Every public campaign. Every curator's verdict.
Artists who opted in have their campaign posted here in full: which curators listened, who added the track, who declined, and exactly what they wrote. Artists and curators reply to each other in the open. Nothing is edited or cherry-picked.
Opted-in campaigns in full: every curator's verdict and feedback, declines included.
Varad Mulay Curator
on Half Astronaut, Half Martian by Ronin 888 · 3 weeks ago
Declined
I liked the atmospheric production and the way the Auto-Tuned vocal blends into the spacey instrumental. The main issue for me was the lack of an immediately recognizable vocal hook. At four minutes, I wanted a stronger moment that would stay with me after lis...
Svitlana Curator
on Half Astronaut, Half Martian by Ronin 888 · 3 weeks ago
Declined
Hi! Thanks for sharing your track! The rap sounds rhythmic and engaging, and the low vocal timbre gives it a deep sound. The instrumental blends smoothly with the vocals, but the overall vibe feels a bit monotonous for my playlists. There's a missing punchline...
Silverpalms music Curator
on Nice Girl by Fair Game · 3 weeks ago
Declined
Hello Fair Game, I’m quite drawn to the high energy and driving beats in this arrangement. Unfortunately I’ll have to decline as the mix of the synths lacked depth and the kick felt a little boxy. I’m focusing more on better balanced synths that have warmth an...
VinylHoops Curator
on Kingston Rise by Echovayn · 3 weeks ago
Declined
Hey again Echovayn, This is a difficult one, the song is fun but the vocals are not as raw as I like them. For any submission, I like a track that showcases dry vocals, even if there's a little bit of wet reverb or pitch correction. Dry vocals to me should be...
VinylHoops Curator
on I Won't Tell by Dezaray Star · 3 weeks ago
Declined
Hey there Dezaray Star, An interesting track here, with cool sound design! Though one of the first things I noticed right off the bat was that the final mix was overblown. Basically all that means on my end is that I was hoping for a better master on the track...
VinylHoops Curator
on Floki's Odyssey by Echovayn · 3 weeks ago
Declined
Hey Echovayn, For a rock sub, I'm looking for a classic rock approach on the drums and guitars, as well as the vocals. And while you had the guitars and drums that make for a great rock song, I think I simply just struggled to get into the vocals as they felt...
VinylHoops Curator
on Boom Boom by James Marsh · 3 weeks ago
Declined
Hey James MArsh, For a rock sub, I would have been looking for a more classic rock approach on the drums and guitars, leaning into a more traditional classic electric guitar approach - with aggressive though not poppy vocals, that match the classic rock sound....
Eden Sound Club Curator
on Echoes of Attenborough by Echovayn · 3 weeks ago
Declined
Hello! I think the music sounds pretty good and it matches my indie playlist. It has a calm and soothing vibe. However, the mix right now sounds a bit too muffled for my liking. There's this unnatural airy quality to it that I find a little distracting and I w...
omglooitsRaph Curator
on Boom Boom by James Marsh · 3 weeks ago
Declined
Hi there guys and thank you for submitting your music! Good work on the energy level in there. The instrumental sounds great with those strings. The vocals only drop in at 36 seconds and this is a bit too late for me though. I personally prefer the vocals earl...
Javier Mandiola Curator
on Echoes of Attenborough by Echovayn · 3 weeks ago
Declined
There is a beautiful sense of harmony throughout the track, complemented by a warm vocal delivery and a carefully crafted production. The overall sound feels polished and inviting, creating a pleasant atmosphere that is easy to appreciate. However, considering...
Javier Mandiola Curator
on Half Astronaut, Half Martian by Ronin 888 · 3 weeks ago
Declined
After a careful evaluation, I feel your song creates a relaxed atmosphere, supported by good sound quality and very well-executed production. However, when comparing it with the criteria of my current curation, I feel that both the vocal performance and the so...
Vibe Agency - Asia Curator
on Boom Boom by James Marsh · 3 weeks ago
Declined
Hi there! We appreciate your voice sync along with guitars and drums. However the overall tempo of your song is a bit slow and overall vibe feels a bit moody and somewhat thoughtful with the tone of guitars and your singing, which doesn't fit quite nice among...
Weekend Sounds Curator
on Kingston Rise by Echovayn · 3 weeks ago
Declined
Tienes una canción agradable pero prefiero canciones de música afro con unas percusiones un poco diferentes. Te mando suerte pero en este caso no voy a poder ayudar
acoustic tides Curator
on Echoes of Attenborough by Echovayn · 3 weeks ago
Declined
Hi Echovayn! Thanks for trusting me with your track. The soothing harmonies and the gentle stomping beats sound so pleasant to listen to. It feels like I’m driving into a field of greens while admiring the beauty of the environment. I’m quite sorry for declini...
Ant Curator
on Echoes of Attenborough by Echovayn · 3 weeks ago
Declined
Thank you for the song! The gentle guitar and expressive vocals create a beautiful and intimate atmosphere that makes the track easy to connect with. The arrangement feels thoughtful, and the performance is both natural and engaging. However, I’m currently loo...
Cristobal Delgado Candela Curator
on Nice Girl by Fair Game · 3 weeks ago
Declined
Hello, thanks for sending over your song. I won't be able to share the song due to the fact it was made with AI. I hope you understand I try to keep my playlists AI-free. Wish you the best of luck with your release.
SoundSafari Playlists Curator
on Boom Boom by James Marsh · 3 weeks ago
Declined
Greetings! I like the groove of the arrangement catchy. But I will pass for now as the mix is a tad too saturated and distorted for my preference. Sorry!
SoundSafari Playlists Curator
on Half Astronaut, Half Martian by Ronin 888 · 3 weeks ago
Declined
Hi there! The beat had a very catchy groove. But I will be passing for now as the vocal mix sounds a tad too thin making it a tad too difficult to understand. Apologies!
Weekend Sounds Curator
on Echoes of Attenborough by Echovayn · 3 weeks ago
Declined
The song is very good but I think it is somewhat slower and more relaxed than my favorite songs. I wish you luck for the future.
Weekend Sounds Curator
on I Won't Tell by Dezaray Star · 3 weeks ago
Declined
Es una canción interesante pero con un estilo un poco alternativo y diferente a lo que se ve habitualmente en la música que yo escucho. Te mando suerte pero esta vez no te voy a poder ayudar
How this board works
- Every campaign here was posted with the artist's permission, chosen at checkout. Artists can switch it off from their dashboard at any time.
- Campaigns are posted once every curator has replied, so no curator sees another's feedback while reviewing. We publish the full text, including declines.
- Reviews an artist has disputed are hidden until resolved.
- Placements are verified against Spotify. Follower counts are the latest we have for each playlist.
Your campaign could be next on the board.