Every public campaign. Every curator's verdict.
Artists who opted in have their campaign posted here in full: which curators listened, who added the track, who declined, and exactly what they wrote. Artists and curators reply to each other in the open. Nothing is edited or cherry-picked.
No written feedback with this decision.
Hey DFalcon, I'm hearing a good arrangement on this track. Although this track's powerful mood is just a bit too emotional for the more relaxed atmosphere on the playlist. I'll have to decline for now because of this.
Hi and thank you for sharing your song with me! For this playlist I am mainly looking for soft and ethereal indie and dream pop with a distinct modern feel to it. Unfortunately I feel your song is not a match for this editorial line. I enjoyed the guitar melod...
No written feedback with this decision.
I really enjoyed the development of the arrangement! But the production, sadly, was a bit too pop rock sounding for the more indie and alternative rock sound of my curation. Apologies but I must decline this submission.
No written feedback with this decision.
Great energy and forward going energy, especially coming from the riff, which i like a lot. For my lists athough teh chords sound a b it too much repetitive and forseeable. I miss some more surprises in this regard. The vocal energy is great but also here I mi...
Hi Dfalcon! Truly sorry for declining this as I noticed that the mix of the bass and drums were a bit muddy. I’m actually looking to add tracks with low end depth in the bass and punchy kick that have impactful depth. Wishing you all the best!
A beautiful performance both vocally and instrumentally, achieving a captivating atmosphere thanks to its great sound and production quality. The proposal conveys sensitivity and good artistic taste in every detail. However, its serene and extremely delicate s...
Thanks for your submission. I can appreciate those nice guitar sounds. Great vocal. For me, I'm looking for something a bit more expansive with the chord progressions. I'm also looking for something more alternative with the sound as well. This is still a very...
The song boasts a very harmonious melody from beginning to end, making it quite pleasing. Its sounds, while still powerful, as is the singer's voice, are soft and emotive. The instrumentation never feels out of place, and the ending maintains the melody's cohe...
Hi, DFalcon! Thanks for sharing. The opening of your song sets the listener in a dreamy mood, and it really grabs attention. The guitar line is melodic and matches the delicate vocals. The singer performs each word with emotion, which adds a dramatic touch. Th...
Hi there, thank you for sharing your song! I think that the song had a nice instrumental well done with the feel that you have came up with, the bass guitar sounded pretty well put together, you are a good singer also, well done with the delivery. I think taht...
Hey there Stephen - thanks for the submission. Your track has a smooth sound, and a really traditional feel. There's a calming vibe and a solid, pleasant melody which feels like an old standard. However, it feels a little dated and mild for my playlists, and t...
Hey Stephen, the song’s pacing feels a bit uneven for the playlist’s steady rhythmic flow, so it sits apart from our current set. Your vocal pocket is warm and grounded and really sells the melody. I’m going to decline.
Thanks for your submission. I can appreciate the nice, raw energy of this track. Nice smooth vocal and guitar playing. For me, this track is much too chill for my playlists. It's also missing an alternative edge for my taste. Just my own opinion. Thanks and go...
the vocals sound so effortless here, i love that the entire production is centered around it, wonderful lyrics too. that being said, i have a rather hard time connecting with the catchier elements of the track, i’m sorry, regardless it’s such a clever song
Hey Stephen, the vocal delivery sits a bit too intimate for the playlist’s more kinetic cuts, but your melody carries real warmth and sincerity that feels honest and gentle. I’m going to decline this time, thanks.
I really like the song’s steady groove and how it draws you in, but the overall feel sits too mellow for the playlist’s brighter, more driving mix. I’m going to decline this time, thanks for sharing.
The intimate, low-key mood here is lovely but leans quieter than the playlist’s upbeat indie-electronic energy, so I’m going to pass this time. Your hook is warm and memorable, keep writing from that strength.
How this board works
- Every campaign here was posted with the artist's permission, chosen at checkout. Artists can switch it off from their dashboard at any time.
- Campaigns are posted once every curator has replied, so no curator sees another's feedback while reviewing. We publish the full text, including declines.
- Reviews an artist has disputed are hidden until resolved.
- Placements are verified against Spotify. Follower counts are the latest we have for each playlist.
Your campaign could be next on the board.