Every public campaign. Every curator's verdict.
Artists who opted in have their campaign posted here in full: which curators listened, who added the track, who declined, and exactly what they wrote. Artists and curators reply to each other in the open. Nothing is edited or cherry-picked.
No written feedback with this decision.
I liked the clean vocal track, the straightforward arrangement and mix. However, as I listened, the structure and arrangement felt a bit static, and I was hoping for a bit more development. That said, I'll have to decline for now. Thank you for sharing your ar...
Hi and thank you for sharing your song with me! For this playlist I am mainly looking for soft and ethereal indie and dream pop with a distinct modern feel to it. Unfortunately I feel your song is not a match for this editorial line as it is too much "rock" an...
Hey DFalcon, While you have a lovely solo pop voice, for a pop sub, I'm looking for a strong upbeat acoustic performance overall - leaning into acoustic guitars and drums, while keeping the vocals clean and clear throughout. This track is missing the acoustic...
Thanks for sending your song. I think the track has a strong structure, and the rhythm, especially the rhythm, gives the song a nice concept to develop. There is a solid sense of direction in the production, and the arrangement feels carefully considered. I th...
Hi! Thanks for sending your track. I think the style you bring here is very interesting, and it works quite well with the rhythm. There are good interactions throughout the song, and the track has a base that feels attractive from the beginning. Maybe, I felt...
(I call it) Wildfire is a release that knows how to do its job well of entertaining and getting you moving from the very first moment. It's positive and fun and manages to connect thanks to a striking sound full of well-executed effects. But its consistent and...
Only Distance is a proposal that knows how to convey sensitivity through beautiful lyrics full of feelings and emotions. It comes across as careful in its textures thanks to a well-executed use of the synthesizer. However, although it is balanced and sincere,...
Hey, thank you so much for sharing your work here with us. I think the track manages to deliver a great atmosphere where the voice lands a pretty exciting performance. Good luck with your release and I hope we can connect again in a future opportunity.
This is a proposal with a remarkable vocal performance and excellent instrumentation. Together, these elements create an engaging and highly captivating atmosphere. I believe the production is outstanding, and the overall structure of the song is very well cra...
The instrumentation is very well crafted, and overall the track showcases strong sound design supported by high-quality production. You have also succeeded in creating an atmosphere that conveys positive energy and an enjoyable listening experience. However, w...
really love how full the sound is on the production end, vocals sound so effortless on here. it’s totally just me but i kinda wish the song packed a bigger and tighter punch, something that can sink its teeth in my mind, regardless it’s a super clever track
love that you retained the rawness of the instrumental lines, vocals are totally made for the radio. it really is a super clever track but the only one thing that’s a teensy bit lacking for me is the catchiness factor on the melody, i’m sorry
No written feedback with this decision.
Thanks for sharing this with me. I enjoyed the energy and there are some nice ideas throughout, but the guitar tone felt a bit too hard and forward for the vibe I'm trying to curate. I think a slightly warmer or smoother tone could help the song breathe and le...
Hey, this song has good vocals and guitar work, but the drums could be just a bit more cinematic during the final part. Work on this next time. For now, unfortunately, I'm declining. Best wishes!
Hey, Nice song that would work well live on stage. The screeching electric guitars and metallic vocals are less our style. The high end frequencies of the mix sounded too harsh and need taming. Overall we focus on more mellow and chill songs Wish you all the b...
Excellent development in the arrangement! But the mix was a little too processed for the more organic sound I am looking for. Sorry but I must decline this submission.
Cool sound selection in the production! But the arrangement is a little too far from the Lo-fi and Jazz Beats track of my curation. Sorry but I will have to decline this submission.
I like the classic rock tone of the drums in the production! However, I feel that the track was too retro sounding for the more indie and alternative rock sound of my curation. Apologies but I must decline this submission.
How this board works
- Every campaign here was posted with the artist's permission, chosen at checkout. Artists can switch it off from their dashboard at any time.
- Campaigns are posted once every curator has replied, so no curator sees another's feedback while reviewing. We publish the full text, including declines.
- Reviews an artist has disputed are hidden until resolved.
- Placements are verified against Spotify. Follower counts are the latest we have for each playlist.
Your campaign could be next on the board.