a bit t...
Thank you so much for sending this track. I enjoyed the listen and appreciated the energy you brought into the music. Unfortunately, the overall fit isn’t quite there for this playlist at the moment. Keep creating and hopefully we’ll connect with another song.
Your flow has a really natural rhythm, and your confidence behind the mic is easy to notice. There’s a genuine quality here that makes the record feel memorable. We’re excited to include it.
Hi there thank you for your submission. Nice guitar work you bring here a very dynamic and organic flow running through the song. The vocal is a little less up my alley sadly but that might be me though. Arrangements work well for the song! Kind regards , Jell...
Thanks for sending this my way. I’m being more selective about the overall atmosphere because the playlist has developed a fairly specific sound. This one has a different kind of energy from most of the current selection, and I didn’t want to add something tha...
Hi there, thanks for the song. Good music lines; really great instrumental playing. The vocal line is melodic, emotional and powerful at the same. It was a good performance. But I must say that I need a more energetic and aggressive sound for my rock playlist....
Hi there! We appreciate your singing rhythm along with warm guitar riffs. However the overall tempo of your song is a little slow for us personally and the tone of your singing is a little too light and even sweet for our taste, which doesn't fit quite nice am...
Hi there Anka. Hearing a great performance on this track. Love the vocal and character. This does have a very slight soul feel in progression and vocal performance, but the mood on the arrangement is just much too somber for the more sultry leaning mood of my...
Hey there. I enjoyed the playful instrumentals and the groovy vocals. The chorus is really catchy. However in general I'm looking for a bit more heavy indie rock for my playlist. Sorry.
Thanks for sending this in, I really liked the energy and the way the vocals sit on the beat. The flow feels effortless, and the overall vibe works nicely for the playlist. Great job, and keep it up.
How this board works
- Every campaign here was posted with the artist's permission, chosen at checkout. Artists can switch it off from their dashboard at any time.
- Campaigns are posted once every curator has replied, so no curator sees another's feedback while reviewing. We publish the full text, including declines.
- Reviews an artist has disputed are hidden until resolved.
- Placements are verified against Spotify. Follower counts are the latest we have for each playlist.
Your campaign could be next on the board.