Every public campaign. Every curator's verdict.
Artists who opted in have their campaign posted here in full: which curators listened, who added the track, who declined, and exactly what they wrote. Artists and curators reply to each other in the open. Nothing is edited or cherry-picked.
Thanks for your submission. I can appreciate the raw and organic energy of this track. Some smooth and nice technical guitar licks going on. For me, I'm not connecting with the recording quality of this one. Just a personal taste thing. Thanks and good luck wi...
Impressive guitar playing in this track! Sadly, the arrangement was a little too blues sounding for the more Neo-Soul and Lo-fi sound of my curation. Sorry but I must decline this submission.
No written feedback with this decision.
No written feedback with this decision.
No written feedback with this decision.
Hello! We appreciate your hard work on the production and careful instrumental flow. However it has a bit slow tempo and chill vibe, which doesn't fit well among other faster and stronger/engaging rock songs with more presence of singing that we prefer in our...
I appreciate the rendition, the rhythm section and the balance of the mix. However, as I listened, the runtime felt a bit long to match the mood of my current selection. Unfortunately, I will not be including this track in my playlist at this time. Wishing you...
Hi there Stew Cutler and Tom Wilson! Thank you for sharing your music! A nice and vibrant tune for sure. Clean work on the production, those strings sound crisp! I do feel like the intro is taking a bit too long. I personally prefer more early action, for audi...
The instrumentation is very well crafted and demonstrates a remarkable level of artistic quality. The song flows naturally, maintains good cohesion in its development, and offers a pleasant and well-constructed sound experience. However, for the direction I am...
Hi Stew Cutler and Tom Wilson, I'll be turning down your track for now because unfortunately my rock playlist focuses on much more aggressive and gritty sound and leans more towards metal. My R&B playlist leans more towards a hip hop/urban feel so this won't b...
Hey there Stew Cutler, I think the guitar playing sounded really phenomenal and full of soul but unfortunately your song doesn't quite fit any of my playlists. My roadtrip playlist features classic and indie rock tracks with vocals, and the type of R&B and sou...
Hi there Lex Ventura and thank you for sending in your music today! A nice and vibrant tune. Great work on the production. I like the energy in there for sure but I am not too sure about the vocals. I prefer more energetic singing and less vocal effects. These...
Impressive guitar arrangement in this track! However, the arrangement was a bit too classic rock sounding for the more indie rock and country sound of my curation. Apologies but I must pass on this submission.
Hey Lex, thank you very much for sharing your music with us! "Don't You Mess with the Heartland" features nice melodies and great production, your work is polished and well-crafted. However, the sound, vibe, energy, and specific sub-genre aren’t quite what we...
It's on the 12 bar blues and the harmonica and guitars responding to the main vocal was smokey. Even so, the style here didn't quite match the feel of my Hard Rock Runs Playlist, which tends to sound metal. Sorry for declining this song.
Pleasure is mine giving my thoughts on your song. Unfortunately, I wasn't able to add this track to my set due to the grainy texture of the audio. However, I commend the instrumentation and the vocal melody. The chorus was easy to remember and the driving rhyt...
Hi Lex Ventura, I'm bummed to turn this down but it's too upbeat and lively for the slow vibe of my indie folk playlist and doesn't fit the more aggressive and gritty energy of my rock playlist.
Hey Lex Ventura, the song is quite catchy, both the vocal melody and the lyrics. I'm sorry to say though that the song's audio has an airy and low-res quality which didn't meet my standards. I'm sorry to decline for now.
Hi, A confident vocal and good sounding groove in this one. Really well-made production. This song is however too upbeat and feels too energetic for the slow and mellow guitar vibe I am going for. I like a slow vibe more like Gregory Alan Isakov. Good luck wit...
The song's got a nice arrangement and the vocal performance was engaging to the ears. On the flipside, I noticed a bit of digital harshness in the vocal quality and mix. So for now, I have to turn down the song.
How this board works
- Every campaign here was posted with the artist's permission, chosen at checkout. Artists can switch it off from their dashboard at any time.
- Campaigns are posted once every curator has replied, so no curator sees another's feedback while reviewing. We publish the full text, including declines.
- Reviews an artist has disputed are hidden until resolved.
- Placements are verified against Spotify. Follower counts are the latest we have for each playlist.
Your campaign could be next on the board.