Every public campaign. Every curator's verdict.
Artists who opted in have their campaign posted here in full: which curators listened, who added the track, who declined, and exactly what they wrote. Artists and curators reply to each other in the open. Nothing is edited or cherry-picked.
While I enjoyed the groove of the drums in the arrangement, I find that the vocals just aren't cutting through the mix enough making it difficult to understand. Apologies but I will be passing on this submission.
Thanks for sharing this with me. I gave it a fair listen, but it isn't quite the right fit for my playlist. The overall mood felt a little too dark for the atmosphere I'm curating right now, so I'll have to pass on this one. Sorry I won't be adding it for now,...
No written feedback with this decision.
Thanks for your submission. I like the raw and organic nature of this one. The vocal is nice and the performances are solid. For me, I'm after something a little more alternative and edgy sounding with the production and song writing. Thanks and good luck with...
Hi The Danphes! Thanks for sharing this track. The dreamy and Sun-drenched feel in this arrangement sounds so exquisite. The washed out vocals blend smoothly with the guitar tones which I enjoyed. I’m stoked to add this track to my Surf Indie Rock playlist. I’...
this was a super Close decision as I really love the guitar picking, the melodic and polyphonic textures. they are super beautiful unique and captivating to me. the reason why I won't share the song is when the chords were just strummed Once the core shapes we...
Hello and thanks for sending me your music The Danphes! A nice and clean, soothing production. Good work! Those strings in there sound crisp, which I like. Your song is a bit too slow paced for me though, to be honest. I personally prefer more power in the voc...
Hello! We like that guitar layering and appreciate your careful of singing. However it has a bit slow tempo and feels a bit sad & moody, which doesn't fit well among other faster and upbeat/engaging rock songs that we prefer in our "rock legends" playlist 🙏
vocals are so very vibe inducing and endearing, song has that hazy summery vibe to it. that being said, i for whatever reason didn't connect with the general aesthetics of the sound design quite as much on this one, i'm sorry, totally a personal preference kin...
Hi there DFalcon and thank you for sharing your music! A nice and clean tune. Those strings sound crisp. Great work on the production. The pace is pretty slow and the soundtrack is soothing/relaxing at the start which is nice. The lyrics are pretty relatable s...
Hey there! That’s a nice aesthetically beautiful tune. Evokes the deepest melancholy in me. Distorted guitars create a great contrast in the chorus. Unfortunately, the vocal parts did not resonate enough with me. I’m really sorry. Your music is a wonderful pie...
Hey Two! Thanks for sending Crush my way. Nice 90's grungy overall feel to it, the amps on the guitar sound really gritty and dialed in. While I dig this track, This song is just more grungy/ garage rock than what I usually share on my ctrl + ALT + repeat play...
I appreciate the build up, the instrumentation and the balance of the mix. However, as I listened, the structure and overall feel of the track doesn't quite fit my current selection that leans more towards Indie Folk/Alternative Indie. That said, I'll have to...
Hey Two Spoons, While I can definitely appreciate your guitar sound design and interesting vocal plugins, I would have hoped for a faster tempo on the drums and rhythm section overall. This one here is too laid back for what I'm looking for, which is indeed a...
No written feedback with this decision.
While I enjoyed the quality of the sound selection in the production, the arrangement was a little too dark and rock sounding for the lighter indie sound of my curation. Sorry but I must decline this submission.
Thanks for sharing this with me. I appreciated the atmosphere and emotion behind the track, but the overall mood felt a little darker than the vibe I'm curating right now. I think adding a touch more warmth or contrast could help some of the song's beautiful m...
Hi Dfalcon! Nice to hear from you again! Appreciate you sending Just The Distance my way. Again, really strong Daughtry vibes coming from this one. While there's a lot to really like about this song, I typically go for tracks that are more raw from a mix stand...
No written feedback with this decision.
Hello there Two Spoons and thank you for submitting your music today! A nice and clean production. Those strings sound clean and the vocals sound crisp. I am sure there is an audience for this but for me this is a bit too slow paced where I prefer more energet...
How this board works
- Every campaign here was posted with the artist's permission, chosen at checkout. Artists can switch it off from their dashboard at any time.
- Campaigns are posted once every curator has replied, so no curator sees another's feedback while reviewing. We publish the full text, including declines.
- Reviews an artist has disputed are hidden until resolved.
- Placements are verified against Spotify. Follower counts are the latest we have for each playlist.
Your campaign could be next on the board.