Loading...
Campaign board

Every public campaign. Every curator's verdict.

Artists who opted in have their campaign posted here in full: which curators listened, who added the track, who declined, and exactly what they wrote. Artists and curators reply to each other in the open. Nothing is edited or cherry-picked.

Opted-in campaigns in full: every curator's verdict and feedback, declines included.

New campaign Every curator replies with a decision and feedback · from $79
8.5MFollowers across curator playlistsFollowers
1,614Verified curator playlistsPlaylists
70%Of replies are declines. Published, not hidden.Declines
11hMedian time to a curator replyReply time
100%Of replies shown in full, as writtenShown in full
A Analias Curator on Fearless and Surrender by James Johnson · 3 weeks ago Declined

Hey thanks for sharing with me! Great production and lyrics but sadly the vocals are AI generated and I'm looking for real ones. So sorry and I wish you all the best!

Jens Van der Borght Curator on Half Astronaut, Half Martian by Ronin 888 · 3 weeks ago Declined

Hey, Quality production. loved the low end in this one. The vocal is way too digitally sounding for us. we prefer vocals with less processing. Mainly just focus on raw rap vocals, more like Nas his music for example. Good luck on your musical journey Cheers, J...

Jens Van der Borght Curator on This Love Is A Fire by Jangle Wave · 3 weeks ago Declined

Hi, A confident vocal and good sounding groove in this one. Really well-made production. This song is however too upbeat and feels too energetic for the slow and mellow guitar vibe I am going for. Especially distorted guitars don't fit my playlist mood. Hope y...

Vibe Agency - Asia Curator on Half Astronaut, Half Martian by Ronin 888 · 3 weeks ago Declined

Hey there! We really enjoy that lead layering and smooth voice flow of yours throughout. However the overall vibe feels a bit sad and somewhat moody/nostalgic, especially with that deep tone of your rapping for our personal taste, which doesn't fit quite nice...

Vibe Agency - Asia Curator on Kingston Rise by Echovayn · 3 weeks ago Declined

Hey there! We like that voice sync along with instruments in your song. However the overall production is too hissing and squished for us personally, which doesn't fit quite nice among other much qualitative and cleaner songs that we usually feature in our 'su...

Grubby Curator on Half Astronaut, Half Martian by Ronin 888 · 3 weeks ago Declined

Hey there, Ronin 888 - thanks for the submission. your track has a crisp, bright sound and some nice atmospherics. The backing is quite simple - no bad thing - but I wanted a bit more variation or development as it does get a little repetitive after a while. T...

LSB RECORDS Curator on Half Astronaut, Half Martian by Ronin 888 · 3 weeks ago Added
Hip-hop Essentials · 1,873 followers

Thanks for the submission! I really enjoyed the track. The delivery feels confident, the flow is smooth, and the overall presentation comes together nicely. I like the energy and character you bring to the song. This is a great fit for my playlist, so I’m happ...

Matthew Lucky Curator on Half Astronaut, Half Martian by Ronin 888 · 3 weeks ago Added
Luiktunez|hip-hop,Rap&Trap · 2,366 followers

Really enjoyed this track. The overall sound feels polished, the production is clean, and the energy fits the playlist naturally. The vocals and delivery also work well with the instrumental. Happy to support this one.

Jelle Curator on Kingston Rise by Echovayn · 3 weeks ago Declined

Hi there thank you for sharing some of your tunes my way. Nice drums you have here a very functional groove with still enough variation to keep you listening to the song with interest. The character of the voice is a little less up my alley sadly but that migh...

Jelle Curator on Stolen Valor by Tony Frissore · 3 weeks ago Declined

Hi there thank you for sharing some of your tunes my way. Nice drums you have here , a very dynamic and organic flow running through the song. The choice of chords is a little less up my alley sadly but that might be me though. Other than that some creative el...

Rushkeys Curator on Half Astronaut, Half Martian by Ronin 888 · 3 weeks ago Declined

Hey Ronin 888, thanks for the submission. I enjoyed the smooth, dreamy atmosphere here - the laid-back flow gives the track an easy feel, and the production comes together nicely. Stylistically, though, my hip-hop selection is rooted more in classic old-school...

Pepijn Vermeulen Curator on Half Astronaut, Half Martian by Ronin 888 · 3 weeks ago Declined

Hi, thanks for sharing this track. I liked the vocal tone and the relaxed groove of the beat but the background elements felt a little subtle in some parts, and I was looking for a bit more texture to give the production some extra character. Wishing you all t...

Luke Bertoz Curator on This Love Is A Fire by Jangle Wave · 4 weeks ago Declined

Thanks for your submission. I can appreciate those epic guitar licks. Vocal sounds nice and has some nice melodies in there as well. I also like those chord changes in the bridge. In saying that, this track is too mainstream sounding for my playlist. I'm after...

Vibe Agency - Asia Curator on This Love Is A Fire by Jangle Wave · 4 weeks ago Declined

Hey there! We appreciate your voice sync along with guitars and drums. However your song feels a bit light and uplifting for us personally and the overall tempo is a bit slow for our taste, which doesn't fit quite nice among other faster and stronger engaging...

Vibe Agency - Asia Curator on Adrift by The Snowball Effect · 4 weeks ago Declined

Hey there! We really enjoy that synth layering and clean production in your track. However we don't have enough monthly listeners on our "ethereal ambient" playlist to give your track a proper-share there. And we usually place a little more ambient piano orien...

Vibe Agency - Asia Curator on Fearless and Surrender by James Johnson · 4 weeks ago Declined

Hey there! We like that female voice sync along with the beat and warm melodies. However the overall tone of singing feels a bit too sweet/sugary for us personally, which doesn't fit quite nice among other tracks with slightly faster pace and deeper/introspect...

Vibe Agency - Asia Curator on Stolen Valor by Tony Frissore · 4 weeks ago Declined

Hey there! We appreciate your hard work on the clean production and careful guitar arrangement along the beat. However your track feels a bit thoughtful and somewhat chill for us personally, which doesn't fit quite nice among other tracks with slightly upbeat...

VinylHoops Curator on This Love Is A Fire by Jangle Wave · 4 weeks ago Declined

Hi Jangle Wave, It's so easy to acknowledge that this is a fun track, I mean everything from the wailing guitars to the smooth, sort of Michael Bublé tinged pop vocals, all of it feels lovely. The first thing that I noticed, though, was that right from the beg...

Konstantin Curator on This Love Is A Fire by Jangle Wave · 4 weeks ago Declined

Hey there, thank you very much for sharing your new music with us! Cool old-school indie rock track in general. The melodies are engaging. However, we think the song would benefit from better mixing and mastering. The current mix sounds a little unbalanced and...

Audio Journey Playlists Curator on Adrift by The Snowball Effect · 4 weeks ago Declined

I appreciate the pads, the score-like feel and the calming textures the arrangement brought. However, as I listened, I was hoping for a bit more development in theme and phrasing. That said, I'll have to pass for now. Thank you for sharing your art. Wishing yo...

How this board works

  • Every campaign here was posted with the artist's permission, chosen at checkout. Artists can switch it off from their dashboard at any time.
  • Campaigns are posted once every curator has replied, so no curator sees another's feedback while reviewing. We publish the full text, including declines.
  • Reviews an artist has disputed are hidden until resolved.
  • Placements are verified against Spotify. Follower counts are the latest we have for each playlist.

Your campaign could be next on the board.

New campaign Every curator replies with a decision and feedback · from $79