Every public campaign. Every curator's verdict.
Artists who opted in have their campaign posted here in full: which curators listened, who added the track, who declined, and exactly what they wrote. Artists and curators reply to each other in the open. Nothing is edited or cherry-picked.
Opted-in campaigns in full: every curator's verdict and feedback, declines included.
I like the ideas, sounds, drum programming and creativity a lot. Your sounds and ideas are pretty good to hear but I feel like the processing and mixdown needs a lot of work done. Keep it up :)
Hi, this is a relaxing song with a confident rhythm. However the sounds production didn't convince me enough, and the vocal samples weren't to my taste. Thanks for your submission, and best of luck with the release!
https://open.spotify.com/playlist/2DfEA8cHwwml8vPfCksl1f?si=w4Sf4plGRJSHbK4b-FQdsw Decidì apoyar con una colocaciòn en el puesto 13.
Hello and thank you very much for sharing your song with us. Appreciate that. Great instrumental performance. We like the guitar and drums in particular. However, first of all the vocal melodies didn't catch our attention enough...additionally we think your tr...
Your track stands out for its strong sound quality and well-organized musical structure, reflecting a carefully crafted production. However, given the high standards I maintain for my curation, the way the vocals blend into the composition doesn’t fully convin...
Your track makes a strong impression from the very beginning, with a well-developed progression that creates an enjoyable atmosphere through its sound quality and musical structure. It’s clear that care has gone into the composition and the way the song unfold...
Hi, thank you for sending this track! I liked the intensity and the way the drums keep the song moving. The transition between the heavier sections felt a little bit abrupt for me personally. I was looking for a smoother connection between parts while keeping...
Hello again Echovayn, So for this track, I have the same concern as the last one: it's a fun rock song that has a bit too much pop inspiration on the vocal style, not to mention way too much processing on the vocals as well. I think the processing is gonna be...
Hi Divine Seven Official! Thank you for sharing this track with me.The rap flow is quite impactful which I enjoyed. I’m sorry for declining this track as I’m not connecting with the subdued drum mix. I’m actually looking for tracks where the drums have a more...
Apologies for declining this track for now. The vocal performance feels a bit too buried in the mix and it took a bit of an effort to focus on the lyrics because the instruments still clash with the vocals.
Hey Timothy and Erik, thanks for sending the track. Idea is very solid overall. Nice sound selection and mixing of elements, the melodic vibe is well achieved. Maybe a vocalwould have fit really good. Anyways the track has a lot of quality in the production. H...
Hey The Great Recycle, It's so easy to latch onto this Melody, I think it's a nice up-and-down arpeggio that changes on the last go of the verse. Nice job on creating a memorable line there. Now, for a rock sub, I would have been looking for a more aggressive...
Hey Year With A Ghost, Though this is a strong post hardcore or screamo inspired track, for a rock sub, what I'm really looking for is more of a classic rock approach on the instrumentation and vocals, stepping into a more traditional classic rock harmonies an...
No written feedback with this decision.
Thanks for sharing your track.The laidback pace and the spacious atmosphere makes it a realaxing and enjoyable track.The efforts put into layering and production are self evident.The track keeps its momentum and energy with the subtle transitions.However,as of...
I appreciate the opportunity to listen to your song. There are several different ideas within the arrangement, but they don’t always feel connected to one central direction. A more consistent approach to the production and song structure could make the final r...
Greetings! I quite enjoyed the drum groove as it matched and complemented the heavy metal style of the arrangement. This will be a great addition to my playlist. Thank you!
Hello! I will be declining your track because the quality of the mix didn't meet my standards. It sounds lacking in body. It sounds unclear and kind of brittle and hollow to me. I think it just needs more fullness but also aside from that I felt like the vocal...
Hey, de instrumentatie van dit liedje is tof en spreekt me zeker aan. De lyrics voelen voor mij alleen nog niet onderscheidend genoeg en ook in de delivery mis ik net dat beetje extra’s. Daarom besluit ik deze voor nu helaas te declinen. Groetjes!
Thanks for submitting this track. I was looking for a stronger sense of development as the song progressed, particularly in the transition toward its biggest section. The arrangement remains relatively similar throughout, so the later moments don’t feel as imp...
How this board works
- Every campaign here was posted with the artist's permission, chosen at checkout. Artists can switch it off from their dashboard at any time.
- Campaigns are posted once every curator has replied, so no curator sees another's feedback while reviewing. We publish the full text, including declines.
- Reviews an artist has disputed are hidden until resolved.
- Placements are verified against Spotify. Follower counts are the latest we have for each playlist.
Your campaign could be next on the board.