Loading...
Campaign board

Every public campaign. Every curator's verdict.

Artists who opted in have their campaign posted here in full: which curators listened, who added the track, who declined, and exactly what they wrote. Artists and curators reply to each other in the open. Nothing is edited or cherry-picked.

New campaign Every curator replies with a decision and feedback · from $79
6.8MFollowers across curator playlists
1,255Verified curator playlists
74%Of replies are declines. Published, not hidden.
15hMedian time to a curator reply
100%Of replies shown in full, as written
Lefuturewave Curator on Side Effects by Clockwork Lemons · 1 month ago Declined

Hey Clockwork Lemons, your song "Side Effects" has good vocals and synths, but the beat doesn't feel varied enough and feels quite dull in how it bounces. Make it much punchier next time so it makes even more of an impression. Also, try to make the layering wi...

Sebastian Wernke-Schmiesing Curator on Side Effects by Clockwork Lemons · 1 month ago Declined

Hey, thanks so much for the submission. It's an interesting song. But unfortunately, the vocals don't quite do it for me here. I'm really sorry.

Lim K. Curator on Side Effects by Clockwork Lemons · 1 month ago Declined

This one has a really nostalgic charm to it, and I can appreciate the character that brings. I'm just leaning toward a more modern sound, so this didn't quite fit the direction I'm curating. Thanks for sharing your music, and I hope to hear from you again soon...

Daniel Mena Curator on Side Effects by Clockwork Lemons · 1 month ago Declined

Hi, I think the rhythmic direction gives this track a lot of personality. I also think there’s drum and bass influence that comes through naturally, and the beat carries a sweet energy that keeps the song engaging. There’s a clear intention behind the producti...

Rushkeys Curator on Side Effects by Clockwork Lemons · 1 month ago Declined

Hey Mark, thanks for sending this over. I enjoyed the combination of the driving groove and the expressive vocal. The lyrics and performance make the relationship theme feel believable, giving the song a genuine emotional core without losing its momentum. I co...

Dmytro Curator on Side Effects by Clockwork Lemons · 1 month ago Declined

Hey there! To start with, production quality is at its very highest here. The mix feels so well-balanced. Dreamy pads made me close my eyes: just to enjoy the moment more. Stunning hi-hats. Unfortunately, the vocal performance did not resonate enough with me....

Curated By Kenyama Curator on Side Effects by Clockwork Lemons · 1 month ago Declined

Hi Clockwork Lemons, thank you for sharing your song, but sadly this song isn't quite aligned with my playlist as it is Electronic Pop leaning and I usually go with a chill and mellow Indie approach or uplifting and energetic type of Alt Rock. Really sorry to...

VinylHoops Curator on Side Effects by Clockwork Lemons · 1 month ago Declined

Honestly, I think this is a pretty cool song, it certainly is channeling that new wave era of music, which is very fun. For me and my contemporary Pop preferences, however, I really prefer more than even balance of acoustic and synthetics, and this one here re...

Anderson Júnior Curator on Side Effects by Clockwork Lemons · 1 month ago Declined

Boas progressões de acordes e melódicos, estrutura musical bem elaborado com base ao estilo de Synthwave devido as características sonoras de percussão. Sua voz está bem claro pelo bom ajuste de equalização, incluindo tua afinação e sincronia ao longo dos trec...

Juicy Jams Curator on Side Effects by Clockwork Lemons · 1 month ago Declined

Sorry for passing on this track for now. The song has more of a club-ready type of arrangement and it veers away from the indie direction of my playlist.

Adrian Curator on Side Effects by Clockwork Lemons · 1 month ago Declined

i thought that the sound design is super creative, vocals are very top40 station coded. it’s totally just my personal preference but i kinda wish the song has this big break out element which i felt would further solidify the hook on here

Jens Van der Borght Curator on Side Effects by Clockwork Lemons · 1 month ago Declined

Hi, Quality production. All elements in the mix work together smoothly. For my electronic playlists this song has however too much focus on the vocals and too little on instrumental and melodic progression to see it fit in the mood with the other songs. I like...

Mood Sculptor Playlists Curator on Side Effects by Clockwork Lemons · 1 month ago Declined

Hey Clockwork Lemons, the production was on point, loved the vintage synths and the dreamy atmosphere. The vocals sounded good too but for my house playlist there was just too much emphasis on the vocals as I'm looking for house/dance tracks that have captivat...

Sound Surfer Playlists Curator on Side Effects by Clockwork Lemons · 1 month ago Declined

Hi Clockwork Lemons, I loved the lush retro feel of the instrumental and found the production quite well done but unfortunately I wasn't as drawn to the vocal because the melody had a slightly predictable pattern and didn't hit me in a catchy way. I'm sorry to...

Javier Mandiola Curator on Alive by mama no likey, Cameron Morris · 1 month ago Declined

Your song delivers a strong rock identity, driven by great energy, a well-crafted production, and a performance that reflects real dedication and artistic commitment. It's clear that you have talent and plenty of potential as an artist. However, due to the hig...

Recap Curator on Alive by mama no likey, Cameron Morris · 1 month ago Added
rock for people · 327 followers

No written feedback with this decision.

oldbandtee Curator on Alive by mama no likey, Cameron Morris · 1 month ago Added
garage rock vibes · 3,079 followers

No written feedback with this decision.

StuckIn1984 Curator on Alive by mama no likey, Cameron Morris · 1 month ago Added
Modern and classic rock · 2,197 followers

No written feedback with this decision.

Sergio Curator on Alive by mama no likey, Cameron Morris · 1 month ago Declined

Hola. La canción presenta una introducción donde la guitarra toma la delantera con la voz principal y una batería que marca bien el ritmo para luego aumentar la intensidad con una instrumentalización variada y voces corales que ayudan a su elevación. L melodía...

Sandeep Raghavan Curator on Alive by mama no likey, Cameron Morris · 1 month ago Declined

I loved the writing! You have an incredible sound. The vocals are amazing! I just felt that the overall mix was a little too bright and gritty for my taste. I prefer more subtlety and depth in that area. I totally respect what you were going for though. All th...

How this board works

  • Every campaign here was posted with the artist's permission, chosen at checkout. Artists can switch it off from their dashboard at any time.
  • Campaigns are posted once every curator has replied, so no curator sees another's feedback while reviewing. We publish the full text, including declines.
  • Reviews an artist has disputed are hidden until resolved.
  • Placements are verified against Spotify. Follower counts are the latest we have for each playlist.

Your campaign could be next on the board.

New campaign Every curator replies with a decision and feedback · from $79