Every public campaign. Every curator's verdict.
Artists who opted in have their campaign posted here in full: which curators listened, who added the track, who declined, and exactly what they wrote. Artists and curators reply to each other in the open. Nothing is edited or cherry-picked.
Opted-in campaigns in full: every curator's verdict and feedback, declines included.
Rushkeys Curator
on The Echo in Your Soul by Brian David · 2 months ago
Declined
Hello Brian, thanks for sharing this with me. Knowing the story behind the song gives it a lot of meaning, and I can hear how personal it is. The vocal feels sincere, and the songwriting carries that emotion really well. It’s not quite right for my playlist, t...
Ken's Collection Curator
on The Echo in Your Soul by Brian David · 2 months ago
Declined
Hey Brian, loving the vocal performance on this track! Overall, the arrangement is already great with movements in the section that make good sense. Unfortunately, the track just leans a bit too much on a pop styled production with all the synths and electroni...
Anderson Júnior Curator
on The Echo in Your Soul by Brian David · 2 months ago
Declined
Então, acabei de ouvir sua música e observamos que sua voz está bem nítido, já que as gravações principais mostraram que sua qualidade técnica foi excelente. As estruturas musicais e viradas de bateria estão apresentados nesta proposta, mas tem um ponto onde é...
acoustic tides Curator
on The Echo in Your Soul by Brian David · 2 months ago
Declined
Hi Brian David! The intro feels so emotional and the soft thump in the kick adds a captivating and inspiring mood in this arrangement. I’m enjoying the rhythmic chorus section that sounded so captivating. Unfortunately though I will decline based on the bright...
Dmytro Curator
on The Echo in Your Soul by Brian David · 2 months ago
Declined
Hey there! To start with, I'm quite captivated with the overall atmosphere of this tune. Guitar sits so well in the centre of the mix. Glues everything together. Simple percussion only reinforces that melancholy. Unfortunately, the vocal performance did not re...
Javier Mandiola Curator
on The Echo in Your Soul by Brian David · 2 months ago
Declined
Your vocal performance is outstanding—polished, compelling, and highly competitive. Combined with the excellent instrumentation and rich harmonic arrangement, it creates a captivating atmosphere filled with warmth, sensitivity, and genuine musicality. However,...
omglooitsRaph Curator
on The Echo in Your Soul by Brian David · 2 months ago
Declined
Hello there and thank you for sharing your music! A nice and clean, soothing tune. good work on the production! The lyrics are also pretty relatable and you have a great voice! The overall pace is a bit too slow for me though as I am currently looking for more...
Dominik Friedrich Curator
on The Echo in Your Soul by Brian David · 2 months ago
Declined
beautiful song I really like the message I also like the natural singing voice but what I also fear is that the groove and the instrumentals sound a bit compressed and even harsh at times and the vocals sound a bit too much separated from the instrumentals. th...
amplaylists Curator
on The Echo in Your Soul by Brian David · 2 months ago
Declined
The track unfolds with a nice acoustic guitar followed by mellow electronic drums that gives further energy, as well as provide support for the melody. While this track was definitely done well, the song's style pulls the direction of my space elsewhere outsid...
Side C Playlists Curator
on The Echo in Your Soul by Brian David · 2 months ago
Declined
The song's narrative was quite interesting and the song's lyrics go descriptive as well that it's easy to follow the story. However, the song's four on the floor beat sets a different listening experience closer to pop. At the moment, I'll be declining the son...
Lefuturewave Curator
on The Echo in Your Soul by Brian David · 2 months ago
Declined
Hey Brian David, ''The Echo in Your Soul'' has meaningful lyrics that radiate a lot of personality and power. The way you describe everything impresses. The chorus is very impressive too. Technically, there are still a few things you could improve. The masteri...
Lim K. Curator
on The Echo in Your Soul by Brian David · 2 months ago
Declined
I enjoyed giving this a listen, but it leans a little too far into pop for the direction I'm curating with my playlist. I won't be adding this to my playlist this time, but thanks for sharing your music, and I hope to hear from you again soon!
Selected By Nona Curator
on The Echo in Your Soul by Brian David · 2 months ago
Declined
Hi Brian David! Great music, I love your lyrics and the instrumental is simple but really effective in getting the emotion out. Unfortunately, I will be declining your track because the quality of the mix didn't meet my standards. Needs more body and it kind o...
Juicy Jams Curator
on The Echo in Your Soul by Brian David · 2 months ago
Declined
Really sorry for passing on this track at the moment. The audio quality of the track has a bit of graininess and within the context of my playlist, it didn't fully match the tone I'm trying to create.
VinylHoops Curator
on The Echo in Your Soul by Brian David · 2 months ago
Declined
Hey Brian David, This is a lovely song for sure, though for a pop or a rock sub, I would have been looking for a more uptempo beat and a punchier sound design on the drums and instruments, leaning into more commanding vocals. This gentle vocal style and instru...
Audio Journey Playlists Curator
on The Echo in Your Soul by Brian David · 2 months ago
Declined
I liked the steady rhythm section, the subtle guitar work and the space given to the vocal track. However, as I listened, the overall structure and arrangement strayed a bit from my current selection that leans more towards Indie Folk/Alternative Indie. That s...
Alejandro Badia Curator
on Side Effects by Clockwork Lemons · 2 months ago
Declined
Hey, thanks for the submission! The song is not bad, the production is solid... I like the vibe on the drums, the bass line is also nice and the melodies have a cool vibe... nice atmosphere in general! Unfortunately I didn't feel the vocals as much as I would...
Rave Sector Curator
on Side Effects by Clockwork Lemons · 2 months ago
Declined
Hey, Thx for sending your tune. The song has a nice idea, but I am not a big fan of the kick drum... It's a bit too hard IMO.
Laurelanne Davis Curator
on Side Effects by Clockwork Lemons · 2 months ago
Added
https://open.spotify.com/track/58RmI36nZR98f08kTzVYBQ?si=c29b21e1f494462a Thank you so much for submitting this one. I'm loving this nostalgia-driven late 80s/early 90s vibe. The production is spot on, and your voice captures that era.
amplaylists Curator
on Side Effects by Clockwork Lemons · 2 months ago
Declined
The sound design, sample selection, and the arrangement of the track conveys musical movement and I find the melody quite striking. Conversely, the track overall musical direction shifts the stylistic leaning of my playlist towards a lofi and indie rock so I h...
How this board works
- Every campaign here was posted with the artist's permission, chosen at checkout. Artists can switch it off from their dashboard at any time.
- Campaigns are posted once every curator has replied, so no curator sees another's feedback while reviewing. We publish the full text, including declines.
- Reviews an artist has disputed are hidden until resolved.
- Placements are verified against Spotify. Follower counts are the latest we have for each playlist.
Your campaign could be next on the board.