Every public campaign. Every curator's verdict.
Artists who opted in have their campaign posted here in full: which curators listened, who added the track, who declined, and exactly what they wrote. Artists and curators reply to each other in the open. Nothing is edited or cherry-picked.
Very grateful for the thoughtfulness behind this. The production on this came out well. The artistry and love put in this track really shines, but the overall pace feels a little more laid-back than the mood we generally feature. Best of luck with this release...
If 'Libre' is a future release where the instrumental is its greatest asset. I like the piano's contribution where it conveys emotions with total effectiveness and love for music. However, its linear and melancholic style differs from what I'm prioritizing for...
The track's got a solid melody and I love the warm piano tone in this track. Adding this to my playlist!
Hey SAMBOX, the track's cinematic pulse leans a bit restrained for the brighter, more immediate arc I curate, but that piano hook really lingers and feels handwritten. I’m going to decline this time, thanks for sending it.
Hi SAMBOX, thank you for sharing, but I'm sorry to say that the melody was not quite captivating for me as the structure of the melody was a bit unclear and it could use a bit more refining in the performance for it to sound a lot more smooth. Really sorry to...
Nice touch with the cinematic scope, though the mastering feels a touch compressed which flattens the dynamics. The piano motif has a warm, easy feel that stuck with me. I’ll decline this time, thanks for sharing.
Hello there! How are you doing today? Thanks a lot for your latest submission! Some nice piano melodies used in a good arrangement of this track. I'll have to pass for the simple reason I'm currently looking for piano songs with more ambient background texture...
The overall mood here drifts a bit toward somber and doesn't match the playlist's brighter cinematic arc, but your piano motif is memorable and tasteful. I'm going to decline this time, thanks for sending it.
Here's a polished English version with a professional curator tone: While the instrumentation is pleasant and the atmosphere showcases a strong artistic vision supported by quality production, I have decided to pass on the track at this time. I am currently pr...
No written feedback with this decision.
The textures feel a bit dense at times, which keeps the piano from opening up as much as it could. I like how focused the central motif is, it has real clarity. I’ll pass on adding it today.
No written feedback with this decision.
I like the tone of the vocals as it matched the instruments really well. But the track was too pop leaning for the indie folk sound I am looking for. Sorry but I must decline this submission.
Hey, thank you for sharing your music with us. I think the track manages to create an exciting vibe, and the rhythm brings a solid energy that keeps the song moving in a pleasant direction. There’s a good structure behind the concept, and the overall atmospher...
Hello! We like that guitar layering and appreciate your careful of singing. However it has a bit slow tempo and feels a bit sad & moody, which doesn't fit well among other faster and upbeat/engaging rock songs that we prefer in our "rock legends" playlist 🙏
I enjoyed the calm instrumentation, the steady groove and the prominent vocal track. However, though interesting, I was hoping for the mix to be balanced a bit more. Additionally, I'm currently seeking English spoken tracks. For these reasons, I'll have to dec...
Hey TKAT, I appreciated the unique and creative instrumental but unfortunately the vocals sounded a bit too processed for my liking and I'm afraid the melody didn't stand out in a very catchy way for me. I'm sorry to pass for now.
Hey TKAT/SARAH, love the unique production style/arrangement on this track and good vocal performance. Unfortunately, this track is not in English and will just stand out on the playlist as all the tracks are in English. I'll have to decline for now because of...
Hi, Nice guitar riff. It works together well with your vocal! For my playlist this song is however too upbeat. I am searching for slow guitar songs with a lot of instrumental parts and less focus on the vocal. Overlal this song felt quite hectic and intense fo...
No written feedback with this decision.
How this board works
- Every campaign here was posted with the artist's permission, chosen at checkout. Artists can switch it off from their dashboard at any time.
- Campaigns are posted once every curator has replied, so no curator sees another's feedback while reviewing. We publish the full text, including declines.
- Reviews an artist has disputed are hidden until resolved.
- Placements are verified against Spotify. Follower counts are the latest we have for each playlist.
Your campaign could be next on the board.