Every public campaign. Every curator's verdict.
Artists who opted in have their campaign posted here in full: which curators listened, who added the track, who declined, and exactly what they wrote. Artists and curators reply to each other in the open. Nothing is edited or cherry-picked.
Opted-in campaigns in full: every curator's verdict and feedback, declines included.
Jens Van der Borght Curator
on Floki's Odyssey by Echovayn · 3 weeks ago
Declined
Hi, a strong production where all elements work together well. The distorted guitars are however too heavy for the more mellow vibe I am after for my slow guitar/indie playlists. Also felt that the vocal were quite noisy and harsh in the high end and need de-e...
Eden Sound Club Curator
on From the Smokies to The Opry by Echovayn · 3 weeks ago
Declined
Hello! It sounds like a very chill and calm track. Perfect vibe for my indie playlist. However, the mix right now has this unnaturally airy sound that I find a bit muffled and fuzzy. Sorry for the decline.
Adrian Curator
on From the Smokies to The Opry by Echovayn · 3 weeks ago
Declined
vocals sound super effortless here, love that you retained the rawness of the instrumental lines. it's a super clever track but i just kinda wish it has this momentous component which i felt would further solidify the hook on here
Lim K. Curator
on From the Smokies to The Opry by Echovayn · 3 weeks ago
Declined
There’s a really nice warmth to the track, but it leans a little more country-leaning than the direction I’m looking for right now. I’d keep some of that organic charm while bringing in a slightly different flavor to make it feel closer to the sound I’m after....
omglooitsRaph Curator
on From the Smokies to The Opry by Echovayn · 3 weeks ago
Declined
Greetings and thank you for sharing your song with me! A nice and clean production, the strings sound crisp in there, I like the bassline. The vocals start early which I like for audience retention. I like the lyrics as well as they are pretty relatable but I...
Mellow Mood Playlists Curator
on Boom Boom by James Marsh · 3 weeks ago
Added
Hey James Marsh, I liked the captivating vocals and the sick guitar playing. I'd love to share this to my On The Road playlist, cheers!
Konstantin Curator
on From the Smokies to The Opry by Echovayn · 3 weeks ago
Declined
Hello there! thank you very much for sharing your new song with us. Nice melodies, the song has strong foundation for a good country track. However, the production side of the song is not there yet...the master sounds very overcompressed and not natural. Sound...
Don's Tunes Curator
on From the Smokies to The Opry by Echovayn · 3 weeks ago
Declined
Hi! Thanks for sending this lovely song. I enjoyed its easy-going melody and the lyrics but for my playlists I prefer a more classic blues / americana with a bit grittier / darker tone and mood. Keep it up!
unique playlists Curator
on Boom Boom by James Marsh · 3 weeks ago
Declined
Thanks for sending this over! The track has some really strong energy and I'm digging those guitar riffs. While I'm always open to rock submissions, the vocals on this one didn't quite hit the mark for me personally. All the best with it!
VinylHoops Curator
on Floki's Odyssey by Echovayn · 3 weeks ago
Declined
Hey Echovayn, For a rock sub, I'm looking for a classic rock approach on the drums and guitars, as well as the vocals. And while you had the guitars and drums that make for a great rock song, I think I simply just struggled to get into the vocals as they felt...
VinylHoops Curator
on Boom Boom by James Marsh · 3 weeks ago
Declined
Hey James MArsh, For a rock sub, I would have been looking for a more classic rock approach on the drums and guitars, leaning into a more traditional classic electric guitar approach - with aggressive though not poppy vocals, that match the classic rock sound....
omglooitsRaph Curator
on Boom Boom by James Marsh · 3 weeks ago
Declined
Hi there guys and thank you for submitting your music! Good work on the energy level in there. The instrumental sounds great with those strings. The vocals only drop in at 36 seconds and this is a bit too late for me though. I personally prefer the vocals earl...
Vibe Agency - Asia Curator
on Boom Boom by James Marsh · 3 weeks ago
Declined
Hi there! We appreciate your voice sync along with guitars and drums. However the overall tempo of your song is a bit slow and overall vibe feels a bit moody and somewhat thoughtful with the tone of guitars and your singing, which doesn't fit quite nice among...
SoundSafari Playlists Curator
on Boom Boom by James Marsh · 3 weeks ago
Declined
Greetings! I like the groove of the arrangement catchy. But I will pass for now as the mix is a tad too saturated and distorted for my preference. Sorry!
Konstantin Curator
on Floki's Odyssey by Echovayn · 3 weeks ago
Declined
Hey there, thank you very much for sharing "Floki's Odyssey" with us! The track has a great foundation for a good folk metal song, great melodies. However, we think the song would benefit from better mixing and mastering. The current mix sounds very overcompre...
Konstantin Curator
on Boom Boom by James Marsh · 3 weeks ago
Declined
Hey James, thanks a lot for your submission. appreciate that. Great guitar work, the energy is engaging. However, we think your track would benefit from better mixing and mastering. In particular the female backing vocals don't sit well in the mix and feel a l...
unique playlists Curator
on Floki's Odyssey by Echovayn · 3 weeks ago
Declined
This track has a really cool rock vibe, and I was drawn in by the mood and the song's concept. However, after careful consideration, the overall mix doesn't quite align with the quality I'm looking for in my curation. I'll have to decline for now, but I truly...
Pepijn Vermeulen Curator
on No Matter Where by Alex Saunders · 3 weeks ago
Declined
Hi, thanks for sharing your song! I liked the vocal performance and the overall warmth of the production. The drums felt a little gentle underneath the guitars, so I was looking for a bit more presence from the rhythm section. Wishing you success with your mus...
Luke Bertoz Curator
on Floki's Odyssey by Echovayn · 3 weeks ago
Declined
Thanks for your submission. I like the Celtic sounding introduction. The vocal sounds nice here with some great lyrics, and I like the nice ambient reverb on the vocals. I do like the cool blend of heavy guitars and flute moments. Once the track starts buildin...
Adrian Curator
on Floki's Odyssey by Echovayn · 3 weeks ago
Declined
love your originality, vocals sound super edgy and radio friendly. the song is a vibe but for the most part it's just too hard hitting for it to fit even my most upbeat of playlist, i'm sorry
How this board works
- Every campaign here was posted with the artist's permission, chosen at checkout. Artists can switch it off from their dashboard at any time.
- Campaigns are posted once every curator has replied, so no curator sees another's feedback while reviewing. We publish the full text, including declines.
- Reviews an artist has disputed are hidden until resolved.
- Placements are verified against Spotify. Follower counts are the latest we have for each playlist.
Your campaign could be next on the board.