Loading...
Campaign board

Every public campaign. Every curator's verdict.

Artists who opted in have their campaign posted here in full: which curators listened, who added the track, who declined, and exactly what they wrote. Artists and curators reply to each other in the open. Nothing is edited or cherry-picked.

New campaign Every curator replies with a decision and feedback · from $79
6.8MFollowers across curator playlists
1,255Verified curator playlists
74%Of replies are declines. Published, not hidden.
15hMedian time to a curator reply
100%Of replies shown in full, as written
acoustic tides Curator on Quiet Morning by Two Spoons · 3 months ago Declined

Hi Two Spoons! The beautiful guitar melodies sounded so pleasant to listen to. So sorry to decline this track because the mix of the vocals seemed a bit buried in the mix while the drums sounded a bit dominant in this arrangement. I'm actually looking for trac...

MarkEEvans Curator on Quiet Morning by Two Spoons · 3 months ago Added
Indie Folk Finds · 2,304 followers

No written feedback with this decision.

RockRecords Curator on Quiet Morning by Two Spoons · 3 months ago Added
shoegaze & indie · 2,821 followers

No written feedback with this decision.

Manuel A. Gonzalez Curator on Quiet Morning by Two Spoons · 3 months ago Added
Indie Folk / Acoustic · 2,899 followers

No written feedback with this decision.

omglooitsRaph Curator on Quiet Morning by Two Spoons · 3 months ago Added
Folk: Freedom Folk · 3,434 followers

No written feedback with this decision.

Selected By Nona Curator on Quiet Morning by Two Spoons · 3 months ago Declined

Hi there! I will be declining your track for the following reason/s: - I feel like mix wise, it sounds a little muffled, especially vocally. It could be a little clearer for sure. - I also think it's a little too country for my playlists. If it leaned towards...

Dominik Friedrich Curator on Quiet Morning by Two Spoons · 3 months ago Declined

Bweautiful song nd message, love the energy as well and the lyrics and storytelling but for my lists and taste the vocals sound ab it too quiet in the mix and it seems that there is a kind of distorting filter on it in the verse which feels a bit too unorganic...

Ken's Collection Curator on Quiet Morning by Two Spoons · 3 months ago Added
Cozy Indie Vibe · 4,192 followers

Hey Two Spoons, hearing a good relaxed atmosphere on the track fitting for the style of the playlist. The good middle sections with the harmonies/vocals make the track fit. I'll be adding this, thanks!

MelancholySeason Curator on Song to Carol by Chris Portka · 3 months ago Added
ambient beautiful nothingness · 3,662 followers

No written feedback with this decision.

Curated By Kenyama Curator on Song to Carol by Chris Portka · 3 months ago Declined

Hi Chris Portka, thank you for sharing! I think the beat has a pretty engaging groove thanks to the added texture from the bass and the shaker, but I'm sorry to say that the low end is a little lacking and sounded a bit thin in the mix. Really sorry for the de...

Rushkeys Curator on Song to Carol by Chris Portka · 3 months ago Declined

Hello Chris, thanks for your submission. This is a really enjoyable track with a great vibe. The groove is catchy, the bassline brings a lot of funk and movement, and the vocal elements work well as hooks that keep the track engaging throughout. Everything sou...

ClubMafia Curator on Song to Carol by Chris Portka · 3 months ago Added
club mafia: house & techno · 3,388 followers

No written feedback with this decision.

Juicy Jams Curator on Song to Carol by Chris Portka · 3 months ago Declined

I believe the song's got a cool concept, it almost reminds me a bit of Glee and jazz combined together. However, I felt that the vocals could still be more locked into the notes a bit more as some of them could be a bit shaky. Sorry for passing on this track....

Mood Sculptor Playlists Curator on Song to Carol by Chris Portka · 3 months ago Declined

Hey Chris Portka, while I liked the funky bass line and the smooth percussion, I'm sorry to say that the track overall just lacked a more distinct and memorable catchy element for me to connect with and nothing really stood out for me. I'm afraid I'll pass for...

Sound Surfer Playlists Curator on Song to Carol by Chris Portka · 3 months ago Declined

Hi Chris Portka, I loved the smooth bass groove and the soulful vibe but unfortunately this doesn't fit my r&b playlist as they vocals were too sparse and lacked lyrics. This also doesn't quite have the punchier drums to fit my house playlist. I'm sorry to tur...

RockRecords Curator on Song to Carol by Chris Portka · 3 months ago Added
shoegaze & indie · 2,821 followers

No written feedback with this decision.

omglooitsRaph Curator on Song to Carol by Chris Portka · 3 months ago Declined

Hi there and thank you for sharing your music Chris Portka! A nice and vibrant tune for sure. That bass in there sounds crisp. Well done on the production. For me personally: a bit too repetitive and slow paced. I prefer more energetic singing right from the s...

Natalia Carina Alonso Curator on Song to Carol by Chris Portka · 3 months ago Declined

The song for Carol is perceived as carefully crafted in terms of sound. I like the polished sound and rich instrumentation. But, regarding its theme and lyrics, it is somewhat lacking in depth. It entertains, but I don't feel that it leaves a lasting mark on t...

Javier Mandiola Curator on Song to Carol by Chris Portka · 3 months ago Declined

In terms of sound and instrumental quality, I can say that the proposal is pleasant and maintains a good level throughout its development. There is a noticeable carefulness in the production and a competent execution that adds value to the whole. However, bein...

Dmytro Curator on Song to Carol by Chris Portka · 3 months ago Declined

Hey there! To start with, I really dig that hypnotizing effect that your tune has on me. Infectious percussion, catchy bass line and hi-pitched back vocals. Pretty unusual layering. I like your openness to experiments. Unfortunately, the vocal lines did not re...

How this board works

  • Every campaign here was posted with the artist's permission, chosen at checkout. Artists can switch it off from their dashboard at any time.
  • Campaigns are posted once every curator has replied, so no curator sees another's feedback while reviewing. We publish the full text, including declines.
  • Reviews an artist has disputed are hidden until resolved.
  • Placements are verified against Spotify. Follower counts are the latest we have for each playlist.

Your campaign could be next on the board.

New campaign Every curator replies with a decision and feedback · from $79