Every public campaign. Every curator's verdict.
Artists who opted in have their campaign posted here in full: which curators listened, who added the track, who declined, and exactly what they wrote. Artists and curators reply to each other in the open. Nothing is edited or cherry-picked.
Opted-in campaigns in full: every curator's verdict and feedback, declines included.
Marco Rohr Curator
on Serial Admirer by Timothy and the Apocalypse · 1 day ago
Declined
I think it's a solid production with some nice airy feel and interesting, almost experimental aspects. For my playlist though I am looking for songs with a stronger melodic hook. Best, Marco
Grubby Curator
on Mile Away by Year With A Ghost · 1 day ago
Added
Hey there, YWAG - thanks for the submission. I thought your track had a real brooding energy and a full sound. I liked the electronic elements - that gave it some extra texture. I thought there were lots of ideas in there. The vocal has good variation and expr...
Sounds of Riley Curator
on Black Bubblegum by The Danphes · 1 day ago
Added
Hey there! this is such a great song with a catchy chorus and incredible production. This would fit perfectly in my playlist. :)
Michiel Beijersbergen Curator
on Serial Admirer by Timothy and the Apocalypse · 1 day ago
Declined
Hi, thank you very much for sharing. Excellent sound design and very interesting to listen to, however it doesn't fit my more mainstream playlists. Therefore I politely decline this one.
Rave Sector Curator
on Serial Admirer by Timothy and the Apocalypse · 1 day ago
Added
Hey, Thx for sending your tune. Will add it to my NOCTYRA playlist. Feel free to share it with your audience.
New Peace Music Curator
on The Holy Weapon by Divine Seven Official · 1 day ago
Declined
What's good fam! Really nice track, it sounds well mixed, but for us right now its not a good fit because it's a bit dark for our rap playlist, we are looking for an uplifting jazzy sound. Sorry fam but we can not support on this one. Good luck with it.
omglooitsRaph Curator
on Mile Away by Year With A Ghost · 1 day ago
Declined
Hi there guys and thank you for sharing your song! Good work on the production, a very captivating and catchy tune, the soundtrack sounds great! The vocals I am not sure about though. There are a lot of vocal effects on there and this makes the vocals quite ha...
omglooitsRaph Curator
on The Holy Weapon by Divine Seven Official · 1 day ago
Declined
Hi there and thank you for sharing your music! Good work on the production, the soundtrack sounds great! I do constantly feel like listening to a long intro. There is no real drop and it feels like I am anticipating for something that is not really happening....
Varad Mulay Curator
on Serial Admirer by Timothy and the Apocalypse · 1 day ago
Declined
Thanks for sharing your track.The track starts energetically,and that's well maintained throughout the composition.The variations are good and befitting the composition.What I found interesting was the melodic layers.They have depth and are really unique .The...
Don's Tunes Curator
on Resilience - Remix by The Fairy Wrens, Hugh Middleton | Out With the In · 1 day ago
Declined
Hi! Thanks for the submission! I really like your expressive, emotional sound and the energy of the track but for my playlists I focus on a more classic blues / blues-rock style with a laid-back, bluesy mood. Keep it up!
Sebastian Wernke-Schmiesing Curator
on Color of the Sound (Gentle Metalcore) by DJ RiccoFX · 1 day ago
Declined
Hey, thanks so much for your submission. Unfortunately, your song was generated by AI. We're not interested in that. Sorry.
Sebastian Wernke-Schmiesing Curator
on Serial Admirer by Timothy and the Apocalypse · 1 day ago
Declined
Hi, thank you very much for the submission. It's a creative track. But for me, unfortunately, it's too experimental—not mainstream enough. I also don't hear any hit potential in the production. For that reason, I'm afraid I have to turn it down. I'm very sorry...
Anderson Júnior Curator
on Color of the Sound (Gentle Metalcore) by DJ RiccoFX · 1 day ago
Declined
Notamos que esse título traz uma explicação sobre as cores que representam um fogo que foi descoberto há milhões de anos. Apresentou boa estrutura musical e nesse trecho estrofe pela segunda vez notei algo diferenciado, onde o acompanhamento de guitarra faz to...
Simone Lorenzon Curator
on Color of the Sound (Retro Dubstep) by DJ RiccoFX · 1 day ago
Declined
Hello DJ RiccoFX thank you for sending this tune to me. The production quality is really good. I enjoyed especially the groove and the kind of downtempo break beat. Unfortunately I fell the vocals and the whole result a nit too pop and commercial for my person...
Simone Lorenzon Curator
on Serial Admirer by Timothy and the Apocalypse · 1 day ago
Added
No written feedback with this decision.
Tim Haverman Curator
on Color of the Sound (Gentle Metalcore) by DJ RiccoFX · 1 day ago
Declined
Thanks for sending your track my way. Even though this is obviously an AI song, it has some nice elements musically. If you continue down this path, the vocals need to be more "in the mix" instead of sitting on top. I would also strive to add more uniqueness t...
Indie Idiots Curator
on Black Bubblegum by The Danphes · 1 day ago
Declined
Genre wise this is close to the vibe of my playlists but feeling like the vocals bring this one more rock pop than indie. Thanks!
Indie Idiots Curator
on Rag Doll Arrival by Echovayn · 1 day ago
Declined
Nice vocals and strong production but a bit too straight ahead rock pop. Looking more for indie and alternative here.
Daniel Mena Curator
on Grave Reservations by The Friends of Norman Havelock · 1 day ago
Declined
Hey! Thanks for sending your music my way! There are quite a few attractive moments throughout this track, and I like how the different sounds bring creative details into the production. Some of those ideas stand out really nicely, giving the song an interesti...
Silverpalms music Curator
on Resilience - Remix by The Fairy Wrens, Hugh Middleton | Out With the In · 1 day ago
Declined
Hello The Fairy Wrens, Hugh Middleton, I appreciate the chance to review this track. I’m drawn to the soaring guitar solo and deep basslines. Unfortunately, I will decline because I’m not resonating with the muddy guitars, bass, and recessed drum mix. I’m focu...
How this board works
- Every campaign here was posted with the artist's permission, chosen at checkout. Artists can switch it off from their dashboard at any time.
- Campaigns are posted once every curator has replied, so no curator sees another's feedback while reviewing. We publish the full text, including declines.
- Reviews an artist has disputed are hidden until resolved.
- Placements are verified against Spotify. Follower counts are the latest we have for each playlist.
Your campaign could be next on the board.