Loading...
Campaign board

Every public campaign. Every curator's verdict.

Artists who opted in have their campaign posted here in full: which curators listened, who added the track, who declined, and exactly what they wrote. Artists and curators reply to each other in the open. Nothing is edited or cherry-picked.

Opted-in campaigns in full: every curator's verdict and feedback, declines included.

New campaign Every curator replies with a decision and feedback · from $79
8.5MFollowers across curator playlistsFollowers
1,614Verified curator playlistsPlaylists
70%Of replies are declines. Published, not hidden.Declines
11hMedian time to a curator replyReply time
100%Of replies shown in full, as writtenShown in full
Ant Curator on i really thought - Remix by davey, Anthony Orange · 5 months ago Added
Happy Indie Songs · 15,754 followers

Hi! Thanks for sharing your track. The melody is wonderful and creates a really pleasant atmosphere, while the vocals complement the composition beautifully. I’m definitely adding this one to my list — really enjoyed it. Appreciate you sharing your music!

A Analias Curator on i really thought - Remix by davey, Anthony Orange · 5 months ago Declined

Hey Davey, thanks so much for sending me your track! I can tell you've put a lot of heart and effort into it, and I think your vocals and production really stand out. That said, I’m currently on the lookout for music with a more danceable vibe. While this one...

A Analias Curator on Pull His Jumper by Chris Portka · 5 months ago Declined

Hi Chris! Thank you for sharing your track with me. Your vocals and production are truly impressive! That said, I usually lean towards a more commercial pop sound, and I felt that this track has more of a techno vibe. Because of that, I won’t be able to move f...

Rushkeys Curator on i really thought - Remix by davey, Anthony Orange · 5 months ago Declined

Hello davey, thank you for your submission. The track sounds very polished and well produced. Nice groove, lovely songwritting, strong vocals and a clean modern sound overall. It feels very accessible and radio-friendly. For my electronica and ambient playlist...

Lim K. Curator on Pull His Jumper by Chris Portka · 5 months ago Declined

Hey! There's a cool atmosphere underneath this and I can hear the direction you were aiming creatively. The mix feels a bit too muffled and distorted for my taste though, so a lot of the details don't come through as clearly as they could. With a cleaner and m...

Sergio Curator on i really thought - Remix by davey, Anthony Orange · 5 months ago Declined

Good morning and thank you for sharing your work with us. The piece has a great feel and rhythm; the choral vocals create a pleasant and captivating soundscape. Our only suggestion is that the ending is somewhat abrupt and unnecessarily so. However, it differs...

Dominik Friedrich Curator on i really thought - Remix by davey, Anthony Orange · 5 months ago Declined

Very good voice and lyrical flow - love the small riffs and runs while still only using them tastefully and sparse enough. For my lists and taste the curse words a re a bit much though - I am not entirely against it but still feels a bit much. WHat I miss gene...

Endless Grooves Curator on i really thought - Remix by davey, Anthony Orange · 5 months ago Declined

Great songwriting and clarity in the vocal mix! But the arrangement and melody just didn't have enough development for my taste. Sorry but I will have to decline this submission.

Endless Grooves Curator on Pull His Jumper by Chris Portka · 5 months ago Declined

Loving the clarity of the drums in the mix as it emphasized the groove of the arrangement. But the track is too EDM sounding for the Lo-fi sound I am looking for. Apologies but I must pass for now.

ClubMafia Curator on Pull His Jumper by Chris Portka · 5 months ago Added
club mafia: house & techno · 3,376 followers

No written feedback with this decision.

omglooitsRaph Curator on Pull His Jumper by Chris Portka · 5 months ago Declined

Hi there Chris, thanks for sending in your music! Clean work on the production. I like the action going on in there but I do miss a little structure. I feel like there is a real build up missing. I am sure there is an audience for this though, but I do prefer...

Manuel A. Gonzalez Curator on Pull His Jumper by Chris Portka · 5 months ago Added
bass and drops · 1,608 followers

No written feedback with this decision.

Ken's Collection Curator on Pull His Jumper by Chris Portka · 5 months ago Declined

Hey Chris, hearing a unique production style on the track. However, I did feel that the distortion and saturation on this track is a bit over done. It's present almost the whole way through in pretty much all the instruments. I'll have to decline for now as th...

Simone Lorenzon Curator on Pull His Jumper by Chris Portka · 5 months ago Declined

Hello Chris Portka thank you for reaching out. An Interestimg production with some raw and deep sound design. Unfortunately the whole vibe of the track is too dark for my selection. I normally search for more dreamy and intimite tunes for both my playlists. I...

Simone Lorenzon Curator on Setting Sail Into the Mist by Tracy Sabin · 5 months ago Declined

Hello Tracy Sabin, thank you for sending this track. It is a really lovely work with some ironical touch and beautiful instruments and vibe. Unfortunately the track is pretty far away from my selection that is focused on deel electronica an Melodic House music...

Jens Van der Borght Curator on Pull His Jumper by Chris Portka · 5 months ago Declined

hey, Nice bassline in this one. I personally found the mix overcompressed and missing dynamcis and feeling too distorted because of this. I like a more polished mix for my list. lastly I focus less on vocals and mainly on melodic progression in the instruments...

Vibe Agency - Asia Curator on Pull His Jumper by Chris Portka · 5 months ago Declined

Hello! We appreciate your hard work on the production and creative synth layering. However it sounds a bit too dark and strong for softer and dreamier side of our "electronic rock/indie" playlist that we curate 🙏

Rushkeys Curator on Pull His Jumper by Chris Portka · 5 months ago Declined

Hey Chris, thank you for submitting your music! This is a great jam with a catchy groove, cool sound and expansive arrangement. Nice sound design, deep bassline, immersive vibe and punchy mixdown. I really dig the track and atmosphere you create with your musi...

Grubby Curator on Pull His Jumper by Chris Portka · 5 months ago Declined

Hey there Chris - thanks for the submission. Your track has a really unique sound and loads of energy. There are big issues with it though. The mix is so overloaded, it's distorting all over the place, which makes it very hard to listen to. I can hear that the...

The Skadoosh Curator on Pull His Jumper by Chris Portka · 5 months ago Declined

Hey Chris, thank you for sending your track our way. While we loved the chaotic vocal samples here, solid sound design. We just feel the track was too intense for any of our playlists. We will sadly have to skip this one. Keep making more music :)

How this board works

  • Every campaign here was posted with the artist's permission, chosen at checkout. Artists can switch it off from their dashboard at any time.
  • Campaigns are posted once every curator has replied, so no curator sees another's feedback while reviewing. We publish the full text, including declines.
  • Reviews an artist has disputed are hidden until resolved.
  • Placements are verified against Spotify. Follower counts are the latest we have for each playlist.

Your campaign could be next on the board.

New campaign Every curator replies with a decision and feedback · from $79