Every public campaign. Every curator's verdict.
Artists who opted in have their campaign posted here in full: which curators listened, who added the track, who declined, and exactly what they wrote. Artists and curators reply to each other in the open. Nothing is edited or cherry-picked.
No written feedback with this decision.
No written feedback with this decision.
the groove of the track is very alluring, i dig the smooth vocal performance, however due to my own musical taste i would've liked for the track's dynamics to have more depth to it
Hey Clockwork Lemons, I appreciate the share, but unfortunately this song isn’t quite aligned with my playlist. I find the song to be too Electronic Pop leaning for my playlist and I usually go for Alt Rock based with uplifting and energetic vibes. I appreciat...
Hey mor2dekai, I'm sorry for the bad news, but I’ll be saying no to this song for now. I do like the melody on the synths and I think it was pretty soothing to listen to, but I find the song to be quite Drum and Bass leaning for my playlist and I usually go fo...
Hey Clockwork Lemons, thanks so much for sending me your track! I can tell you've put a lot of heart and effort into it, and I think your vocals and production really stand out. That said, I’m currently on the lookout for music with a more danceable vibe. Whil...
Hi Clockwork Lemons, thank you for sending your track. Although we really enjoyed the synth melodies and overall arrangement, we feel that the track has a formulaic structure. We will sadly have to skip this one. Keep making more music :)
Hi, thank you for sending your track Beautiful. We really enjoyed the synth elements on the track, however, we feel that the track does not match the playlist mood. We will sadly have to skip this one. Keep making more music :)
Hi! Thanks for sending us your song. The emotional delivery and expressiveness in the track was very impressive. We felt that the vocal delivery and processing could have been a bit more impactful though. Sadly, we will have to decline but keep sending more mu...
No written feedback with this decision.
Hi there, thank you for sharing your music! The production is clean. Great work! I do miss a bit more power overall. I feel like waiting for the song to really start taking off and this is taking quite long. The vocal effects are also a bit too much. Natural s...
Hey there Stephen - thanks for the submission. Your track has a smooth sound, and a really traditional feel. There's a calming vibe and a solid, pleasant melody which feels like an old standard. However, it feels a little dated and mild for my playlists, and t...
Very cool melodies. I loved the vocals. The synths were beautifully written too. I just felt that the overall percussion sounds were a little too loud and compressed sounding in the mix for my taste. I prefer a little more subtlety and dynamics in that area. I...
I loved the vocals. The performance is amazing! You have a really interesting writing style. I just felt that the overall arrangement had too many stark energy shifts for my taste. I prefer more of a steady build personally. I totally respect what you were goi...
Hey Stephen, the song’s pacing feels a bit uneven for the playlist’s steady rhythmic flow, so it sits apart from our current set. Your vocal pocket is warm and grounded and really sells the melody. I’m going to decline.
Thanks for your submission. I can appreciate the nice, raw energy of this track. Nice smooth vocal and guitar playing. For me, this track is much too chill for my playlists. It's also missing an alternative edge for my taste. Just my own opinion. Thanks and go...
Thanks for your submission. I can certainly appreciate the quality song writing here. Great melodies and song structure. For me, this track is a little too electronic and dancy for what I'm looking for. I also feel the vocals could have been glued back in the...
the vocals sound so effortless here, i love that the entire production is centered around it, wonderful lyrics too. that being said, i have a rather hard time connecting with the catchier elements of the track, i’m sorry, regardless it’s such a clever song
Hey Mama No Likey! Awesome name by the way :-) Thanks for sending Slow and Steady my way. This sounds like a recording of a live performance rather than a studio track, and I mean that in the best way - you captured that organic energy without compromising qua...
No written feedback with this decision.
How this board works
- Every campaign here was posted with the artist's permission, chosen at checkout. Artists can switch it off from their dashboard at any time.
- Campaigns are posted once every curator has replied, so no curator sees another's feedback while reviewing. We publish the full text, including declines.
- Reviews an artist has disputed are hidden until resolved.
- Placements are verified against Spotify. Follower counts are the latest we have for each playlist.
Your campaign could be next on the board.